Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A reply to Tony Benn

Socialist Organiser nos. 405–406: Ireland: The Socialist Answer, 13 June 1989 · scan pp. 43–44 · about 758 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 43 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 43

Tony Benn has outlined a policy for ending the conflict in Northern Ireland in his Guardian column on 18 July 1983.

He wants to make the proposal for British withdrawal central to public debate in Britain. "For too long those who have so courageously advocated it have been denounced as if they supported terrorism," he says.

Benn's solution is this:

(1) Britain should set a date for withdrawal not more than two or three years ahead.

(2) The UN should be invited to send troops to replace those of Britain.

(3) A tripartite agreement should be negotiated - "including safeguarding of human rights" — between Britain, the Southern Irish state, and a "new Northern Ireland government"

(4) There should be an amnesty for prisoners "held under the emergency"

(5) Financial aid should be given to the new Northern Ireland government, equal to what is now spent on 'security' and the present British subsidies to Northern Ireland, for a five year period.

This is, essentially, the 'independent northern Ireland' policy long favoured by the Ulster Defence Association (UDA) and by one or two Catholic mavericks like former SDLP socialist Paddy Devlin. It begs questions that Benn does not even consider, let alone try to answer - and these are the decisive questions.

What would be the political system in an independent Northern Ireland? Majority rule? Rule by the Protestant majority artificially built into the state?

The references to 'guarantees' suggests that Benn's trend of thought would lead him to answer yes. The Catholics have no reason to believe such guarantees, and would fight on indefinitely rather than accept it.

They would be right to do so, for majority rule would be sectarian rule, whatever the guarantees. Though the British makes propaganda that the Six Counties are the democratic expression of the rights of the Protestant majority, in practice it refuses to let them exercise their majority. Why? Because there is no way that 'majority rule' in Northern Ireland could avoid being, or quickly becoming, Protestant sectarian rule. The British government knows it — and so do the Northern Ireland Catholics.

The 'independent Northern Ireland' policy is unviable because the Six Counties is not a stable entity - it would quickly dissolve into communal civil war. If the South could be kept out of it all the UN could hope to do would be to freeze the conflict at a certain point, as in the Lebanon.

The explosive communal eruptions in Ceylon, with its mass movement of people to their own 'safe' areas, shows us what would inevitably happen in an 'independent Northern Ireland' Benn hopes that proposals such as these and a British declaration that it was going "would force both communities in Northern Ireland to discuss how they could best cooperate to tackle the real problems of the province. These are mass unemployment, bad housing, poverty, inequality and social deprivation, the solutions to which require conciliation and political action, especially by the labour movement, that could override the sectarian hostilities that have been deliberately encouraged to divert people from the main tasks that have to be faced."

Sure, the ruling class in both Britain and Ireland encouraged and took advantage of the communal division: it is much deeper-rooted than that, though. The 'real problems' include the problem that — in social and political fact -shapes and conditions all others: the problem of the right to national self-determination of the majority of the Irish people, and how that Irish majority community will relate to the natural Irish minority, the Protestants of northeast Ulster.

To appeal to "bread and butter questions' as the 'real issue' - though where possible working class unity should be built even on this minimal basis - is to repeat the error of the 'socialism-is-theonly-answer' activists who were outflanked in Northern Ireland by the rising IRA at the beginning of the '70s. Militant is the heir of such politics for Ireland.

Another argument thrown in by Benn is that Britain sees a united Ireland as possibly posing a military threat. This is out of date by three decades and an epochal revolution in military technology (from battleships and World War I! aircraft to Cruise missiles).

In fact Benn's policy is an unjellable mix of the UDA, Militant and the Communist Party (Bill of Rights/ 'guarantees'). The UN presence would not jell it. Nothing could.

The solution is a united Ireland with, within it, as much autonomy for Ireland's natural minority (the Protestants) as is compatible with the rights of the majority.

Ireland

Scan page 44

The affa

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 405–406: Ireland: The Socialist Answer

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →