Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Tony Benn on Ireland

Socialist Organiser nos. 405–406: Ireland: The Socialist Answer, 13 June 1989 · scan pp. 42–43 · about 794 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 42 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 42

The time has come when British withdrawal from Northern Ireland must be moved to the centre of public debate. For too long those who have so courageously advocated it have been denounced as if they supported terrorism.

Yet it must be obvious to everybody that the present policy of military repression has failed, is failing, has no prospect of success and, in so far as it is intended to enforce partition, does not deserve to succeed.

Not only is the bitterness growing, along with the casualties, but the techniques for para-military policing and counterinsurgency are turning Northern Ireland into a police state, and those techniques are in danger of spreading to mainland Britain. Though there is massive media coverage of the violence, it is presented in such a way as to blank out any serious discussion of the alternatives.

vrkers' Parliament itself devotes a few hours every year to the procedures necessary to renew the emergency legislation, listens to ministerial statements that follow major incidents and debates, in a very low-key way, such administrative issues as fall to it to deal with under direct rule. My own experience of Cabinet is that the real choices do not even get properly discussed there.

There was a debate in full Cabinet in 1969 when troops were sent in; again, after the Birmingham pub bombing when the anti-terrorist legislation was brought forward, and we had reports on the Ulster workers' strike. But at no time was the option of withdrawal ever seriously considered. Even discussions of successive Labour manifestos were always hedged about with warnings that any commitment to withdrawal might cost lives — as if they were not being lost all the time.

I believe that one reason why Britain retains control is based on an analysis by the chiefs of staff that an independent and unified Ireland might constitute a defence threat, though this is never made explicit and is not a valid reason for staying there. Some confirmation of this may be drawn from the papers that have come to light recently, suggesting that during the last World War Winston Churchill himself was quite prepared to ignore the Ulster veto if the Dublin government would assist Britain in its war effort.

What we should be discussing now is the way in which Britain could break the deadlock by a clear statement of intention to withdraw.

and set a date — not more than two or three years ahead — by which time Britain would withdraw, leaving open the possibility of an earlier withdrawal if suitable arrangements could be made meanwhile.

Second, we should invite

Scan page 43

tions to send a peace-keeping force into the province to replace our troops and to sustain law and order until such a time as the new government could assume that responsibility.

Third, we should negotiate a tripartite agreement setting out a basis for future relations between Britain, the Republic and a new Northern Ireland government, including safeguarding of human rights.

Fourth, we should declare an amnesty for prisoners held under the emergency.

Fifth, we should offer financial aid to the new government equal to the present contributions to Northern Ireland plus the costs of the emergency, for a five-year period, to be renegotiated thereafter on an annual basis for a further fixed period.

The very fact that such an alternative was being seriously considered by Britain would force both communities in Northern Ireland to discuss how they could best cooperate to tackle the real problems of the province. These are mass unemployment, bad housing, poverty, inequality and social deprivation, the solution to which require reconciliation and political action, especially by the labour movement, that could over-ride the sectarian hostilities that have been deliberately encouraged to divert people from the main tasks that need to be faced.

No-one can be sure that a policy along these lines would succeed, but there would certainly be massive support for it in Britain and the Republic. The people in the North, once they realised that we were in earnest, would then have a chance to build a future for themselves and their children, free from the unending prospect of further violence that now seems inevitable. • It sometimes appears as if Britain is an excuse that can be used to postpone consideration of what so many people in the province Thi know must be done sooner or later. A clear statement of our intention would strip away that: excuse, end an ancient injustice perpetrated by Britain on the Irish people over many centuries, and open up possibilities for cooperation that for the moment seems totally beyond our reach.

The Guardian, 18 July

----- pull-quotes -----

The Socialist Answer

First, we should legislate to terminate Her Majesty's jurisdiction in Northern Ireland"

The Socialist

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 405–406: Ireland: The Socialist Answer

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →