Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Labour's 'unity by consent'

Socialist Organiser nos. 405–406: Ireland: The Socialist Answer, 13 June 1989 · scan pp. 40–42 · about 3,336 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 40 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 40

and John O'Mahony interviewed Clive Soley for Socialist Organi in February 1983 At the time, Clive Soley was deputy spokesperson on Northern Ireland Can you outline the Labour Party for us, as it stands now?

The first think Labour would do on gaining power would be to give a clear commitment to a united Ireland by consent.

Why consent? First of all, we prefer to govern by consent, obviously. But, secondly, and this is very important, the population of Ireland is five million. Of those five million, one and a half million live in Northern Ireland. Of that 1½ million, one million, to a greater or lesser extent, support the Unionist cause. And to try to force one million to join the other four million without their consent would be a recipe for disaster.

I don't think a united Irish government would be well equipped, particularly in the early days, to cope with the problems that would come from that. But what consent must not mean is a veto on political progress. We would legislate in a way that would lead people to the conclusion that a united Ireland was in their best interests.

The sort of things I would like to see us consider, and I think we would consider, would be measures like joint citizenship, joint voting rights, the ability to vote and stand in each other's elections, very close harmonisation, so that the Unionist won't feel trapped in a united Ireland - so that he knows that if he chooses to he can travel on a British passport or an Irish passport, he can vote in British elections, he can vote in Irish elections and, I would hope, could stand in elections on both sides too.

I think we would be looking very quickly for a major effort to harmonise various matters on the economy, social 'orkers' and south of the Border. I believe the Border has distorted the economies of both North and South alike. One of the things I would want to consider very urgently • would be an all-Ireland Economic Development Council. I'd also like to look at some form of all-Ireland council, or a sort of British-Irish council - with elected representatives from the North and the South, and possibly from Britain.

We'd want to consider an all-Ireland police force, recruited - and I emphasise this — from both sides of the Border, trained in a common training school, with a common sense of identity.

I would say to people who are worried about an all-Ireland police force that unless you do consider things like that, then frankly you are not serious about a united Ireland. At the end of the day, there has to be a police force that can cross that border, and it's an important step forward.

There's a whole range of factors of that sort which we'd want to consider. Do you see withdrawal of troops as an objective of Labour Party policy?

The aim should be troops back to barracks as soon as possible. That is actually happening, but slowly. We want to continue it as quickly as possible.

I'm not a Troops Out man, nor am for setting dates for British withdrawal. I see a policy of British withdrawal trom Ireland as opposed to a policy for a united Ireland. It does not follow that if we withdraw our troops then you will have a united Ireland.

We all know that some unionists are prepared to fight for an independent Northern Ireland. I don't think it would work, but I do know that plenty of them are prepared to fight for it.

Therefore my view is that policies that are designed simply to get Britain out don't provide a solution. They simply get Britain out, which might be nice for us but doesn't solve the problem. Can I put to you a view of what the last Labour government did? You have a situation where the government balances between the Protestants and Catholics. The Labour government capitulated to the Orange general strike in May 1974. I think it simply let its strategy (powersharing and a Council of Ireland) be wiped out. Then it swung in the opposite direction and, after he succeeded Merlyn Rees, Mason adopted a policy that was essentially one of beating down the Catholics. There is a lot of evidence of very widespread searches of thousands of Catholic homes. It amounted to terrorisation. It was basically a policy of holding the ring, doing nothing, sweating it out — immediately after buckling under the pressure of the Orange strike. That's what happened.

I understand that view. Can I say how see it? I wasn't involved in the politics of Ireland until I came into this House in 1979. I always felt there should be a united Ireland. Then when the civil rights movement came along in the late 1960s I got very excited. I thought there was a good chance of real political and economic progress by peaceful means.

I think the destruction of that civil rights movement was a crucial step. A lot of people have got a lot to answer for. The main people are the Stormont government, and then the paramilitaries on both sides of the divide over there.

Because,_leaving aside the obvious things the Loyalists and the Stormont government did, the other thing that happened is that the IRA, as it then was, recognised that the initial popularity of the British troops could not be allowed to continue. So they started their policy of shooting at British forces.

But why do you think the civil rights movement of the late 1960s turned into the armed offensive led by the IRA?

I think the civil rights movement was a threat to the paramilitary groups on both sides. Certainly it was a massive threat to the Stormont government and the Loyalists generally. There is no doubt in my mind that a whole lot of people who had a very fixed view of how they saw things developing, thinking they represented their particular group, set out to destroy the movement. The IRA scarcely existed in 1969.

Well, it existed all right, and it existed enough to do the damage by turning on the British troops.

The Provisionals emerged at the end of 1969 as part of a reaction against the fact that over the previous seven years there had been an evolution towards peaceful methods by the old IRA. They were involved in the civil rights agitation. They had no guns, or scarcely any, during the pogroms of 1969. The IRA didn't, in fact...

I'm quite prepared to accept that you know more about the IRA than I do. I wasn't deeply involved. But I put it to you that there was an effort to alienate the minority community from the British presence there when the troops were first brought in. Is that not correct? I doubt it — not at first. I could, for example, tell you in detail about how the British army was allowed into Catholic Free Derry, and the protective barricades (erected in August 1969) voluntarily taken down, in October 1969. It was actually organised by the Republicans. Later the IRA split and things changed. But can I put the point in a different way? It seems to me that there was an absolutely necessary political logic in the development from civil rights to the IRA offensive, in that the basic civil right that the Catholics lacked was the right of self-determination.

Right.

Scan page 41

The whole logic of the struggle for limited objectives led to a Protestant backlash, which in turn pushed the Catholics, in fear and terror, towards self-defence, and then boosted those who wanted to go on an armed offensive, after the IRA split. That takes us back to what you said about waiting for a majority in the Northern state. The point is that it has been artificially caryed out — very artificially. 35% of the population are opposed to the state's existence. Over the past 15 years, in fact from before the violent phase, when it was a question of Britain putting pressure to reform on the old Orange state, the central problem has been that the state was deliberately designed to give a permanent Protestant majority. It was not reformable. Yet you are committed to remaining within the narrow limitations of a state which has a built-in Protestant sectarian majority.

These are very important points, and I recognise the logic of what you have said. I'd go along with quite a bit of it. I'd have reservations about some of it. What I would stress to you is that the key to this is having the political skill and determination to go through with the political, social, economic and institutional changes regardless of opposition from the Unionist group.

I don't mean rough-riding over them. I am saying that we would not accept that they had a veto - for example, on setting up an all-Ireland Economic Development Council, or an all-Ireland police force, and a whole host of other things of that nature.

If you do that, you are saying something you've never said before to the unionists: it's not just that we want to get things better in Northern Ireland. We are saying to you that we don't want you in the UK any more, we want you in a united Ireland. That is a very different message going out to the Unionists than has gone out before.

I don't think you can assume that all Unionists are hard-liners who will fight in the last ditch. Obviously there are lots of those. They keep making their presence felt. But there are also a lot of them saying things that they would not have said even five years ago, let alone ten. 'Well, we can't go on as we are, can we?' for example. That's a very significant change.

I think you could not coerce the Unionists. Quite certainly you would have to have a federal Ireland and give them rights over their own affairs. The thing is that a British Labour government could create the political conditions for change by a declaration of intent to withdraw; by really energetic determination to change the whole structure and framework to make some form of a united Ireland realistic polities for the Protestants - give them options where they would have an incentive to accept change.

I haven't ruled out any of that. But if you start by accepting the majority's rights within the artificial entity, then you are in fact saying to them: ‹We'll always let you veto us' No, I'm not saying that at all. All I'm sayıng, very clearly, is that what we'll do first is have talks with the Dublin government - whatever government it happens to be — to set up new economic and social institutions, and we do not allow them to veto that.

I've already indicated that, obviously, governments can get pressurised and deflected if the pressure is strong enough. That's where the political skill comes in.

There would be a major effort not to allow any group or any individual to veto those things that were agreed by London and Dublin. In effect what I'm saying is: yes, we are giving a strong commitment to get out. We are not setting a date. I think, as I've said, a commitment to getting out is not a policy for a united Ireland — it might be that the real policy is to have a commitment to a united Ireland, and that's what I'm saying. You yourself say we can't do it by coercion. Therefore we have got to do it by consent. But you don't allow them to veto the political progress.

How would a new Labour treat the Catholics?

Better.

For example, it was a Tory government which granted political status as part of an attempt to find a new solution after Bloody Sunday (when 13 unarmed men were shot dead in Derry, on 30 January 1972). A Labour government took it away. You still seem to be committed to a policy that would involve a continual harassment of a big section of the Catholic population.

I would hope things like the Prevention of Terrorism Act can go, and that we would have a major review of the Emergency Provisions Act. I would want to have a whole look at human rights issues there, like the delay in getting death certificates and coroners' reports on children killed by plastic bullets, and all sorts of other things like that.

That won't come about quickly. The Catholics, for very understandable reasons, don't trust the security forces, and it's very difficult to change that quickly. I mean, I'd like to change it tomorrow morning.

We'll make the forces be seen and felt to be totally impartial. I haven't got a magic wand that would do that. I have got a number of things in my mind, including an all-Ireland police force, that would help do that. But not overnight, I fear.

What do you feel about restoring political status to Republican prisoners?

I would not give political status. I've always been very opposed to political status, not least because as an exprobation officer I very strongly take the view that if you decide to lock people up for whatever reason then you should treat them equally, except on the grounds of security (ie. a burglar doesn't get the same sort of security as a mass murderer).

I think it is wrong in principle. The only justification for it would be under the Geneva Convention on prisoners of The war, in which case you have got to have two states that have declared war on each other, both sides wearing recognisable uniforms.

One of the most dangerous things about political status for nationalists is that you also give it to Loyalists. It you do that, and you then have a united Ireland, you hand over a large number of Loyalist prisoners of war to the new state, which is the surest way I know of saying to the Loyalist people - you have a legitimate fight, you are entitled to prisoner of war status too, you have got it, and make sure you keep it.

I know that the Unionists will be prepared to fight and kill and die themselves for their cause, as are the Nationalists at present.

But you accept that the Catholics have been oppressed terribly for 60 years at least. On what definition are the IRA straightforward criminals?

They're not. Of course they're political, I'm not disputing that for a moment. But if we lock them up, that doesn't mean that they should be treated differently.

You are saying that an ordinary criminal should be treated worse. As a penal reformer I reject that strongly. There is no reason why a so-called common criminal - personally I find the phrase very offensive - should be treated worse than you who committed your act for political reasons.

Secondly, what's political? If you are a young black in this country, you lee. the police don't defend you, and you take out a brick in your pocket to defend yourself — is that political or not? I would argue it is political.

So would I.

Someone who goes around shoplifting and says, 'I don't like the present structure of society in capitalism', is political. You're mixing up two questions, though. I'd be in favour of penal reform, and of recognising the political dimension in the case of the young black or the unemployed person shoplifting. But there is a qualitative difference between the political element in these things and the political army of an admittedly oppressed community, with grievances which — you admit — pose a united Ireland as the only solution, even it you disagree with their methods.

That's not a reason for treating them differently. And certainly no reason for treating them better - which is the request.

They are soldiers.

If they are soldiers, then prisoner-ofwar status comes from a very specific Workers' ireland 39

Scan page 42

The agreement. It is the Geneva agreement, which covers two states at war, and wearing a uniform when you are in combat. It's a dangerous policy because at the end of the day you'll wind up with a Loyalist prisoner-of-war camp in a united Ireland. If you want that, OK. But it's dangerous.

The Geneva Convention in its details is a product of established governments. We are talking about an oppressed people and their guerilla army, which does not wear a uniform because it is outnumbered and so on. But they are soldiers.

By that definition, anyone who is fighting the British state as such, including the Tartan Army in Scotland and the Welsh arsonists and the Angry Brigade, are soldiers. We give them political status, do we? What sort of status would you give them and why treat them better?

I think you are using the whole business abut penal reform to obseure the qualitative difference. For example, the Catholics in 1969 did not have guns. The IRA offensive grew out of the civil rights movement in reaction to the Protestant backlash and the pogroms. Your picture about how the armed conflict developed is somewhat askew, because one of the earliest events was the British curfew in the Falls just after the Heath government was elected, in July 1970 — before the IRA offensive got under way. The whole chronology of how it developed shows that the IRA began as the defensive militia of the Catholic community.

I think that people who pursue this line are, not intentionally, betraying socialist values. There is no reason to argue that peopole who are less articulate - the vast majority in your prisons are working class people -don't in fact have political motives for waht they do. Some of them act as organised groups like the Provisionals do. But that does not justify unequal treatment. If you want specific prisoner of war status, then two things follow: one, you must accept prisoner of war rules and regulations under the Geneva Convention; two, to my mind more importantly, you must give PoW status to Loyalists too. You must take on board that you will hand over to a united Ireland political prisoners of war and you are virtually saying to the rest of the Unionist population that this legitimises their fight against the new Irish state. Isn't that the distant, or mid-distant future?

I don't think so. I'm working as fast as possible on this programme. Although I'm not setting dates, I'm not writing it off as some distant future aim. You are using the 'Unionist PoWs' argument and the political element in ordinary so-called criminal activity to obscure the actual Provisional IRA is pressed people.

I've been working for good treatment in prisons for donkeys years - but 1 want it for everyone, not just one group. So you're in favour of a blanket reform in prisons?

Yes. One of my positions from early on in the hunger and dirty protests was that if we had made such reforms, we would have had no problem - the five demands would have been met. So your policy in Northern Ireland will be to bring in a complete prison reform to include all sorts of rights for political and other prisoners?

In fact Northern Ireland prisons are better than the ones here, which are appalling. If we could do more to liberalise prisons, I'd be very happy.

You will in effect grant political status to all 'ordinary criminals' in Northern Ireland?

No. You are twisting my words. I'm saying I want good conditions for prisoners, and I'm not prepared to distinguish as to why a person committed an offense or not.

You are evading the actual point.

I don't think so, but we'll have leave it there.

Thank you very

----- pull-quotes -----

factors, and political institutions north The Socialist

The Socialist

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 405–406: Ireland: The Socialist Answer

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →