How to argue for troops out
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-06-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 35 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 35
Geoff Bell wrote this polemic in response to a report in Socialist Organiser on a Labour Party conference debate on Troops Out. The report argued that the left ha lost not only the debate but also tl argument, because it failed to answer the objections of the rightwing or to explain how troops out could lead to a positive solution.
Socialist Organiser of 17 October 1985 gave over three pages to attacking myself and three other movers and seconders of the resolutions on Ireland ference.
In replying to this, the first admission I would make is that I am somewhat dubious about doing so. I find it rather difficult to take seriously John O'Mahony's 'review' of the Irish debate at conference. It is reminiscent of those old stories about theatre reviews written by someone who spent the entire performance of the play in the theatre bar. Like John O'Mahony, that reviewer may have read the script and O'Mahony reproduced ours at great length — but there are more to plays than the script. And there is more to debates at Labour Party conference than what is actually said in speeches.
However, let me begin by questioning O'Mahony's methodology. In asking why, or rather asserting that, "the Troops Out current still counts for little in our movement" he says that those who . seek an explanation for this can begin by looking at the debate at conference and at the weak argument put over by those who made speeches there.
This is a very silly suggestion. The movers of the resolutions have five minutes each, the seconders and other Workerg' Ireland 33
Scan page 36
The loft speakers three minutes. To expect any individual to make a detailed, theoretically-sound, answering-allpossible-objections-that-might-be-raised type of speech in that time is absurd. This is especially the case when the issue concerned is Northern Ireland: an issue continually distorted or neglected by the ruling class press and the labour bureaucracy. No, all we can do when speaking to resolutions on Ireland at the party conference is hope to make a couple of polemical points, correct one or two misapprehensions and supply the odd bit of information which perhaps, just perhaps, may start the odd delegate thinking afresh about the Irish issue.
These may appear modest intentions, but I do suggest that John O'Mahony is rather naive if he believes that it is speeches at Labour Party conferences which win or lose debates there. As I am sure he knows, the vast majority of votes are decided beforehand at caucus meetings of the unions. What informs their discussion on Ireland I will discuss shortly, but to give over three pages of Socialist Organiser to discussing four or five speeches of a few minutes each is to elevate the importance of those, and the possible effect they could have, to a level they do not warrant.
But if John O'Mahony wishes to do that, at least let him get off his metaphorical theatre bar stool, buy a programme and see what the play was called. The basis of his attack on us was to insist "the single slogan "Troops Out' needs to be replaced by a broader agitation which would make "Troops Out' one element in a coherent programme." I agree, as 1 am sure do the other delegates O'Mahony attacked. And that is why, totally contrary to the impression given by Socialist Organiser, the resolutions we moved and seconded went way, way beyond "Troops Out' O'Mahony wants "a coherent programme". So do we, which is why in the resolution I moved we called not just for withdrawal within the lifetime of the next Labour government, as Socialist Organiser reported, but also for the British withdrawa Cailed ooherent British withdrawal" programme" or a "detailed policy", it matters little: what does matter is they amount to the same thing.
Certainly we did not detail this policy or programme, although the second resolution mentioned some possible components of it - the ending of the PTA, plastic bullets and strip searching - but what we did do, in the wording of our resolutions, was to suggest that the working out of this policy/ programme Socialist Workers' was of such importance that we needed a wide-ranging discussion within the labour movement to flesh it out. That is what the resolutions called for, and for John O'Mahony to try and parade us as Troops Out simpletons is a sectarian distortion.
And, if I may, I will add a personal note here. John'is kind enough to say in his article that I have written some "useful works" on Ireland. For that, thank you, but if he had read one of those works a little more closely — "The British in Ireland' — he would know that in the conclusion I argue for and detail a coherent programme for British withdrawal.
The Labour Committee on Ireland also argue the importance of establishing a programme for withdrawal. All of which underlines the importance of not jumping to too many polemical conclusions on the basis of what is said in a couple of minutes of speechifying at Labour Party conferences. As to the quality of those speeches which O'Mahony seeks to denigrate, that is, of course, a matter of opinion. In the opinion of the Irish Post, for instance, "the Irish case was put most eloquently at Bournemouth — the best ever presentation and all who spoke in favour of those resolutions must be warmly congratulated."
Now the Irish Post may not possess the theoretical wisdom or Marxist analysis of Socialist Organiser, but there is one reason for taking its views a good deal more seriously than those of O'Mahony: its coverage of the Irish debate at conference concentrated on attacking the disgraceful, incoherent performance of Alex Kitson, the spokesperson for the NEC.
That, for me, was a much more important target — the target of the labour bureaucracy who historically and presently must share the responsibility for British misrule in Ireland - than that of their left critics such as myself and the others who spoke in the debate in favour of ending that British misrule.
Mention of the labour bureaucracy raises a further point concerning the debate in the trade unions in Ireland and the relationship of this to discussions in the Labour Party. When O' Mahony asked: "Why is the Troops-out-ofIreland current so feeble in the British labour movement?" he was not only mistaken in characterising us as simply "Troops Out', , he was also wrong in his assessment of our strength.
Within the last four or five years we have won the party to supporting, on paper, Irish unity; securea promises to repeal the PTA and stop the use of plastic bullets; and defeated the NEC on the ending of the jury-less courts and strip-searching. Support for our positions in the CLPs has also ensured that Ireland has been debated at conference for the last five years.
I would also argue that we now have the majority, if not overwhelming, support in the CLPs in support of British withdrawal. Where we lack support is in the trade unions, and it is their block vote which has consistently ensured our withdrawal motions are lost.
Why have the unions adopted this attitude? Is it because, as John O'Mahony suggests, the trade union delegations at conference are worried about the prospect of a blood-bath if Britain leaves? They may be worried about this, and certainly the question of the blood-bath needs serious discussion, but to suggest this is what informs the unions' opposition — or that of the NEC — to British withdrawal is to acribe to these union bureaucrats — as many of them are — a degree of concern and compassion for the poor Irish Catholics of which, quite frankly, there is as much evidence as there is of snow in hell.
No, as any half-decent materialist analysis would recognise, the reason the union leaderships are hostile to British withdrawal is because of their membership in Northern Ireland, the vast majority of whom are loyalists and who would quite likely leave their unions if they believed their leaderships • were voting for pro-Republican resolutions at Labour Party conferences.
Add to that fact the unions' local leaderships in Northern Ireland have, in some instances, been themselves accused of operating discrimination against Catholics by the Fair Employment Agency, and you begin to get a materialist explanation for the unions' attitudes towards Northern Ireland, rather than some idealistic notion that it is all in people's heads and if we put the right argument over we will win the With that in mind, let me just conclude by making a couple of remarks as to how we can help to change this situation. The work of building up support for British withdrawal from Ireland within the rank and file of the unions is an obvious priority, and one way in which, in future, the material interests of the bureaucracy could be negated. And we are all agreed that to win that support means going beyond Troops Out Now.
Where the real dispute lies, I suspect, is just exactly where do we go? For myself, the guiding political principle is that socialists insist that British withdrawal from Ireland is unconditional. To spell this out, neither the British government, the Labour Party conference nor even Socialist Organiser can place conditions on British withdrawal. The principle of self-determination means that they have no right to insist that the Irish construct their state in this or that way before Britain leaves.
That is why I object to John O'Mahony's practice — both in this article and others - of coupling British withdrawal with the advocacy of a federal Ireland in which there would be considerable autonomy for the Protestant North. I have no intention of entering into this argument here because I do not accept the prime responsibility of British socialists at this stage in the Irish struggle is to sit around and commentate on debates at Labour Party conferences one day and construct constitutional arrangements by Ireland will be governed the next.
Scan page 37
Our job is to work for British withdrawal from Ireland. In the course of that work we can suggest ways and means of lessening the threat of a bloodbath — for instance, the disbandment and disarming of the UDR - and we can include these measures in a wider and more detailed programme for British withdrawal.
That, however, is an entirely different process than the Irish priority Socialist Organiser has chosen to adopt in the last couple of years — arguing in Britain for a Federal Ireland.
It all conjures up an amusing vision: we win the debate in the Labour Party; a socialist government prepares to withdraw from Ireland; John O'Mahony parades up and down Whitehall with the banner 'Troops Must Stay Until Protestant Rights Are Secured'.
This, of course, is a caricature. The point I am making is that, for me, any theoretical discussion on the nature of loyalism which we in Britain have is best placed in the context of advocacy for unconditional British withdrawal. Once that context is agreed, then perhaps we can get away from both the type of 'reportage' Socialist Organiser used for the Irish debate at conference and the type of reply which was necessitated by that reportage.
John O'Mahony replied D others whose speeches at id I "attack" Geoff Bell and Labour Party conference I summarised and commented upon in SO 248? Certainly I criticised them pretty severely, and I suppose I was a bit unkind to Sarah Roelofs, whose writings on Ireland in Labour Briefing sum up for me much of what's wrong with much of the left. But to disagree is not necessarily to "attack". I consider myself to be on the same side as those who spoke for Troops Out at Labour Party conference.
I presented full summaries of the speeches in order to avoid giving the impression of trigger-happy factional sniping and to give readers the chance to form an independent judgement: 1 solicited Geoff Bell's present reply because I believe a serious debate within the left on the question of Ireland is one of the most urgent tasks we have to tackle.
Unfortunately Geoff Bell declines to discuss most of what I wrote. Having summarised and critically analysed the arguments used by advocates of Troops Out, I concluded that: ...The left lost the argument at this year's Labour Party conference. With the partial exception of Geoff Bell the left did not even seriously attempt to answer the arguments" (emphasis added). Was 1 right or wrong?
Geoff Bell is of course right that there is more to the Labour Party conference 'play' than the mere script, the speeches, alone embodies or can convey. The pressures and vested interests of the outside world overshadow the debates, giving their precise meaning and weight to the sentiments and ideas expressed there and sometimes predetermining the vote without regard to the speeches and arguments that emerge at conference.
Geoff is right that it is a weakness in my account of the debate that I didn't underline and bring out the significance of Kitson's reference (which I cited) to the TGWU's 200,000 Irish members. But my subject was the script, ie. the arguments. The absence of comment on the trade union bureaucracy's vested interest not to upset the status quo is a weakness in my article, but not a decisive one unless you want to say that the arguments are irrelevant.
I itemised the three arguments on which the opponents of Troops Out base themselves: "(1): That British withdrawal would be followed immediately by sectarian civil war, and therefore, (2): Troops Out leads not to a united Ireland but to bloody repartition and two Irish states; and (3): That Northern Ireland is some sort of legitimate expression of the rights of the Protestant community, which can only be changed fundamentally with their consent."
My summary of all the points made by the speakers established the remarkable fact that only one left-winger even attempted to deal with any of these arguments — Geoff Bell took up the bloodbath argument. The rest of the arguments were not touched at all by any of the left speakers. That was the most striking feature of the debate — they didn't try to argue. In terms of the arguments it was almost a non-debate because the left simply defaulted on the arguments.
If I'd seized on this or that hasty speech and said the equivalent of: "It is no accident, comrades, that comrade X in his speech about rate rises in Tower Hamlets neglected to deal with the class character of the Communist Parties of Cuba and Outer Mongolia" - then that would be very unreasonable. But what happened in the conference debates needs an explanation.
Because movers of the resolutions have only five minutes, says Geoff Bell, and seconders only three, "to expect any individual to make a detailed, theoretically sound, answering-allpossible-objections-that-might-be-raised type of speech in that time is absurd." Moreover, though "the question of the bloodbath needs serious discussion" "any half-decent materialist analysis would recognise (that) the reason the union leaderships are hostile to British The withdrawal is because of their membership in Northern Ireland, the vast majority of whom are Loyalists and who would quite likely leave their unions if they believed their leaderships were voting pro-Republican resolutions at Labour Party • conference. (This suggests) a materialistic explanation for the unions' attitude towards Northern Ireland rather than some idealistic notion that it is all in people's heads and if we put the right argument over we will win the debate."
So the arguments don't matter? Or anyway not very much? But the arguments do matter — and if they don't, why write articles and books, why bother to make speeches at all? The arguments had an importance outside the 'theatre' of the conference - they went out live on two TV channels.
Was five minutes not enough? That wouldn't explain the virtual absence of even attempts — rushed and garbled as they might have to be in the circumstances — to take up the arguments. Nor does it explain the fact that in an article of about 1800 words — which can't be much less than the 'comment' part of my article — Geoff Bell still doesn't attempt to answer any of the points. Perhaps our disagreement then, is about what the arguments in the movement are! Well then, what are they!
In fact, Geoff Bell's position seems to be not that the arguments don't matter, nor that they are different from what I stated, but that we don't have the right to discuss such issues. Neither the British labour movement nor British Marxists (nor - in my own case — Irish Marxists who live in Britain) have any right to discuss the issues. Our political rights can go no further than the right to repeat, as often as we can muster the energy and conviction, the single relevant slogan, Troops Out Now, with no qualifications.
I must have expressed myself badly, because Geoff Bell has not taken on board the main point I made, about the Reed for seeing Troops Out as one element in a coherent programme. His response is "that the resolution we moved and seconded went way, way beyond Troops Out...the resolution I moved... called not just for withdrawal in the lifetime of the next Labour government...but also for the working out of a 'detailed policy' for British withdrawal." Further:
"Certainly, we did not detail this policy or proposal, although the second resolution mentioned some possible components of it - the ending of the PTA, plastic bullets and strip-searching
Scan page 38
- but what we did do... was to suggest... that we needed a wide-ranging discussion within the labour movement to el policy prone understood a detailed " By "detailpolicy for how to withdraw the troops, not a proposal for what is to replace the present structure which depends for its survival on British troops.
My entire argument was — and I said it explicitly — that "Troops Out' alone is counter-productive. It begs questions -like the bloodbath issue — which it does not answer and which can only be answered by a programme for how Ireland should be restructured. I said our programme should be "self-determination for Ireland as a whole and within that autonomy for the Protestant areas." Even allowing 50% of the responsibility to the opacity of my writing, it is still remarkable that Geoff Bell does not seem able to take in the point, let alone reply to it.
In fact he explicitly refuses to discuss issues like 'federalism' in a profane publication like SO in a foreign country. Ours is not to reason why...
"We are all agreed that to win that support means going beyond Troops Out Now. Where the real dispute lies, I suspect, is just where we do go. For myself, the guiding political principle is that socialists insist that British withdrawal from Ireland is unconditional. To spell this out, neither the British government, the Labour Party conference, or even SO can place conditions on British withdrawal. The principle of self-determination means that they have no right to insist that the Irish construct their state in this way or that way before Britain leaves...
But this is metaphysics, not politics of any sort and certainly not working class politics. You elevate Irish self-determination into an absolute principle against which everything else is measured and to which everything else is, if necessary, sacrificed.
Now I'm for a united federal Ireland (any other form of united Ireland is simply inconceivable). But I don't start out from the idea that a united Ireland, or even an independent Ireland, is the goal itself, an unquéstionable axiom. I arrive at support for a united Ireland as a result of asking other questions. How can the Irish working class be united? How can the paralysis of the Irish working class be lifted? What are the conditions in which the Irish working class is most likely to separate itself politically from the Green, Orange, and GreenWhite-and-Orange segments of the split and divided Irish bourgeoisie?
rkers' I arrive at the belief that a united Ireland is necessary because I believe a federal united Ireland in which the democratic rights of both sections of the Irish people will be protected is the necessary way towards another goal, working class unity, which I consider a higher goal and, it there were a choice to be made, a far more important goal.
I reject the politics of ABC economic agitation combined with abstract socialist propaganda characteristic of Militant and other groups because it simply has no way of relating to the political questions which dominate the life of the Six County working class and sections of the 26 County working class, and therefore has no grip on reality.
But if I thought the working class could be united by ignoring the unresolved and festering national question, then I would consider it a socialist duty to ignore it. Neither Irish independence, nor Irish self-determination, nor Irish unity is an absolute principle if your standpoint is that of Marxist socialism. That is what distinguishes us from all nationalists, left and right: Irish independence and unity is not the end but a means to an end. We are for it or against it depending on other things.
You make of 'self-determination' a self-sufficient programme with Troops Vut as its sole expression. It is not even something that can be discussed. Your position conflates the Marxist support for a democratic programme and for those fighting for it — a support that is always conditional in the sense of being a means to an end — with the nationalist view of slogans like Troops Out as an end in themselves.
You collapse the particular, and exceptionally complicated, Irish question into generalities about self-determination — the concrete into the abstract. For a certainty the 26 Counties have self-determination and full political independence from Britain - they took a different line in World War II and the independence? No, it hasn't. But that Is an entirely different question. The socialist programme against colonialism and imperialism is not the reactionary utopia of economic independence and autarky, which the Irish bourgeoisie partly attempted between 1932 and 1958. Our solution to the economic questions is class struggle and socialism.
Self-determination is an organising principle for socialists, and an always binding and active principle. We are obliged to oppose its opposite, oppression and denial of national democracy. But how, if not by discussion, can we decide concretely whether we are for self-determination of particular groups, what self-determination means in particular circumstances, and what form of self-determination it is to be!
You cannot make determination' , meaning co "Troops Out and no talk abo 'selficretely it what comes after' an absolute principle, presented to British workers in a spirit of ultimatistic sectarianism. Self-determination has to be assayed, concretely, discussed and weighed: you have to make your case for your interpretation.
How should British (or Irish) workers work these things out? After all there is good reason to be perplexed, and reason to fear that Troops Out is the road to a bloodbath and the repartition of Irelana. How! 1 say, by reason and argument. You say, by accepting the issue as posed now by the militant nationalists and in the demand "Troops Out Now' with no nonsense or procrastination and no talk of a programme other than for how to withdraw.
This is metaphysics for another reason. For how is 'self-determination' and Troops Out going to be realised? By a sudden British- pull-out with no political settlement?
Any serious talk of British withdrawal is necessarily talk of Britain negotiating its way out, arranging for a replacement for the state power which Britain now sustains. It will be a negotiated pull-out.
This is the Sinn Fein version of "Troops Out', and the only one that does not raise the spectacle of Troops Out meaning an inevitable bloody civil war, leading to repartition. Why should the left and the labour movement confine itself to the phrase-mongering role of saying "Troops Out and no discussion' ' thereby depriving itself of any possible role in shaping a political settlement? It makes no sense.
The "Troops Out and no chatter' line amounts to a self-denying ordinance for the left in trying to explain and argue its case. This may not matter too much if you confine yourself to a 'constituency' predisposed towards you by attitudes on Nicaragua, Cuba, etc — people who might indeed well be lost by having the issues and arguments teased out in a way that would make the Third World parallels difficult to sustain.
1 worded carefully what I wrote about the "feebleness" of the Troops Out current: "Even after a notable accession of strength in the last three or four years, the Troops Out current still counts for little in our movement." Geoff Bell replies by claiming victories on the juryless courts, strip-searching, the Prevention of Terrorism Act, and Labour's commitment to a united Ireland.
Even if you accept the claim that the Troops Out current won all those victories, the fact remains that all those positions - and especially a united Ireland - are counterposed by the Labour Party leadership to Troops Out! It is true that there is a lot of support for Troops Out in the Constituency Labour British population (over 50%). Yet the Troops Out current still has very little clout outside the comprehensively leftwing sections of the CLPs. You admit that it counts for little in the unions.
More is involved than numbers. The Troops Out current is politically feeble.
Scan page 39
It is a current that cannot answer its opponents politically and at the conference did not seriously try. I think that Geoff Bell is kidding himself if he thinks the solid Troops Out support can be identified with the number of votes that Troops Out can get at constituency GCs. Will those who cannot answer the arguments of our opponents on the bloodbath question and on Troops Out not leading to a united Ireland stand up under pressure of a serious civil war scare? Passing a resolution reflecting conventional left wisdom at the ward or GC is one thing - sticking to it in face of the harsh realities that may unfold in Northern Ireland is something else, and so is being able to go out and argue and campaign in the trade unions for it.
For example, given the wide passive support for Troops Out in the population, why are the Constituency Labour Party Troops Out forces unable to win the unions? The Troops Out current is a The partition of Ireland and the repressive Six County state in the North were given a much-needed boost from the voters in the South in June 1986.
That was one of the tragic effects of the massive vote against legalised divorce in a referendum proposed by the then coalition government of Fine Gael and the Labour Party.
The referendum proposal was to allow divorce under fairly tight conditions when a married couple could show that their marriage had broken down for at least five years. All that is available now are church and civil annulments after which separated people have no right to re-marry.
The Church worked hard for a 'no' vote. Fianna Fail campaigned for 'no', though it claimed to be neutral. And by two to one the voters rejected the proposal to liberalise the law.
The first victims were the 70,000 Irish women thought to be affected by the ban on divorce. These women have no rights to maintenance or help, and yet no right to remarry.
The second victims were the Northern Catholics. Their basic civil and democratic rights cannot be won in the mainly Protestant and sectarian Northern Ireland state. They need to break down that state and create a united Ireland.
The harsh reality is that this united Ireland will not come about without big defeats for the two traditions of sectarianism. The referendum defeat showed the malignant vigour of Catholic sectarianism. neglect that. feeble.
The argument that we have no right but to support those in struggle in Ireland is not only widespread but also a very old argument. I have difficulty taking it seriously because i encountered and opposed it as far back as August 1969, when it was used as an argument against British socialists calling for Troops Out!
When the British troops were put on the streets in August 1969, Catholics in ed Belfast and Derry welcomed them. thi Socialists and Republicans in Northern Re Ireland did not call for their withdrawal and some explicitly welcomed them. The biggest revolutionary socialist group in we Britain dropped its previously promi- sh nent call for British withdrawal and no polemicised in Socialist Worker and go elsewhere against those of us who refus- an ed to give de facto support to the deployment of British troops. And as one of the their most 'clinching' arguments they us- cO John Hame, leader of the main Northern ог Catholic party, the SDLP, realised this. For na the sake of the Anglo-Irish Accord he made a are final appeal to Southern voters to say 'yes' to the divorce reform.
Sinn Fein, in a confusion which reflects the populist politics of the movement, came out the for a 'yes' vote, but then went on to explain set how they could understand many of their Ire supporters not being able to vote 'yes. They un evaded the issue. rel Many socialists who are sympathetic to dit Irish nationalism will point to the reactionary an attitudes of most Loyalist leaders on issues like divorce, and say that it is all really irrele- sta vant. They will be right about the Loyalists. SiE They will be wrong about the relevance of the po What the vote showed us is how the Irish Republic treats a minority — non-Catholics, The the fact that neither our socialist coinkers in the Six Counties nor even the publicans were calling for Troops You will say, of course, that they ire wrong. But logically, Geoff, you ouldn't. For if it is a principle w for us that we have no option but to along with the Northern Ireland left a Republicans then the same principle ist have been in operation then, even ough it led to diametrically opposite nclusions. separated women. Since the whole of the tional question in Ireland today revolves Dund the question of a minority, the Norern Protestants, the point could hardly be ore relevant.
One of the ironies of this is that many of e leading anti-divorce campaigners would : themselves as strong fighters for a united land. For us, as socialists, that just derlines the vast gulf between secular publicanism, whose aim is to remove the visions between the communities in Ireland, d chauvinist Catholic nationalism. In its explicit attempt to create "a Catholic Ite for a Catholic people", that nationalism aply mirrors the Protestant-sectarian litics of the Unionists of Northern Ireland. Uniting Ireland and uniting its working iss are two things that have to go together. you are not for both you are not for either.
Ireland
Scan page 40
The
----- pull-quotes -----
to nk issu
The Socialist
The Socialist
Britain as an eds tar, tin the Bue with Southern Ireland hasn't got economic
Party left, and there is also a lot of passive support for Troops Out in the
lot bigger than it was, but I didn't When the 26 When Count ies voted to divorr
The Socialist