Dates and
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-06-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 26 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 26
The 1960s: the South reopens its economy to the world market; Britain moves cautiously towards reforming the North. 1959 New foreign investment law in South gives big subsidies to investors. Start of an influx of foreign capital. 1965 January: Northern and Southern prime ministers meet. December: Angloİrish Free Trade Agreement. 1967 Northern Ireland Civil Rights Association formed. 1968-72: The Catholic revolt explodes: the Northern Ireland state breaks 1968 October: Civil rights march Derry banned and attacked by police.
vrkers? secret talks between Provisionals and British government. Late July: 'Bloody Friday' — nine killed by Provisional IRA bombs in centre of Belfast. Operation Motorman: army takes down Catholic barricades in Derry and Belfast. 1973 December: Agreement drawn up by London and Dublin governments and Northern Ireland 'moderates' at Sunningdale for power-sharing in Northern Ireland and à "Council of Ireland'. 1974 January: Power-sharing executive set up. February: Big victory for anti-power-sharing Unionists in Westminster election undermines Executive. May: General strike by Ulster Workers' Council brings down Executive.
November: Over 20 killed by bombs in pubs in Birmingham. Provisionals condemn the bombing but say it was probably done by Provisional IRA volunteers. British government rushes through Prevention of Terrorism Act. 1975 February to autumn: truce between Provisionals and British Army. May: New British initiative — Constitutional Convention, supposed to design a new form of power-sharing. Dominated by Loyalists who will settle for nothing less than restored Protestant majority rule. 1976 Convention shut down by British government.
Tries West Belfast. SDLP attends the first meeting of the New Ireland Forum with Southern parties. In the South, abortion is made constitutionally illegal after a referendum. 1984 May: New Ireland Forum produces a report with three options — a unitary Irish state, a federal Ireland and "joint (London-Dublin) authority over Northern Ireland. Forum report is supported by US and British Labour Party, but Thatcher replies 'out, out, out' to the three options.
November: Anglo-Irish summit. 1985 Anglo-Irish talks proceed throughout the year. Orange marches through Catholic area in Portadown are re-routed. November: Anglo-Irish Accord signed. 1986 January: 13 Westminster by-elections due to Unionist resignations in protest at the Accord; Unionists lose one seat to SDLP. March: One-day Protestant general strike against Accord. Violent clashes between RUC and Protestants.
Over the summer: further clashes between RUC and Protestants when Orange marches are re-routed. Hundreds of Catholics forced to move house because of sectarian attacks. 1987-9 Protestant activity against Anglo-Irish deal subsides, but Protestants still refuse to cooperate with the deal. Few reforms result from the deal, and Northern Catholics' support for it wanes; but the deal remains in place.
Scan page 27
federal Socialists in Britain frequently talk as if the Protestants of Northern Ireland simply do not exist. The classic example is Socialist Action's headline reporting Sinn Fein's electoral success in 1983, which announced that they had got "42 per cent of the vote". In fact it was 42% of the Catholic vote, the whole of which is about a third of the Northern Ireland electorate. This headline was not an accidental slip, but typical of a whole approach.
In fact the Protestants have been central to the Northern Ireland crisis. It was the Protestant backlash against Britain's policy of reforming Northern Ireland in the '60s which generated the Provisional IRA; it was the Protestant general strike, not the Provisional IRA campaign, which wrecked the power-sharing experiment in 1974. It is important, therefore, that the Left is clear about the Protestant/Catholic conflict in Northern Ireland.
The Protestant community in Northern Ireland is a distinct community with its own history, culture and psychology. If it existed in its own distinct territory it would have all the features Marxists recognise as making up a nation. It does not have a distinct territory — there is a major Catholic community even within the Protestant heartlands. Therefore it is not a fully formed nation.
In any case, because the Protestant and Catholic communities in the North of Ireland are so intertwined, there can be no question of full 'Protestant selfdetermination' • Our slogan for Ireland is self-determination for the people of Ireland as a whole. But within that we need a democratic policy for the question of the Protestant minority.
The tragedy of Irish society, and specifically of the Irish working class, lies in this: that the divisions among Irish workers stand as an impenetrable barrier to socialism and a socialist revolution which would bypass those divisions; while at the same time the decayed state of capitalism in Ireland, and the decrepitude and feebleness of the divided Irish bourgeoisie, has so far ruled out a democratic rearrangement of relations TRAITOR Orangeists burn effigy of Thatcher between the two communities of Ireland (within the Six Counties and between the North-East and the rest of Ireland) which would allow working class unity Years develop.
Bolsheviks There can be no socialist revolution in Ireland without the unity of large sections of the Catholic and Protestant workers. There can be no democratic solution in Ireland - that is, no solution offering the best, clearest conditions for the free development of the class struggle - without democratic relations between the majority (Catholic) and minority (Protestant) community. Socialists should therefore support the maximum democratic rights for the Protestant minority compatible with the rights of the majority.
As a general principle, Marxists tavour regional or provincial autonomy for markedly distinct areas within a state, together with the most decentralised possible local government. The Bolsheviks put it like this:
"In so far as national peace is in any way possible in a capitalist society based on exploitation, profit-making and strife, it is attainable only under a consistently and thoroughly democratic republican form of government...the constitution of which contains a fundamental law that prohibits any privileges whatsoever to any one nation and any encroachment whatsoever upon the rights of a national minority.
"This particularly calls for wide regional autonomy and fully-democratic local government, with the boundaries of the self-governing and autonomous regions determined by the local inhabitants themselves on the basis of their economic and social conditions, national make-up of the population, etc. " (1913 Resolution of the Bolshevik Party Central Committee)
Within Ireland our slogan for the Protestant community must be: autonomy and local self-government of that community's own affairs to the furthest extent compatible with the democratic rights of the majority of the Irish people.
Such a proposal for a united, independent Ireland, and within it a measure of self-government for regions, and within those regions maximum local autonomy for towns, districts, etc., can offer both majority and minority the maximum of democratic guarantees possible without infringing the rights of the other community. The Catholic majority of Ireland would have the rights of a majority within all-Ireland_politics. Catholic minorities in mainly Protestant Workers' Ireland 21
Scan page 28
20 Years regions would have the protection of local government (town/district) autonomy, plus the constitutional guarantees (courts, bills of rights, appeal procedures, inspectorates, penalties against sectarian practices) of the federal government. Likewise Protestant minorities in mainly-Catholic regions. The concentrated Protestant minority in the North-East would have the safeguard of regional institutions. So far as formal democratic constitutional provisions can ever guarantee anything, this proposal would protect the rights of both Catholic majority and Protestant minority, while allowing neither to oppress the other.
The precise details of such an arrangement will be worked out by those who will live within such structures. A federation of two regions — the four heavilyProtestant counties and the other 28 -with local autonomy within each region, eg. for the Belfast Catholics, is one possibility. The parts of the federation would have roughly the same relation to each other and to the federal (all-Ireland) government as the states in the USA have to each other and to the US federal government.
Short of military conquest or driving out the Protestants, there is no other conceivable form of united Ireland than one that allows such autonomy. Bourgeois green nationalism and its petty-bourgeois spin-offs can never unite the Irish people. The sectarian Catholic nature of the Southern state has reinforced partition and the communal divisions. Indeed: it is by no means certain that a socialist Ireland could dispense with such federal arrangements. The divisions are profound - cultural, psychological, historical. Even an agreement between Catholic and Protestant workers to cooperate in fighting for socialism would not mean that these differences between the sections of the Irish people were immediately eliminated.
Democratic demands The proposal for local autonomy is a democratic proposal - it is part of a transitional programme for Ireland. 'The Fourth International, " wrote Trotsky, "does not discard the programme of the old "minimal' demands to the degree to which these have preserved at least part of their vital forcefulness. Indefatigably, it defends the democratic rights and social conquests of the workers. But it carries on this work within the Binge ireland framework of the correct actual, that is, revolutionary perspective... " (The Transitional Pogramme). The sectarian fear of advocating reforms and democratic demands lest they undermine the prospect of revolution should be rejected. To advocate democratic demands in no way confines us to a perspective of reform. Reform demands within the revolutionary programme are weapons for the mobilisation of the masses, including (as in this case) the reconciliation of divisions within the working The socialist programme for Ireland is workers' revolution. That requires the unity of the working class North and South, Protestant and Catholic, and the building of an all-Ireland revolutionary party that can combine the struggle against British imperialism and for the unity of Ireland with an all-Ireland working-class struggle for socialism. Reforms and democratic demands are not counterposed to the workers' revolution: on the contrary, they are an itreplaceable part of the work of leading the working class towards it.
Republicanism and Green Nationalism Irom the point of view of both Irish Republicanism and working-class politics, the choice to be made about the Northern Ireland Protestant population is either to accept its existence and its right to existence or else to try to drive it out or suppress it by force — to 'undo the conquest'. As long as 200 years ago, secular and democratic Irish Republicanism adopted the former policy, and Wolfe Tone expressed it thus:
•To unite the whole people of Ireland, to abolish the memory of all past dissensions, and to substitute the common name of Irishmen in place of the denominations Catholic, Protestant and Dissenter...
This is the irreducible basic principle of secular Irish nationalism and Republicanism, and also, of course, a basic principle of Irish socialism. Anything less is inevitably a lapse into sectionalism, communalism, 'Catholic nationalism' and revanchism. To try to define away the Protestant community with a political tag which dismisses them as "pro-imperialists' is to abandon Republicanism. It stands nearer to the programme of King James's Dublin Parliament of 1689, which made wholesale confiscations of Protesant property, than to Wolfe Tone, whose oft-quoted words (above) marked the decisive break with that mainly-Catholic tradition.
Green nationalism can only propose to replace the present oppressed half-million Catholic minority in the North with an oppressed one-million Protestant minority in a united Ireland. If a united Ireland bore any resemblance to the existing 26 County state, then the Protestants would be an oppressed minority from the beginning. Lenin's principle: "A struggle against the privileges and violence of the oppressing nation and no toleration of the striving for privilege on the part of the oppressed nation", should guide us also on the relation between communities and groups within a nation.
In the event of a working-class upsurge in the South which could appeal to the Northern Ireland Protestant workers on a class basis, the consistently democratic element in our programme would in no way limit us or hold us back. On the contrary, its advocacy by revolutionary socialists and Republicans would help prepare the way for a socialist solution, in so far as it was successful in placating Protestant fears of being incorporated as a minority into a state like the existing green-nationalist, Catholic-sectarian 26 Counties.
Against 'selfdetermination' for the Protestants There is a radical difference between the proposal above, for regional and local autonomy within a united Ireland, and the proposal of a separate, partitionist Northern Ireland state, whether independent or ruled by Westminster. The 'right to self-determination' of the Protestant community does not make sense. There is no territory naturally suited to the exercise of such 'self-determination' . Any 'Protestant state' would entrap and oppress a large Catholic minority, as the Six Counties had done for over 60 years. Concretely, now, 'Protestant selfdetermination' would mean restoration of Stormont (the Northern Ireland parliament abolished in 1972) and/or repartition. It would not be a democratic solution, clearing the path for class struggle, but a sectarian solution bitterly divisive for the working class. No constitutional lusions Federalism could not mean letting the Protestants in the North-East go on as usual, discriminating socially against Catholics. In so far as such discrimination is a matter of local (or, in a federal Ireland, regional) government patronage, etc., would be outlawed. Formal democratic constitutional guarantees can never, of course, guarantee anything if the conflicts of real social forces dictate otherwise. The essential purpose of the proposals above is not as advice to the powers-that-be, but as part of a socialist programme around which Irish socialists and Republicans could assemble a real united working class force, capable of being a real material guarantee against all sectarian discrimination.
Scan page 29
Orange thugs terrorise Catholic during "74 general strike th left loft drain on British capitalism, to the tune of about £1.5 billion a year. British capitalists have more profitable relations with the independent South than with Northern Ireland. And in no way does Britain's military presence in Northern Ireland help British capitalists' profit-making in the South.
Lie No.5: Britain needs to hold on to Northern Ireland for military reasons.
Militarily, control of Ireland has been irreplaceable for Britain in the past. Northern Ireland bases were very important in World War 2. The British government considered invading Southern Ireland to regain port facilities, and so did the US in 1943-4. But all that has changed in the era of intercontinental ballistic missiles. Militari-
----- pull-quotes -----
The Socialist
The Socialist
The Socialist
The Socialist