Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Is an independent Northern Ireland possible?

Socialist Organiser nos. 405–406: Ireland: The Socialist Answer, 13 June 1989 · scan pp. 25–26 · about 1,267 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 25 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 25

John Hume and others warned in the House of Commons debate that the logical end of the road down which the Unionists' refusal to accept Parliament's endorsement of the Hillsborough agreement propels them ends in a Unilateral Declaration of Independence - or anyway some form of an independent Northern Ireland.

The present Six Counties entity would split apart if it were 'independent'. An independent Protestant state of northeast Ulster could not come into existence without repartition, either repartition supervised from above by Britain and the 26 Counties, or repartition by way of civil war. Any unilateral declaration of independence by a provisional government in Belfast would - if they could make it good against the British government and its army - inevitably involve repartition by civil war.

Just as there are Provisional IRA/Sinn Fein supporters of a unitary 32 Counties state who know it could only be achieved by way of bloody subjugation of the Protestants, so there are supporters of an 'independent Ulster' who would accept that it could only lie at the other side of bloody civil war and repartition. They would pay that price - if...if a Protestant state of north-east Ulster could be economically viable.

The fact is that it would not be viable anything like its present economic and social level. Economically Northern Ireland is massively dependent on Britain — so much so that many Southern politicians now believe that the 26 Counties cannot afford unity with such an economically weak and feeble Northern Ireland. There has been a dramatic reversal in the relative economic position of the Six and the 26 Counties. The facts and figures speak for themselves.

In 1911 the contrast was between the industrialised north-east and the underdeveloped, mostly rural, South. Ulster had 48% of all Ireland's industrial workers and Belfast alone, 21%. Only 14% of the workforce in the 26 Counties was in industry or commerce.

By 1961 40% of the 26 Counties workforce was in industry and commerce, and 257 in industry alone. The South had become a predominantly urban, industrial economy. Since the 1960s manufacturing for export has increased sharply in the South. The 26 Counties are now more industrial than the Six Counties: 29% of civilian employment in the South is in industry, as against 27% in the North. And the South's industries are generally more advanced.

A full 40% of manufacturing jobs have gone from Northern Ireland since 1970. Unemployment is now 22%. Since Protestants had more jobs to start with they have been worse hit, but still unemployment is twice as high for Catholics as for Protestants. 25 years ago living standards in the South were on average scarcely half those in the North; now EEC figures reckon the purchasing power of income per head in the South at only 2% less than the North.

Take what has happened to Derry and Carrickfergus. Carrickfergus is a town of 30,000 people, mostly protestant, not far from Belfast. In the past it has been one of the islands in the Protestant archipelago of industry and comparative prosperity within the long-depressed economy of Northern Ireland. But it has been devastated by the slump. The synthetic fibre plants owned by Courtaulds and ICI have been closed, wiping out 5,000 jobs.

In parts of Derry unemployment among heads of households is 70%. Derry's shirt factories for long employed women and girls, producing a substantial role reversal because there were many more men than women unemployed and the men looked after the house and children. Now even the shirt factories have closed. Courtaulds abandoned Derry in 1981, wiping out over 1,000 jobs.

Over half the population of Northern Ireland is directly dependent on the British state for its income, either because they live on social security or because they work for the government. (25,000 of the new jobs created in the Six Workers' Ireland

Scan page 26

Counties since 1970 are in the police and military: this is a large fáctor in the maintenance of the Catholic-Protestant unemployment differential). Northern Ireland receives a net subsidy from Britain of about £1.5 billion a year — a quarter of Northern Ireland's total income. Without this subsidy Northern Ireland living standards would plummet.

And the position from which Northern Ireland would plummet is that of being the area with the worst poverty in the EEC, except only Calabria in southern Italy. About a third of households in Northern Ireland have a weekly income of less than f75.

After a civil war in which there would be forced population movements, communal slaughter, and the hiving-off of some Catholic areas to the Republic, there would almost certainly be a Protestant-controlled area in north-east Ulster in which an independent Orange state would be viable politically, culturally and in having a common agreed national identity. But unless it could keep British subsidies, or find alternative subsidies, it would have regressed socially and economically below the worst level in Europe. According to economist Norman Gibson, writing in 'Fortnight' magazine, living standards would be cut by 25 to 50 per cent.

Those are the hard economic facts that inhibit the growth of support for independence among the Six Counties' Unionists, alienated though they now are from Westminster 1969 Constant conflict between police and Catholics. Battle of the Bogside to keep the police out of the Catholic areas of Derry. Catholics burned out of their homes in Belfast. August: British Army takes control of the streets.

October: Catholics in Belfast and Derry take down their barricades. December 1969-January 1970: Republican movement splits into Official and Provisional wings. 1970 July: Army curfew and house-to-house search in Catholic Lower Falls area of Belfast. August: Social Democratic and Labour Party formed. 1971 August: Internment without trial introduced: 600 Catholics and radicals arrested. Big increase follows in Catholic alienation and armed activity by both Provisional and Official IRAs. September: Ulster Defence Association — a mass-based Protestant paramilitary group - formed.

1972 January: Bloody Sunday. 14 marchers on a peaceful Republican demonstration in Derry shot and killed by British Army. Barricades go up in Catholic areas of Derry and Belfast. March: Northern Ireland's home-rule parliament abolished. 200,000 Protestant workers strike in protest. Previously monolithic Unionist Party bréaks up over the following year.

1972-6: Britain seeks a solution through reform but is beaten back by Protestant militancy 1972 May: Official IRA ceasefire (which proves permanent). June: temporary Provisional IRA ceasefire. July: and 'sweat out' the Catholic revolt. 1976 March: 'Political status' withdrawn for Republican prisoners (it was introduced in 1972). In protest, prisoners refuse to wear prison uniform and wear blankets instead. 'Ulsterisation' policy: local forces strengthened, British Army presence reduced. 1977 May: Paisley attempts Protestant strike for greater 'security' but it fails. British government found guilty of inhuman and degrading treatment of prisoners by European Commission for Human Rights. 1978 Prisoners refuse to have cells cleaned in 'dirty protest' against removal of political status. 1979 Paisley tops the poll in Euro-election, and four Paisleyite (DUP) MPs elected to Westminster. 1980 October: H-Block prisoners go on hunger strike for political status. Strike called off at Christmas on basis of expected concessions. 1981 March: Second hunger strike begins, led by Bobby _Sands. April: Sands is elected MP for Fermanagh and South Tyrone. His agent, Owen Carron, is elected after Sands' death in May. Ten prisoners die before hunger strike ends in October. 1982 Sinn Fein successes in local elections. SDLP proposes 'Council for a New Ireland' with Southern Irish parties. 1983-9: Sinn Fein consolidates its 'political' turn, and London and Dublin seek a new solution through reform from above. 1983 Gerry Adams elected as MP for

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 405–406: Ireland: The Socialist Answer

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →