Since 1968: what ha happened and why
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-06-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
• Before 1968: Moves 'or reform from aboy For four years or so before 1968 Northern Ireland had been shaken up and destabilised. In October 1968 it blew up.
The British Labour government had been openly putting pressure on the Protestant sectarian regime in Stormont to stop being sectarian, to stop discrimination against Catholics, and to stop repressing them. The British government plainly no longer considered the partition of Ireland to be in Britain's interest.
The prospects ahead were that Britain and Ireland would both soon join the EEC. Relations between Britain and the 26 Counties were better than for many years. In 1965 the Anglo-Irish Free British overement had the bones of Sit Roger Casement dug up out of their grave at Pentonville jail, where Casement was buried after they hanged him in 1916, and returned to Ireland with much ceremony, as if symbolically to lay the ghosts of past conflicts. Six County Prime Minister O'Neill visited Dublin and Taoiseach Sean Lemass visited Belfast.
The Southern Irish economy was in its best shape for a quarter century. On the surface it seemed to be a time of amicable cooperation, readjustment and rational reconstruction. The contradiction that changed these prospects so dramatically lay in Northern Ireland itself, which proved beyond the power of Britain — or of Britain and the Southern Irish bourgeoisie together -to control.
For j0 years Northern Ireland had been ruled as a "Protestant state for Protestant people" (long-time Northern ers" Ireland Prime Minister Lord Brookeborough). The Catholics were a big and threatening hostile minority of about one in three who had been kept in the Six County state against their will in 1921. Chronic antagonism was therefore built into the Six Counties state. The Protestants repressed the Catholics, organising a special sectarian part-time wing of the police, the B-Specials, to do So.
The built a solid Protestant bloc, involving all classes from slum Protestants to horse Protestants, against the Catholic minority. Partly for political reasons, but also because there was great scarcity and poverty, they systematically discriminated against Catholics.
More Catholics were unemployed than Protestants; run-down areas where unemployment never dropped below the Great Depression level, even during the years of the boom in the '40s, 'S0s and '60s, tended to be Catholic areas. Politics was largely communal-sectarian politics — Catholic against Protestant. Catholics were cheated of local democracy: the system long discarded in Britain of giving business people one vote for every business premises continued in Northern Ireland where it hit the poorer Catholic community. Areas with big Catholic majorities — Derry City for example — were blatantly gerrymandered to give the Protestant/ Unionist minority control of the local council. Because votes went with houses, Catholic housing was among the worst in Western Europe.
There was systematic anti-Catholic discrimination in employment. The Harland and Wolff shipyard, and the big engineering works, employed practically no Catholics. The Sirocco Engineering Works in East Belfast, standing in the Catholic enclave of the Short Strand where there was 70% unemployment, had four Catholics out of 600 workers in the mid-'70s. As a direct consequence of this, the composition of the trade unions was titled heavily against the Catholics.
The unions remained united on day-to-day trade unionism, on a basis of tacit acceptance of these discriminatory practices and agreement not to raise Colicies constitution Ternie union i ty was unity of the privileged with the oppressed on the terms laid down by the privileged — the status quo in industry and on the Six Counties' constitutional position.
At the top, where prominent people often were leftists or had a left-wing past — like, for example, Betty Sinclair, the Stalinist secretary of the Belfast Trades Council - trade unions and trades councils could sometimes be got to pass "progressive' or liberal resolutions, but these were not representative of the Orange majority of the Northern Ireland labour movement. Unity in the Northern Ireland trade unions was a fragile thing. The threat of a split on the constitutional questions was always present, staved off by political paralysis and tacit agreement to avoid splitting issues.
The situation was the same with the political labour movement. In the '60s the Northern Ireland Labour Party had a socialist left-wing in Derry and Belfast. But it was a Unionist, that is a fundamentally Protestant, party. Time and again, throughout its history, it had been disrupted by conflicting positions • Always for the status quo, it attempted to broaden its support, sometimes by playing down its Unionist character, sometimes by trickery. In the '40s for example, the NILP agitated in the Falls Road under the Irish tricolour; in the Shankhill under the Union Jack, and in the city centre under the Red Flag! Inevitably this party fell apart, repeatedly.
The Protestant workers were a privileged layer. Their privileges were marginal — but nevertheless big privileges. Leon Trotsky once remarked that the greatest possible privilege is to have a crust of bread when everybody else is starving. To have, as part of the Protestant ruling bloc, a considerably better chance of a job amongst mass unemployment, was no small privilege.
Sectarianism was no surface part of Northern Ireland, but basic to it. It was a society flawed right through along the lines of the Catholic and Protestant communities. In the late '60s and early '70s it split vertically along the lines of the communal divide, not horizontally along the lines of class.
This was the problem for Britain's reforming drive in the mid '60s. The upper-class Orange and Unionist leaders were willing to make timid moves
Scan page 7
Demo in Newry after Bloody Sunday towards reform; the Protestant working-class ranks became very alarmed that reform would be at their expense. At first this was a slow process. Around 1966, lan Paisley, the most vocal representative of that alarm, still seemed an archaic crank. But the first killings occurred in 1966, when a Protestant secret army, the UVF, killed a Catholic barman suspected by them of having IRA connections.
But at first, in the mid-'60s, the Protestant backlash was limited, and seemed like it could be easily contained. The Catholic agitation that now got under way, to add pressure from below to the British government's pressure for reform from above, turned the Protestant backlash into a powerful mass movement.
The Catholics began to agitate for 'civil rights' — one man (sic) one job, one man one house, one man one vote. The Northern Ireland Civil Rights Association was formed in 1967. It was a broad coalition led by Republicans who had renounced the gun — at least for the moment - green nationalist politicians, Stalinists, and socialists of various sorts. Inevitably their demands were taken by the Protestants to be demands to divide up the existing jobs and homes.
It is possible that these 'civil rights' demands could have been rendered more palatable to the Protestant workers if expressed in some way as this: create jobs by building more houses, etc. However, it is not at all certain.
The implications of the Catholic movement went way beyond what they demanded. The fundamental civil right the Catholics lacked was the right of self-determination - the fact that they were an artificial minority within an artificial state, carved out against the will of the big majority of the people of Ireland. From that flowed the possibility of discrimination and repression in the Orange sectarian state. It was not just ultra-sensitive Unionist politicians like the Stormont Home Secretary William Craig who saw that the logic of any such mainly-Catholic movement would lead it straight to the question of Northern Ireland's constitutional status. The leaders of the 'Official' Republicans, who were heavily involved in the civil rights agitation, did see it as the first stage in a mass mobilisation that would, when the time was ripe, raise 'the national question'. Protestants tended to see any movement of Catholics as a threat to 'the constitution'.
Yaars T secretary Wiiam Craig baned his was the background to the Secretary William Craig banned the civil rights demonstration in Derry, and the police enforced the ban by baton charges when it was defied. World TV audiences saw the Republican Labour MP for West Belfast, Gerry Fitt, with blood streaming from a head wound caused by a police baton. Most importantly, people in Britain saw it.
From that moment on, the Protestantmajority Unionist government at Stormont was on the defensive. Northern Praise for report pressure for reform intensified. William Ireland was world headline news. The Craig was sacked from the Stormont government. The Protestant working class became increasingly alarmed at the prospect of being 'sold out'. The Protestant backlash grew bigger and began to reflect itself inside the ruling Unionist Party.
One of the main Northern Ireland responses to the bloody events in Derry was the creation of a powerful movement of students to agitate for civil rights - People's Democracy (which should not be confused with the present organisation of that name, though the two do have some links). PD was based on Queen's University, Belfast, had initially had many Protestant members. Outraged by police brutality at home, they were influenced by the world-wide student radicalisation of that time, which elsewhere focused on organising protests and solidarity with the Vietnamese against the US Army in Vietnam. Most of the leaders of PD were Marxist socialists.
PD agitated and marched - often very provocatively - for civil rights. The Orange backlash grew. The Unionist Party went into ferment and crisis. Prime Minister Terence O'Neill was a feeble politician nurtured in a political system in which gentry like himself could take the loyalty and deference of the lower orders for granted. He could not cope.
Central to what happened in the next three years was the incapacity of the Unionist upper-class elite to carry the
Scan page 8
Years Protestant masses with them on reform. Every Catholic, or pro-Catholic, action stirred up and agitated the Protestant ranks, feeding the backlash. The elite could control neither the one nor the other, and the system was ground to bits between the two. O'Neill resigned in early 1969, to be replaced by another ex-Army man, his cousin ChichesterClark.
In January 1969 police rioted in Derry's Bogside, the Catholic slum area built outside the walls of the one-time Protestant city of Londonderry. The Catholics erected barricades to keep them out.
Serious rioting occurred in July. Then in August the upper-class Orange Order, th Apprentice Boys of Derry, staged a provocative march on the walls overlooking the Catholic slums. Bitter clashes occurred, which became full-scale warfare between the police, the sectarian B-Special constables and assorted Paisleyites on the one side, and the Catholics of the Bogside on the other.
Barricades were set up, and the Bogsiders held off the forces of the state using stones and petrol-bombs. Protestant bigots attacked Catholic areas in West Belfast, and the same thing happened there. The Southern Ireland Prime Minister said that the South could not "stand idly by". The Northern Ireland state seemed about to dissolve into sectarian civil war. On August 13th the British Army was moved onto the streets to stop the state falling apart. It quickly took control in Belfast and Derry.
The Catholics welcomed the Army as saviours - but they didn't take their barricades down. The Catholics of Derry and Belfast had seceded from the Northern Ireland state, for the moment. The barricades would stay up, patrolled on the outside by the British Army armed with machine guns and rifles, and on the inside by Catholics armed with hurleys, until the Catholics agreed to take them down in October.
This was the first crucial turning point. The Northern Ireland state had shown itself to be unreformable. It had been designed to serve the Protestant majority and they had a built-in majority against any change they didn't want. The Labour government had to decide what to do. As well as sending in the army, it sent in a bevy of civil servants to oversee the chief Northern Ireland civil servants, thus seriously curtailing the in dependence of the Northern Ireland government. That's all the British Labour government did.
Der's?
Instead of recognising that the system had to be radically dismantled and restructured, it lett it essentially in being, tinkering with it. But a process had begun that would end with the abolition of Stormont in March 1972, thus depriving the Protestant majority, whose right to self-determination the Six County state allegedly gives expression to of any right to exercise that majority local political structures.
The events of August-October 1969 set Northern Ireland on a new trajectory, though that was not clear at the Paradoxically, this period saw the high point of socialism in Northern Ireland. Most of the prominent Catholic activists or representatives were socialists — the exceptions were middle-class civil rights people like John Hume, and even they allied with "socialists' like Gerry Fitt MP and called the party they set up in 1970 the Social Democratic and Labour Party. (Mainly Catholic, it then included some Protestants, like Ivan Cooper MP.) PD ceased to be an amorphous student movement in late '69 and started agitating for socialism and on social questions. The PD-associated MP for Mid-Ulster, Bernadette Devlin, elected in 1969, was a revolutionary socialist, who worked closely in Britain with groups like IS (SWP) and, briefly, the SLL (WRP). (Today she is hardly distinguishable from a Republican).
All the leading activists in Derry were socialists, with the leading role falling to the Derry Labour Party, led by Eamonn McCann. In Derry almost all the Republicans were socialists, and some were influenced by Trotskyism. Most of these socialists did appeal on a class bad ato the fust 1969. Even in, is wita and provocative student days, PD appealed to Protestant workers to see that socially they had a common interest with Catholic workers. They all carefully tried to avoid appearing as Catholics or traditional Republicans.
For example, a PD leader, Cyril Toman, who was then a sort of Trotskyist, tried to get a hearing from Protestant workers by flying a Union Jack over his platform! Today Cyril Toman is in Sinn Fein, and in 1983 was one of its Parliamentary candidates.
All the socialists made Militant-style denunciations of the idea that there could be a non-socialist united Ireland. Only in a socialist Ireland could the Protestant's legitimate fears that Home Rule would be Rome Rule be allayed. 'Neither Thames nor Tiber' , the most Republican of them said, meaning no Irish unification apart from socialism. time. The youth in the Catholic areas had been roused up and radicalised, and were deflated and disappointed when the barricades came down in October 1969. The crisis in the Unionist Party continued, under pressure on one side from the British government to reform and on the other from the Protestant population against 'selling them out' to the Catholics or 'Dublin'. Chichester-Clark resigned in 1970, to be replaced by the tougher, less genteel and altogether less effete Brian Faulkner.
They roundly abused the 'Green Tory' Republic and marched across the border waving illegal condoms in the faces of the 26 County police.
By contrast the Republicans were eclipsed. Shamed and split by their inability to defend the Catholic areas in August 1969, they seemed to count for little - and anyway the main body of Republicans were socialists too.
The high point for socialism was the election of June 1970. The Northern Ireland Labour Party refused to endorse Eamonn McCann as a candidate, and he stood with the backing of the Derry and Coleraine Labour Parties. He advocated troops out and socialism, which he defined as nationalisation of the commanding heights of the economy. McCann got 8,000 votes.
There were lots of socialists, many of them Trotskyists of one sort or another. The problem was that they were largely confined to the Catholic community. Individual Protestants were socialists, of course. Though the big student Protestant support for civil rights fell away very quickly, some stayed - for example, Ronnie Bunting, son of a prominent associate of lan Paisley, who joined PD
Scan page 9
and was reputed to be 'Chief of Staff of the Irish National Liberation Army when he was murdered in 1981. But these were individuals. The Protestant working class remained impervious to appeals.
Sections of it were 'radicalising' and separating off from the traditional Unionist leaders. But they were going to Paisleyism. Their radicalism was diffuse, sectional, fuelled in part by fear of the Catholics in the Six Counties and in a possible united Ireland.
Any class feeling was strictly confined within their communal framework. If they recognised similar people in similar conditions to their own across the communal divide, they did not go on to conclude that there was a common interest. Communalism shaped and limited everything. Northern Ireland's society split vertically along communal lines in 1969 and after; and when the Protestant community split horizontally, it had no significance for class politics — it was an affair internal to the Protestant community. That is the basic tragedy of Northern Ireland politics in the last 15 years: that workers' disillusionment with the Orange bosses served only to build the Paisleyite Democratic Unionist Party.
The Catholics and their representatives — in the first place the socialists - could and did propose working class the Sinn Fein candidate of '83 - symbolises and sums up this tragic experience.
The Republican movement had come out of World War II, in which it had allied with Germany, pulverised and seemingly defunct. It made a principle of physical force and of boycotting the various parliaments (Dublin, Bellast, London) and apart from that was 'nonpolitical'. In fact it reflected the rightwing cold-war atmosphere of Catholic Ireland in the '40s and '50s. It revived slowly in the post-war period, and in 1956 launched a military campaign of small guerilla actions on the Border. This soon petered out and eventually, in 1962, a formal 'ceasefire' was declared.
Trying to learn from their experience some or the leading activists turned 'left' and began to talk of using social agitasion to an ey dent on ale ortional 'the national experiences of left-wing Republicanism in the '30s, when left-moving traditional Republicans met the right-moving Stalinised Communist Party of Ireland, and together they created a sort of populist Republicanism. The immediate task was to win national independence ('the Republic'; for the Stalinists, 'the bourgeois-democratic revolution'); then socialism would come at the next stage. hanged, in 1942 — went back even further. They denounced the 'communism' of the mainstream Republicans, though they too called themselves socialists -democratic socialists. The Provisionals' prospects did not seem very bright: for example, J. Bowyer Bell, the author of a learned academic study of the IRA published in 1970, dismissed them as a moribund relic of the past who could not keep up with the development of the mainstream.
In fact the Provos grew with astonishing speed. They recruited rapidly from the disillusioned Catholic youth.
Fianna Fail money helped launch the Provos, but to explain the development of their movement as a result of ruling class divide-and-rule is self-evidently inadequate, and no more than a conspiracy theory of history. As well to ex-
----- pull-quotes -----
1 Before for reform and below
The Socialist
The Socialist 2. 1968-9: The Northern Ireland state breaks
The Socialist
1969-70: The failu the socialists, th the Provos
WaN KQ0o7 SUNDAY"
The Socialist