Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Use your head for more

Socialist Organiser no. 404, 8 June 1989 · scan p. 10 · about 555 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

By Sleeper small but powerful group of highly privileged, politLically motivated men bent on protecting their "jobs for life' could hold the key to the outcome of a set of simmering industrial disputes. I refer, of course, to the judges.

Under successive rounds of government legislation it now seems to be nigh on impossible to organise an effective strike without falling foul of the law. But how should activists respond to this situation?

One obvious answer is to (literally) go for broke and simply urge outright defiance of the law. The problem with this is that after the experiences of the printers, the miners and the seafarers, not even the most "left' union leader these days would countenance that way forward in their wildest dream/ nightmare. I for one wouldn't condemn Ron Todd simply for having made an attempt to protect the union's assets from sequestration under the 1982 Employment Act. I would condemn him for putting his concern for legality before the requirements of organising an effective strike.

Now we see the painful spectacle of Brother Ron being dragged through the courts by the Port Employers who claim that any strike over the abolition of the Dock Labour Scheme is, by definition, "political'. Poor old Todd had more or less to promise in advance that he'd sell out in the end. Cross-examined by the employers' brief about the demand for 'terms and conditions no less favourable' than the existing scheme, Todd had to explain that this 'did not represent the final position...but merely the starting point for further negotiations since asking for anything else at the outset of the dispute would be ridiculous.' You can almost see him sweating, can't you?

The legal arguments at the disposal of the employers are almost endless: there's the whole issue of the wording of the ballot papers (remember London Underground); there's the question of whether a right to strike even exists under the 1947 Act. Then they can appeal - and they have already indicated that they pay all the costs (even the union's!) if necessary. The employers' gameplan, of course, is to tie Brother Ron up in court until June 16, when the legal validity of the ballot result expires.

Representatives of the (semi-official) National Ports Shop Stewards Committee, speaking at labour movement gatherings, have indicated that they're not entirely happy with Todd's approach but that at this stage of the game maximum unity at every level of the union is the main priority.

Some militants, observing Todd's performance in court, have been attracted to the other obvious response to the Tory laws, as exemplified by the London Underground strikers — what might be called The World War Two Approach. In this model, you keep all your actions completely unofficial and bypass all the normal union structures, as a way round the law. Even so, of course, individual strikers can still be dragged through the courts and bankrupted for 'incitement to breach of contract. Which is why the London Underground strikers were, to say the least, a little coy about publicity and giving people their real names. The Chair of Hull Port Shop Stewards is presently being done by the employers on precisely these grounds.

But apart from the risk of individual militants being picked off, the World War Two Approach is not really a

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 404

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →