Anti-Tory thriller misfires
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-06-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Belinda Weaver 'Paris By Night' Drop an innocent man into D deep trouble, have all his efforts to extricate himself only make things worse, and there you have the basis of a thriller.
There are usually a few old standbys — the police sniffing around asking awkward questions, a sense of time running out, ever increasing suspense and momentum as the trap appears to close around the hero, who's generally some poor sod we like and want to see survive.
"Paris By Night' , though it's billed as a thriller, offers none of the pleasures of the genre. For a start, the central character, Euro MP Clara Paige, isn't innocent, and she's not particularly likeable either, since she's constantly spouting drivel about the virtues of Tory self-reliance.
Director David Hare doesn't want us to like her, since he's using her as a vehicle to show how corrupt and self-seeking the thrusting new breed of Tory women are. But it's a mistake, because we end up not caring very much what happens to Clara, instead of being on the edge of our seats cheering her on.
There's no-one else to like in the film either, so it's a pretty unpleasant 90 minutes. Clara's husband is a drunk, her Tory think-tank friend Adam is a selfish, twisted horror, and Clara's new lover, Wallace, appears slightly cold and sinister. He's meant to be charming, and he's the moral centre of the film, yet he's obscurely unsettling and ambivalent. I kept expecting him to be revealed as a baddie.
The film isn't very fast paced, which is another mistake, since energy and momentum can cover up holes in the script or the kind of twists and implausibilities most thrillers hang on. In this film, we have too much time to think: Hang on, that doesn't make sense.
So it's a dud as a thriller.
It also fails as the kind of moral tale that Hare is hoping to portray. He's not interested in seeing Clara locked up or punished for her crime; he's more concerned that she herself face up to her own selfishness and corruption. But is that enough? Can Clara come to any sort of moral regeneration without facing up to what her politics really mean?
Hare seems to think that Clara will be saved if she only tells the truth. But even a truthful Clara would still be a Tory, and since her Tory politics have caused the moral rot in the first place, surely truth telling alone wouldn't save her. Hare seems to have painted himself into an ideological corner.
To help Clara confront herself, we have Wallace as the moral touchstone by which she recognises what she's become.
But the film collapses into implausibility at this point. Wallace would have needed second sight to piece together what Clara's been up to, and there's no explanation of his discovery, which borders on the truly miraculous.
Wallace isn't presented very clearly, but his balance is all wrong. He's much more censorious about Clara's neglect of her sick son than he is about her capacity for murder. And he's so joyless and judgemental that it's hard to see why she likes him.
Hare obviotsly loathes the Tories. That's a pretty understandable position, and the few enjoyable moments in the movie occur when he neatly skewers the relentless pomposity and selfishness of Tory politicians and their chauvinistic arrogance towards Europe.
But by robbing Clara of motive for her actions, and by piling more and more blame upon her (is it really her fault alone that her husband's a drunk?), he ends up overstating his case, and making us almost sorry for shallow old Clara.
Charlotte Rampling does her best to bring a brittle edge to Clara, but she's not well saved by the rather