Storm at the
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-06-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
Wto pur i another was;, as that justice? Is lan to put it another way, is Private Eye worth defending? Certainly, the £600,000 libel verdict that now threatens the very existence of the satirical magazine is almost incredible.
The libel itself occurred in 1981 when Hislop's predecessor, Richard Ingrams, was at the helm of the Mighty Organ. It was a quite nasty attack on Mrs Sonia Sutcliffe, the unfortunate ex-wife of the Yorkshire Ripper. It was an example of the Eye at its most petty and snide, attacking a 'little person' Monday or by phone Monday Published by Socialist Organiser PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.
Printed by Press Link International (UK) Ltd (TU).
Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office.
Signed articles do not ecessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser. SPRESS GANIG who had, one might have thought, already suffered enough. But was it really worth £600,000 — about the sort of sum you might expect for being totally paralysed in a motor accident and rather more than most people would get for even the most horrendous industrial injuries?
Most of the national press expressed outrage at the verdict. The Daily Mirror described it as 'verging on the obscene', presumably because Cap'n Bob only managed £200,000 when he sued the Eye a couple of years ago.
Like most people on the left, I have ambivalent feelings Lord Gnome and his Organ. It is often anti-union; it is consistently anti-gay; its attitude towards women is puerile in the most literal sense; until recently it was fairly openly anti-semitic. None of this prevents the SWP printing the thing course) or lefties as diverse as ken Livingstone, Paul Foot and George Galloway, contributing occasional little titbits.
At its best the Eye can be brilliant, displaying an unerring nose for humbug and hypocrisy. Under Hislop it has become more sharply anti-Thatcher (and not just, I think, because she's a woman) and bitter against the likes of Murdoch and Maxwell. The present issue contains a spoof 'Auberon Waugh' report from China that made me laugh out loud (that was, of course, while it was still possible to extract any humour from events in China) and a 'Paul Johnson' column that manages to attack Neil Kinnock for backsliding on unilateralism and Paul Johnson for attacking him over it, if you follow my meaning.
Yes, on balance, I'd be sorry to see the Eye go under. Life would be that much duller without it. But I don't think I'll be contributing to their fighting fund and I do have this sneaking feeling that lan Hislop is a bit likela banana. not a solution even in its own terms - of the capitalist parties is austerity and yet more austerity. The workers are being made to pay.
In Bolivia, austerity has led to the almost complete obliteration of the once-mighty tin miners. Almost everywhere, political crisis is looming.
In Brazil in March, 35 million workers staged a two-day general strike. Strikes continue now.
Argentina's working class is also powerful well-organised and militant. But its traditional Peronist leadership, whose aim is to regain the mutually-beneficial relationship they once had with the authoritarian state, is a crippling weakness.
The main would-be Trotskyist party, the MAS (Movement to Socialism) have made gains, but at the expense of enormous concessions to the Communist Party, with whom they have had santaictoral bizarre towards, for example, this year's march of the Mothers of the Plaza de Mayo, which they refused to Join.
The food riots in Argentina are not a hopeful sign. They suggest despair and disorganisation, rather than coherent working-class resistance. But there is no doubt that Argentina is now heading to a massive crisis in which the working class will have to play a decisive role or, once again, go under.
Scan page 4
*LESBIANS FIGHT THE BIGOTE GA Secti 8 on 2 DEFEN LEFE FIGHT THE B OJCU WWE 0904-6 Peter Burton (SO 391) reiterates the case that the bureaucracy in the USSR is not a ruling class.
He argues that the system is deeply untable; that there is no planning (although there is 'administration'); the bureaucracy is 'not a collectivity'; and that there is no mode of production in the Peter convinces me that the whole theory (derived from the journal Critique) is deeply incoherent.
(1) "In 7 decades there hasn't been one decade of stability." You could say that about most of South America, of course. I think one of the issues exposed by debate on the USSR is the inadequacy of the concept of 'stability' in analysing difrevolutionary crises in the USSR we need greater theoretical precision than just to say it's been an unstable system all along anyway.
(2) Peter insists: "To decide [what exists in the USSR] as planning or even bad planning is to divest the category of planning of any real meaning for Marxists." But I don't see why.
Bourgeois governments - and enterprises — plan. Not all planning is socialist planning. You can call bad planning 'organisation' or "administration' if you prefer, but we're still talking about the same thing - which is that production in the USSR is not completely anarchic.
(3) No class "collectivity" independent of the state? Of course not. But that this is proof of the non-existence of a class is merely an assertion. The state, atter all, is a "collectivity'.
(4) To assert that there is no mode of production at all in the USSR reduces the entire framework it mean of a "powerful to talk working conflict with the class" in elite?
d. What, then is the state? If there's no ruling class, whose interests does the state serve? Nobody's?
e. Where does this 'no mode of production' stand in relation both to capitalism and socialism?
The whole Critique framework simply fails to address these issues. Yet it's these issues that underlie the apparently "terminological"
Edward Ellis Southwark * Morning Star Historic moment as China USSR end rift
----- pull-quotes -----
Daily Express DAILY
effect ETITERS