Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Greek left fails to take its chances

Socialist Organiser no. 403, 24 May 1989 · scan pp. 9–10 · Vicki Morris · about 1,814 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Plan Swindale from Greece n Greece, the PASOK government of Andreas Papandreou seems to have given up all hope of winning an overall majority in the Greek general election due to take place on 18 June.

This is the most obvious conclusion to be drawn from the draft electoral law which was finally published after months of delay in the middle of March, and voted through Parliament at the beginning of April.

In public, government ministers and Papandreou himself insist that PASOK will be returned to power for a third four-year term of office. But this is very unlikely.

The 1985 elections were held on the basis of an electoral law which reinforced the position of the two main parties and especially PASOK, who drew up the law, at the expense of the (then) two Communist Parties.

With 45.8% of the vote, PASOK took 53.7% of the seats (161) and the Conservative New Democracy party with 41% of the vote took 42% of the seats (121). On the other hand, the CP, with 10% of the vote took only 4% of the seats (12) and the CP Interior with nearly 29% of the vote took 0.33% of the seats (1).

If those elections had been held under the electoral law for 1989, the result would have been PASOK 149 seats, ND 127, CP 22, CP Interior 2 and PASOK would not have won an overall majority.

Nobody believes that PASOK could achieve even that result now after a second period of government which has ended with the eruption of major scandals like the Koskotia/Bank of Crete scandal in which leading government figures are implicated, and as a result of which the heads of the Post Office and Telephone Company have been remanded in custody on serious charges.

There had been a lot of pressure on the government to introduce an electoral law based on full proportional representation. The CP and the Greek Left (EAR) who have formed an electoral alliance, the Left Alliance, have been campaigning for proportional representation and an end to two-party politics in Greece. New Democracy, although obviously favouring the two-party system, went along with the campaign.

The electoral system for the June elections is not, however, a full proportional representation system. The left will not take all the seats they are entitled to. If they did, then probably neither PASOK nor New Democracy could win an overall majority and the way would be opened. for a possible coalition government of PASOK and the left.

By leaving open the possibility of one of the two major parties winning an absolute majority it seems that Papandreou has not after all abandoned all hope of turning the situation around during the next two months and winning a third term of office. However, it also opens up a real danger that the right-wing New Democracy party of Konstantinos Mitsotakis will form the next government.

Undoubtedly New Democracy commands more support than any other party at the present time. But it needs to win probably 48% of the vote in order to form a government and it is by no means certain that New Democracy can achieve that result.

In a series of opinion polls conducted for the pro-CP paper I Proti in various towns and cities, New Democracy seemed to have lost some support since the last elections in every town.

For a whole generation of Greeks, these elections pose a major dilemma. Having grown up under the Junta and been politicised by the struggles of that period and the sharp shift to the lett in Greek politics after 1974, they have voted for PASOK as the party of non-Stalinist socialism. 'Now, cruelly disappointed and disillusioned with Papandreou, they nevertheless remain unable to vote for a ND government which they consider would be a big step backwards.

But will they vote for the Left Alliance? The Left Alliance can't win the election although it will undoubtedly emerge much strengthened after 18 June. But the Greek Communist Party, which remains heavily Stalinised, has a terrible record of mistakes and betrayals stretching back tot he Çivil War and beyond.

It is also, of course, identified with the Stalinist regimes of the USSR and Eastern Europe, although this may weigh less heavily against it now given the current popularity of Gorbachev.

The Left Alliance has held impressive rallies in Athens and Salonica and large meetings in towns up and down the country, but its main platform has been based on two demands: proportional representation and the 'cleansing' of society.

The first demand calls for nothing more than a (necessary) reform of the electoral system and the second demand, in the form in which it is posed by the Left Alliance, calls for the cleansing of the capitalist system to rid it of the worst elements of corruption. Nowhere does the Left Alliance map out a course of action for Greek workers in the struggle for socialism.

The Left Alliance has succeeded in winning to its side two former PASOK ministers. Other leading members of PASOK can also be expected to join the Alliance, though some have expressed reservations about the 'narrowness' of the Alliance's appeal and have argued that its basis should be broadened out to embrace all 'progressive' forces.

In 1985, before the austerity measures and the Koskotas scandal, PASOK won a second term of office largely because many voters, already disillusioned with Papandreou, swung back to PASOK at the last minute to keep out the right. PASOK cannot count on this happening in June. conflicts, resulting for example trom the collapse of welfare and education provision, unemployment, and inflation, we are convinced the the solutions cannot be solely economic. We aim to offer theoretical and practical aid to the widespread building of social self-organisation, community self-defence, and solidarity.

e. In international relations, we consider necessary the creation of an alliance with all social and political movements which aim to change the present international system, still infinitely unequal and unjust, to a new world order which is more democratic and based on the equality of nations.

f. We aim to contribute to the good results which will flow from the coming-together of European peoples and from efforts which will strengthen the economic and political relations of peoples. We consider it important that closer and more egalitarian relations should be established between the nations of our continent.

It is in that spirit that the system of alliances of the countries of Eastern Europe should be transformed, while progressively eliminating all forms of national hatred, especially against minorities:

g. We seek collaboration with all those groupings internationally organisations, movements, associations, institutions, etc. which have objectives partially or totally identical to ours.

Budapest, March 1989. This tion of the original Magyar tex the translation is from a French translaContact: c/o Office of the Patriotic Popular Front of the 8th district, HNF, VIII.ker. Biz., 1084, Budapest, Rakoczi ter 2, Hungary.

Scan page 10

Young mothers are forced to give away their children through TV More and more these M days, watching programmes about 'social problems' makes me believe that socialism is the answer.

More than usual, this belief was reinforced in me when I watched this week's 'Forty Minutes' programme called 'Who'll Win Jeanette?' *40 Minutes' trained their cameras on a pioneer system of adoption which is legal, although still unusual, in the United States, but which would be illegal in Britain, 'Open adoption" means that the woman given up a baby for adoption has the major, instead of no, part in choosing the legal parents of her child. In the system which currently prevails, natural mothers relinquish all say in their babies' future to professionals like social workers.

The programme makers were careful to show us the pluses and minuses of this new system, but they made one glarıng omission when they didn't provide us with any mechanism for comparing it to the normal procedures. In this. situation, the viewer such as mysell, with no personal experience of adoption, inevitably probably wound up thinking about the fact of adoption itself The only conclusion I came to was that sorrow abounds all around and that there have to be better ways of solving the problems confronting the 17 year old who, for the second time, had to reluctantly give up a baby. And there have to be better ways to satisfy the needs of the childless couples who vied to be parents to Jeanette.

Liz, the | "birthmother" been abused as a child, and herself been given up for adoption when she was 13. Since then she had sought love and approval in affairs with men who didn't give a damn about her or the children they fathered. Now she was looking for the parents and the sort of family life for her child which she would have chosen for herself.

The three couples short-listed were wealthy but, for all that, desperate and unable to have children. As she showed Liz around her house, one of the prospective mothers was aware that Liz was seeing them at their best...yet at less than their best.

The most glaringly obvious thing about all the couples was their self-consciousness about the sense of emptiness they felt without children to share their comfortable lives.

The programme ended with a scene of the least of the couples making off with the prize while Liz sobbed her heart out in the hospital where she'd given birth, the fees paid for by the now parents of her child. The knowledge that she couldn't provide the baby with the material security it might need, and the fear that bringing up a baby by herself might prove too great a strain on her temper, made Liz resolute in the final days before parting.

Significantly, Liz had chosen to place the baby with the couple who showed the least resistance to her keeping in touch with her baby.

It never once seemed to occur to anyone involved in the programme that Liz might be able to bring up the baby if she was only given the money to do it, and allowed some time to herself by sharing her childcare responsibilities.

The couples who wanted children clearly would have made excellent parents. So why did they have to demonstrate untold wealth in order to be able to share in the raising of a child? pressure of poverty The programme included some elements which showed that its perspectives were very different from mine but which, in any case, seemed disrespectful to all concerned, in particular the tricks used to build up the sense of competition between the couples.

In the end I don't think that the audience would give a damn about who "won". Whoever won, there were bound to be too many losers in this programme, through no fault of their own but just because they live in an irrational society.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 403

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →