8 DISCUSSIOI The basis of socialism today
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-05-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Marxists today must set Gramme for working class freedom and democracy world-wide.
The labour movements of the world have been polluted as much by the influence and the example of the bureaucratic states calling themselves 'socialist' as by reformism and pro-imperialism. We need to restate our commitment to genuine Marxist socialism and to the international organisation of the working-class - East and West - for self-emancipation.
Marxism and workers' The working class is the basic productive class: it can aspire to oppress and exploit no-one, and it must rule collectively and therefore democratically. The emancipation of the working class must be the task of the workers themselves. The rule of the working class will eliminate class differences and thus lay the basis for the withering away of the state, the family and all class institutions.
The Marxist view is based on an understanding of history as the product of class struggle. Capitalism, the rule of the capitalist class, is to be replaced, for the first time in history, by the rule of the same class which actually overthrows the ruling class - the working class.
The idea of working class rule, working class democracy — what is called the dictatorship of the proletariat, before the founding of Stalinst police states made this term confusing - found its first practical expression in the Paris Commune of 1871. From that Marx drew a picture of how the 'Dictatorship of the proletariat would operate in practice - how proletarian democracy, with the right of recall of representatives and the end of privileges for officials and managers, was radically different from bourgeois democracy.
The Paris Commune was also a practical lesson in the need to smash the bourgeois state and the apparatus of army, judiciary and bureaucracy, in order to establish the rule the proletariat without which there could be no working class power.
The working class came first to power for more than a brief few weeks in Russia in 1917, under the Bolsheviks. The workers' state was organised through Soviets (workers' councils) which had been created by the working class in its struggle against the old order. This was most democratic system which had ever existed.
Although Soviet power was eventually usurped by a privileged bureaucracy (led by Stalin), workers' rule on which we can draw.
In countries and situations as widespread as Russia in 1905, Chile during Allende's government, Portugal in 1975, Hungary in 1965, and Poland in 1980-1, the working class has thrown up Soviets, or workers' councils, as its committees of struggle. With its flexibility, democracy and contact with the of elected, accountable, recallable delegates is undoubtedly the historic form of rule of the working To the working class struggling for power, or in power, it is what Parliament was to the democratic bourgeoisie. It has been counterposed by revolutionary workers both to capitalism and to bureaucratic Stalinist rule in countries like Hungary, Poland and Even before Socialism is an not an outdated concept. socialist theory does n updated. What are the theory for the 1990s?
bureaucracy usurped power in the USSR, the Soviets had become undermined during the protracted civil war, and a debate established that trade union independence was essential even from the workers' state. Lenin outspokenly championed this view in these debates.
In the existing statised economies like the USSR the workers do not have political power. On the contrary they are denied even the most basic political rights by a bureaucracy which seeks monopoly control of all areas of social life.
Cuba was for long the least repressive of the existing statised economies. The institutions there, called Poder Popular (People's Power) are claimed by some to represent organs of workers' power. However, they are quite different. They are organs of bureaucratic state control of the people.
They do not arise as a means of the working class pursuing its struggle. They are not independent of the bureaucracy. They have no control over the bureaucracy. Their jurisdiction is limited. The real centres of decision-making are only effective, if at all, only at local government level.
The central bureaucracy rules, and the workers do not have the right to organise freely in parties or even in trade unions.
In all the Stalinist state monopoly systems the working class needs to make its own proletarian revolution. which will smash the state and replace it with genuine workers' councils ('soviets') and which will impose a democratic working class and consumers planning on the economy, rejecting both bureaucratic 'planning' and 'market socialism"
The world since 1945 Since 1945, capitalism has had a new era of great expansion, including an immense (though uneven) growth of capitalism in the "Third World'. This development has brought with it terrible suffering. Yet it has also brought a great expansion of the force which will overthrow and replace capitalism: the working class.
In many ex-colonial countries, bourgeois and petty-bourgeois nationalists have led revolutions against imperialism: in others, the old imperial powers have conceded independence peacefully. In a number of underdeveloped coun tries, forces linked to the USSk (or; in Cuba, petty-bourgeois radicals who eventually linked up with the USSR) have made revolutions and destroyed or broken up old ruling classes.
The regimes produced by these various revolutions have often led to considerable economic development and social reform: they have all, however, suppressed the working class. Where they have been revolutionary against the old capitalist order, they have simultaneously been counterrevolutionary against the working class, imposing a police state on it.
We were and are for the right to independence of the oppressed nations; for land reform; and for the nationalisation of major enterprises. In that sense we stand with the nationalist revolutionaries against imperialism and the old oligarchies.
We are with the Sandinistas against the US and the Contras.
But our touchstone is the working class and working class control.
Our programme is workers' liberty - working class self-emancipation dated con red consta essentials from wage-slavery and state oppression, for a cooperative commonwealth. We are for the workers, for this programme, and for free and independent working class and trade union organisation everywhere - against the nonworking class revolutionary regimes as well as against the long-established capitalist and old Stalinised regimes.
Consistent democracy and the national question The world is not divijed into 'imperialism' and antiimperialism'. The big capitalist powers have their own conflicts of interest among themselves. The USSR is the world's greatest oppressor of nations.
Unless nothing in history except monopoly capitalism can be called imperialist, the USSR is imperialist.
A number of Third World capitalist powers, from India through Israel, Saudi Arabia and South Africa to Mexico, Brazil and Argentina, have become regional big powers, or 'sub imperialisms' Oppressor or privileged nations can become oppressed; oppressed nations can become oppressors.
The cause of international working class unity demands that we reassert the Marxist commitment to consistent democracy on the national question.
1. The national question is one of political democracy. It is not a question_ of 'economic independence'. No country in the modern world can be economically independent, and there is nothing progressive about trying to be.
Many former colonies and semi-colonies have now won real political independence - ie, such independence as is possible in the modern world. A programme of "fighting for real independence' in such countries is a nationalistpopulist snare.
2. Currently oppressor nations are not 'bad nations' that must be destroyed. We recognise the right of all nations to freedom.
Our principles are Lenin's: "A struggle against the privileges and violence of the oppressing nation and no toleration of the strivings for privilege on the part of the oppressed nation".
The working class needs democracy Even bourgeois democracy is an immense advantage for the working class. It allows working class organisations to develop, and thus the working class to prepare itself to become the ruling class.
Revolutionary Marxists like Lenin and Trotsky criticised bourgeois democracy scathingly. Behind its formal equality lies real inequality. The ruling class gains vast advantages from the possession of wealth; from its control of the "ideological trades'; from the obstacles to political activity imposed on the working class by poverty and overwork; and from its control of the permanent military and bureaucratic state machine.
Thus Lenin and Trotsky poured polemical vitriol on those socialists who made a god of bourgeois democracy and its institutions.
They argued that bourgeois democracy is only a very limited form of democracy. The working class should use bourgeois democratic institutions, but it should also use direct action and go outside bourgeois democratic like the Chinese and Vietnamese channels as necessary. The Communist Parties, which have struggle and the working created new statised economies interest within it, is the only under bureaucratic rule. Often rule. workers' movements have become They were right, and their just appendages of these nontradition here is ours. Today, however, we have to supplement proletarian forces. Events in the last 12 years have based on the conclusions we must their approach with another one, drawn sharp lines between working class socialist politics and nondraw from modern history.
Counterposed to bourgeois proletarian "anti-imperialism • In Vietnam the forces led by the democracy in the last 60 years have Communist Party fought heroically been a variety of totalitarianisms — to defeat US imperialism - and fascist, Third World nationalist, then immediately imposed a police and those on the model of the state on the working class. USSR. In terms of civil liberties and Marxists, while supporting the CPhuman rights, these political led forces against the US, should regimes were an immense simultaneously have been fighting regression. They fall short of to mobilise the workers to resist the bourgeois democracy by a whole imposition of a regime modelled on. epoch in human progress. In this the USSR. But in fact most sense the existing bureaucratic state Marxists barely criticised the CP at monopoly economies are all. incontestably a step backwards - • Even worse, in Cambodia, most however we evalute their social Marxists said nothing about basis, 'degenerated workers' state', organising workers independently "state capitalist' or some new form from and eventually against the of society. Khmer Rouge - who, once in Working class socialists today power,. ran a regime of mass have to combine the attitude of murder.
Lenin and Trotsky in the class • In Iran, Khomeini's opposition struggle with defence of the to the US led many Marxists to hail democratic traditions and him as 'progressive' while he was democratic values which we inherit beating down the workers' from the bourgeois democratic independent organisations that had revolutions, and with advocacy of emerged in the struggle against the liberty and democracy in the way it Shah and constructing was advocated by Marx and Engels totalitarian Islamic regime. in pre-democratic Europe. Khomeini presented his opposition Our movement to modern society as opposition to imperialism, and many took it as For over 60 years now, radical good coin. Many Marxists at least workers' movements across the initially, took Iran's side in its war world have been split up and with Iraq, instead of denouncing thrown into disarray by the the war on both sides. influence of revolutionary • Immediately after the USSR's nationalist forces and of the forces. invasion of Afghanistan
----- pull-quotes -----
very pores of the daily life of the working class, the workers' council