Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Workers' Liberty '89

Socialist Organiser no. 402, 17 May 1989 · scan pp. 5–7 · about 1,465 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

Friday 7 July John's Way, Archway, London NI9 Workers of the World Unite!

Speakers include

Socialism and Revolution (Iran), US Marxist Robert Brenner, Polish Socialist Party (RD), Chinese Socialists, Socialist Organiser Saturday 8 and Sunday 9

Scan page 6

Sessions include • How to save the world -a debate with the Green Party Robert Brenner on Imperialism • Hilary wainwrigne and Bob Fine discuss the Left and political democracy Socialism and Revolution (Iranian Marxists): ten years after the revolution Soclalist Organiser and Marxism Today debate "New Times' The PLO speak on the chances for peace in the Middle East • Left Unity in the student movement The left debates the nature of Time To Go - a forum Ireland to introduce debate organised by and Revolution.

Food, bar and professional creche provided. Tickets cost 68 waged £6 low wage/students £4 unwaged.

phone 01-639 7965.

Scan page 7

JOHN BULL - CREDENTIALS EXCELLENT Kinnock shifted to the left in the TUC and. the Labour Party.

In this period MacDonald produced all manner of left talk. No doubt he found it morally uplifting. Besides, it could help his career.

Workers' councils

At the famous Workers', Soldiers' and Sailors' Convention in Leeds in July 1917 he hailed "the great achievements of our comrades in Russia" — and called for soviets (workers' councils) in Britain! In 1920, he loudly backed the action of London dockers who refused to load munitions for use against Soviet Russia onto the ship 'Jolly George*.

But revolutionary rhetoric was one thing, revolutionary conclusions were another. MacDonald denounced the Third International and the new (then revoluthe same time as he tried to ingratiate himself with the Clyde Shop Stewards' movement. He defended the doctrine of Parliamentary democracy as the central motor of change, while also calling for social revolution.

The General Election of 1922 produced a radical break with ihe past. The Liberal Party was eclipsed, taking third place. Labour became a major force, with 142 seats. (The Conservatives had 347 seats and formed the government).

MacDonald was re-elected leader of the Party. beating Clynes by a whisker - 61 to 56 - in a Parliamentary Labour ity Party vote.

Donald, I am very led Flag song in the lo not worry, Your ns and miners. We That the mass of ordinary workers had illusions in MacDonald and his crew cannot be doubted. The New Leader' wrote at the time:

"He is the focus for the mute hopes of a whole class. When he entered his constituency of Aberavon, it took his car one hour to move two miles. It is enough for us to know that rarely, if ever, in English political history has such a scene been witnessed - who could be a pessimist after this!"

The 1924 election tilted the balance even more. The Conservatives had. 259 seats, Labour 191, and the Liberals 159. No overall majority for anyone. The King sent for MacDonald and the first Labour Government in history was formed.

Trotsky wrote:

"If MacDonald walked into Parliament, laid his programme on the table, rapped lightly with his knuckles, and said, 'Accept it or I'll drive you all out , if he did this, Britain would be unrecognisable in two weeks.

Reverence

MacDonald would receive an overwhelming majority in any election. The British working class would break out of its shell of conservatism with which it has been so cleverly surrounded; it would discard that slavish reverence for the law of the bourgeoisie, the propertied classes, the church and the monarchy"

But MacDonald had different ideas.

"Socialist measures are not on the agenda. We have to prove that we can govern as competently as Baldwin. We must not alienate the middle classes".

No measures were taken against Capital. Nu welfare or sucial policies were introduced. This government did not even deserve the name 'reformist For MacDonald that was unfortunate, but secondary. What mainly impressed him was this:

**Who would ever have thought that MacDonald the starveling clerk, Thomas the engine driver, Henderson the foundry labourer, and Clynes the mill-hand would one day form the King's Cabinet"

Mac Donald enjoyed himself:

*The left wing people have been criticising me again for wearing Court Dress. They are a dull-witted lot. In their view, if I was to give sixpence a day from public funds to the poor, then would be a socialist. What rot!

I do not care a fig for the argument that Court Dress is part of royal flunkeyism. The King has been cordial and friendly, and that is important to me"

Nine months later the Labeur Government was bundled out of office, with the help of the forged 'Zinoviev letter" scandal.

But by the late '20s, with unemployment climbing steadily, Baldwin's Tory government lost popularity. In 1929 Labour won 287 seats in the General Election, with the Conservatives taking 261 and the Liberals 59.

John Maynard Keynes had begun to put forward his theory that the government could use budget deficits to reflate, the capitalist economy by launching public works programmes. The Liberal Party entered the 1929 General Election with a Keynesian platform, 'How to Conquer Unemployment' Bu: the Labour Party manitesto, Labour and the Nation' was cautious, conservative, and monetarist. It made only vague hints about expansion, repudiated the wild adventurism' of Lloyd George's claim that unemployment could be brought down to 500,000 within a year.

While Keynes and' the Liberals had the confidence to challenge the shibboleths of orthodox economics and to propose radical changes within capitalism. MacDonald, Snowden, and Henderson were concerned above all to make themseives respectable in the eyes of the conservative bourgevisie Strike-breakers in 1926 The first act of the new Labour government was to preside over the sentencing of Wal Hannington, organiser of the National Unemployed Workers' Movement, to 12 months for sedition: Its second act was to reduce the civil service clerks, dockers and railworkers by 5%.

Then the Wall Street finance empire blew up.

In January 1930 unemployment was 1,533,000; by March 1,731,000; by June 1,946,000. By December 1930 it was 2,735,000.

The crisis split the government down the middle. Philip Snowden, the Chancellor, demanded strict adherence to monetarist orthodoxy. There would have to be cuts all round in order to keep sterling on the Gold Standard, he said.

Oswald Mosley (later to g over to fascism, but then stil Labour) proposed a Keynesian alternative. MacDonald was unmoved: *There is no more socialism in that than there was in the cup of tea I had for breakfast this morning".

Snowden placed a statement before the Cabinet calling for a cut of £67 million in unemployment benefit.

For three weeks the government prevaricated. Henderson, who had the closest links to the trade unions, led the opposition to MacDonald and his Chancellor. Finally, the vote was 1l to 9 in favour of cuts. Immediately the nine resigned.

Expelled MacDonald, Snowden. and Thomas formed a National Government with the Tories, and were promptly expelled from the Labour Party. Henderson became Labour Party leader, and was backed by the TUC.

Mac Donald's daughter, Sheila, noted in her diary:

"Daddy spoke to Mr Thomas, "We cannot shirk our responsibilities" he said. 'All this senti mentality about the workers is trash. The unemployed must make sacrifices too' "But what about Henderson', Mr Thomas said.

'Bugger him! We've got a National Government, to form', said Daddy"

Ramsay 'MacShackles" re mained prime minister, but was a mere prisoner of the Tury Brldwin and became a pariah figure for the rest of his days. In the 1935 election, when the National Government was reelected with a 247 seat major ity and Labour was reduced to seats. MacDonald® nonetheless lost his own Parliamentary seat to Labour's Emmanuel Shinwell.

MacDonald became an increasingly pathetic figure, and died in 1937, aged 71.

Reflex response

Why did it all happen?

The working class movement in Britain was formed organisationally and ideologically long before Marxism became accesSible. The trade unions, the bedrock upon which the Labour Party came into being, had grown through piecemeal Donald's spasmodic lurches forward, as a reflex response to Capital's attempts to increase the exploitation of labour.

The labour movement's leading cadres were often imports from the reforming wing of the Victorian middle class. Trotsky put it well:

*At bottom the English Labour Party has thus far been living without a head on its shoul. ders, while the party of the English bourgeoisie has a head - a head with a high and mighty brow, supported by a robust and powerful neck".

It is only by understanding this history that we will be able to fight for a socialist leadership of the labour movement today.

MANAGER

WANTED ONE WHO CAN RUN A LARGE CONCERN PUBLIC INTEREST APPLY

----- pull-quotes -----

JOHN BULL L° JUST THE MAN I WANT.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 402

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →