6 OUR HISTOR Neil Kinnock
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-05-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Neil Kinnock has declared he wants Labou to abandon its commitment to unilateral nuclear disamament. Kinnock is in many ways like the first Labour leader, Ramsay MacDonald. He too was prepared to ditch Labour policy and socialist principles in order to appear respectable to our rulers. I reprint an account of MacDonald's life an 'career'. dent Labour Party, which had been formed in 1893 and now became a component part in thé federal structure of the new The ILP had many left-wing activists, but mostly it remained at the level of a vague, moralistic, often religious, socialism.
MacDonald, ironically, summed it up in 1904:
"Every time I go abroad and see on the bookstalls evidence of intellectual and imaginative activity amongst foreign socialiste I am ashamed of our English movement"
MacDonald himself, however, was much more fascinated by the goings-on in radical Establishment circles than in developing a socialist philosophy for the working class. From 1900 to 1914 he hoped that the way forward for Labour would be through a great split between the Asquith and Lloyd George wings of the Liberal Party, after which Labour would fuse with the latter to create a new 'Radical Party', carrying on the reforming work of Gladstone and the 1906 Liberal Government.
Desertion
For MacDonald, the working class was not quite good enough to deserve its own independent political party. His desertion in 1931 was intellectually prepared for long in advance.
Indeed, if the years 1889-95, 1910-14, and 1916-22 had not been characterised as they were by the enormous growth of the trade unions, MacDonald would not have been a Labour leader, but a semi-orthodox Liberal MP, sitting alongside John Burns and Lloyd George. In 1911 MacDonald Forced his MPs to vote for the clause in the National Insurance Act that forced empitoo to pay one third of the contribution to the scheme. This was against the Labour Party's Annual Conference decision that the whole contribution must be paid by the employer and the Guvernment. But MacDonald was contemptuous: "What would Lloyd George say if we were seen to be pettifogging over details?"
The cornerstone of MacDonald's tactics was the Macson Herbert. The Labour Representation Committee and the Liberals agreed on a division of seats so that in a few constituencies Labour could stand against the Tories without Liberal competition.
29 Labour MPs were returned in the 1906 General Election. The price of the electoral success, however, was capitulation to Liberal policies. Anyone who opposed this orientation was, in MacDonald's вуев, 'a wrecker' ] In 1918, for example, when a by-election occurred in fifeers ederal in Fit hire the "wreckers' They nominated a local miner, Raymond McAttwell, as the Labour candidate, in preterence to an ex-Liberal worthy.
MacDonald was furious. "Do not those dim-witted miners realise that the former Liberal MP, Sir Arthur Ponsonby, is willing to stand (for Labour)? I must go to Fifeshire to put some sense in their heads" '. Sir Arthur became the candidate.
Here as always, MacDonald's guideline was the Fabian idea that social reform would come through the enlightened 8eCtions of the bourgeoisie, not through the crude, uncouth efforts of the working class itself. The same outlook determined his attitude to the industrial struggle.
During the national rail strikes of 1907 and 1911, in which the union was fighting for the right to negotiate, MacDonald spent his time talking to the company and the government side in an attempt to "bring harmony to our nation by finding a solution"
It was the same later, during the General Strike. MacDonald had always opposed all "that syndicalism stuff" ', and used all MacDonald his energies to try to call off the "calamity of the General Strike"
On May 5, the second day of the strike, he journeyed to the country house of Winston Churchill, who was editor of the government's 'British Gazette' and master-mind of government strike-breaking policy, for dinner and a chat.
For MacDonald there was nothing out of order in the Labour leader, quite arbitrarily and off his own bat, dining with the leader of the class enemy in such circumstances. He noted: "Besides the miners' issues, we had a pleasant dinner talk on superstition and ghost topics"
•The notion that socialism has anything to do with the mad scramble for the extra penny a week is nothing but an illusion" MacDonald warned Party members in 1913.
*It is the job of the trade unions to negotiate for better conditions for the workers, not the Labour Party. Our goal is to unite the country and take it towards progress"
Trespass
And in MacDonald's view, the other main component of the Labour Party, the Independent Labour Party (whose place in the Party corresponded roughly to that of the constituency activists today), had the job of painting a mored vision of socialism.
-It should not trespass on the territory of the trade unions, or get its hands dirty by leading struggles against capitalism, but "follow the teachings of Jesus and point the way to the Promised Land" by general moral enlightenment.
In 1931 he was to say: "T am the representative of the whole nation and not just one region or class. The King expects me to do my duty by himself and the ountry. Not to form a Nationa This desertion of the labour movement in the name of loyalty to 'the nation' was only the logical conclusion of long-held views. In 1910 he had argued for distancing Labour from the unions.
*Labour needs to be an independent party — not just a cancfor implementing TUC decisions"
Class war
In MacDonald's view, **the Labour Party should have no class conscicaness. Our opponents, they are the people with a class conscicuences. Instead of this we wish to advance the consciousness of social solidarity. The class war is not the work of our hands. It was created by capitalism's And when young militants fought for a genuine socialist programme for the Party, he told them: "You speak of revolution - but look at nature. How wise is the worthy tortoise, and you will find in its movement the natural rhythm for the transformation of society. Learn from nature".
Trotsky was to comment:
"English pigeon-fanci-- by a method of artificial selerson, have succeeded in producing a variety by the progressive shortening of the beak. The beak of the new stock is so short that it is incapable of breaking through the shell.
The English bourgeoisie's political skill lies in shortening the revolutionary beak of the proletariat and thus preventing it from breaking through i the shell of the capitalist state. This beak is the Labour Party.
single glance at MacDonald, Thomas, and Mr and Mre Snowden, is sufficient to convince us that the work of the bourgeoisie in the selection of short-billed and soft-billed specimens has been crowned with immense success, for these ladies and gentlemen are not only not fit for breaking throagh the shell of the capitalist system, but are good for nothing whatever"
in 1915, however, Mart ald was forced to resign leadership of the Labour Pe The Labour Party had suppa World War 1. Arthur Hen son, with majority TUC and I our backing, joined the Lib Government as Minister of E cation.
It was a small minority Donald and lyncluding o mained opposed to the War.
No doubt MacDonald rece the career of Lloyd George 1900 the Liberal MP had voc opposed the Boer War. It did career no harm at all. l George rocketed from anot ity to the centre-stage of Bri politics.
Why could Ramsay Macl ald not do the same?
Pacifism Lenin called MacDon position "social pacifism. Donald deplored war slaughter - "violence in form is unthinkable and u ceptable" - but confined self to appealing to the caj ist governments to stop il made no effort to mobilise working class to take power the hands of the warmongen He stumped the country ing for peace initiatives Germany and an izama ceasefire, and also chast the Coalition Government fa military incompetence.
As the war ended, the C Sheffield, Manchester and where became amoulde cauldrons of industrial tancy. The centre of gr King George V: "Mr Ma about the singing of that and elsewhere."
Ramsay MacDonald: but a small group of ruf well in hand."
----- pull-quotes -----
Donald/Gladstone pact of 1903 agreed with the old stager's
dereramest woald be the high: est treachery to them both".