The struggle inside Israel
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-05-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
After nearly eighteen months, the Palestinian Intifada against Israeli occupation of the West Bank and Gaza continues, although Israeli repression gets worse and worse. After recent heavy fighting in the Gaza, and following celebrations of Israel's forty second year, Arabs working within Israeli borders have been forced to return to their homes in the occupied territories. The Israeli government's proposal for elections to be held in the West Bank and Gaza have been rejected both by the exiled Palestinian leadership and by local leaders. The proposal, they say, is a substitute for Palestinian statehood. Israeli leaders have threatened dire consequences for the Palestinians if they continue along this road. But Israel is increasingly isolated inTernationally. These articles from The Other Israel examine the background. - 19 i February and March, the military authorities started to implement a new policy, aimed at dividing and weakening the refusing soldiers' struggle. In hundreds of cases, refusers were not imprisoned but offered a variety of 'deals':
In some cases, they were sent to duties in the Occupied Territories, which do not involve direct contact with the Palestinian population.
Others were sent home or offered temporary or permanent discharge from the army on medical or psychiatric grounds.
In all these cases, the military authorities attempted to avoid publicity, to obscure the political aspects and play down the whole issue as 'personal problems of certain individuals. I However, with the growing number of refusers, these 'deals' have become such a massive phenomenon that they became an Refusniks The rise in the number of soldiers refusing to serve in the Occupied Territories is a source of constant concern for Israel's military and civilian authorities. At the end of 1988, an attempt was made to isolate the refusers by delegitimising their support organisation, Yesh Gul - with the intention of eventually outlawing it altogether.
However, this attempt backfired. Far from discrediting Yesh Gul, the intensive police investigation of its members resulted in a wave of public sympathy and solidarity, making its positions more widely accepted than ever in the Israeli public. In February 1989, the investigation was terminated.
Defiance
In 1988 reserve lieutenant-colonel Doy Yirmiyah, a veteran of all Israeli wars, spoke at a rally in Haifa and called upon soldiers to refuse service in the Occupied Tel ritories.
Interrogated by the police, he admitted the charge of inciting soldiers to disobey orders' and told his investigators that he would welcome a trial. He declared that, in such a trial, true defendant would not be himself but the occupation.
• Several months later -presumably after the implications of the prospective trial were considered - the police closed the case of this "self confessed criminal" on grounds of...lack evidence. interesting item lin themselves for several papers.
According to 'Ha'aretz' (April 2), senior military officers who denied that the army command is encouraging units to make such 'deals' with refusers, were unable to explain why such deals have become so numerous., Simultaneously with the largescale offering of 'deals' the military authorities have singled out a number of refusers for particularly severe treatment. An arbitrarily chosen soldier was made an example of: 33-year old Rami Chasson of Jerusalem. Chasson who had never been particularly active politically, refused in April 1988 to participate in putting down the Intifada and served a 28-day prison term.
Before the end of the same year he was called again and ordered to serve as a guard in the Fara'a prison, notorious for cases of mistreatment and torture of Palestinian youths. Upon his refusal, Chasson was sentenced to another 28 days.
Since that time, this reservist again and again received upon his release a new, similar order; he has been going in and out of jail, now serving his fifth consecutive prison term.
The few days of freedom, in between, he spent sitting in front of Prime Minister Shamir's home, holding in his hands a big photograph of a three year old Palestinian girl, who lost her left eye from a 'rubber' bullet shot by an Israeli soldier.
All of Chasson's trials were conducted by his commanding officer, rather than before a regular court martial.
In a trial by a commanding officer the accused is not allowed to be represented by a lawyer, and the trial is held in camera. Such trials, in fact, seldom last more than five or ten minutes.
On the other hand, the commanding officer is limited to imposing no more than 28 days of imprisonment, in comparison with the far longer terms in a court martial's authority.
Chasson's case shows this limitation can be circumvented In theory there is nothing to prevent the army from putting a person in On the mountain side, from where loudspeakers could reach to Chasson and the five other imprisoned refusers, they held a Pesach ceremony: Pesach is the holiday of the Exodus from Eygpt and the liberation from slavery -the time of freeing captives and Letters of encouragement to: Samal Rishon (senior sergeant) Rami Chasson, personal number 2245495 (reservist prisoner), military prison six, military postal code 03734, Israeli Defence Forces, Contact: Yesh G'vul PO Box 6953, Jerusalem 91068; or PO Box 4172, Tel Aviv 61041; or British Friends of Yesh G'vul c/o 6 Endsleigh St, London WC1. The following excerpt from the speech of Major (res.) Yossi Dan ziger, commander of a reserve infantry company, was delivered at the Tray Kriah rally, and is translated from "Zu HaDerech" (April 12, 1989).
This year 1 did seventy-two days' service in the Territories, most of them spent fighting children. I did not refuse the callup order. None of my soldiers did - I convinced them not to refuse. Nor will I disobey the next callups. I am gnashing my teeth and continuing to serve. This is not just a figure of speech - my front teeth were broken by an Intifada stone, on the Jewish people's front line in Rafah.
Israel's political and military leadership is leading us into a dead end. The soldiers know what is happening on the ground. They know it far better than our sleepy Prime Minister. They are losing confidence, both in the political leadership and in their commanding officers.
I was brought up upon Jewish history. I was told that, after the Second World War, Jewish life will never again be defenceless. Today this argument is still in use. Having commanded a company which restored order in the Territories, I can tell you that today it is Arab life which is defenceless.
They tell us that all the women, children and old people who were killed, died because there was no other way. That is not true.
Our leaders give moral legitimacy to the killing of Arabs; they create a situation where any trigger-happy psychopath can kill Arabs in the Territories, knowing that the system will cover up for him.
The army could maintain the struggle in the Territories at a far lower cost in human life; but what is really necessary is just to get out of this quagmire.
I call upon the government: For the sake of Israel's security, get out of the Territories! Let the Palestinians determine their own fate. Stop playing tricks, stop inventing a non-existant 'Palestinian leadership' • Sit down and talk with the true leadership, with the PLO, with Arafat and if need be with Saladin's ghost in person!
Human rights
42-year old Carlos Levinhof came to Israel from Uraguay, after his fatherin-law was tortured to death by the military dictatorship. In Israel, he and his family continued to struggle for
----- pull-quotes -----
sraeli maj condemns West Bank repression