Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Coup threat n Argentina

Socialist Organiser no. 401, 11 May 1989 · scan p. 5 · about 2,661 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

By Sleeper t would be hypocrisy to pretend that last week's news of the death of Sir John Boyd, caused AEU activists any great sorrow, let alone loss of sleep. It is said that he was a personally honest man, devoted to his family and kindly in his general demeanour. That may well all be true. But as a trade union official he was a treacherous old sod.

Boyd became a Division Organiser in 1946 and was on the Union's National Executive throughout most of the '50s and '60s. At this time the AED was led by a vicious old reactionary, Bill (later Lord) Carron. But the left was busy beavering away at rank and file level. By the time Boyd put himself forward as the 'moderate' candidate for the union President's job in 1968, the left was in the ascendant. Shop stewards committees, combine committees, branches and districts in key areas were dominated by militants who had spent years building up rank and file support. In Glasgow, Manchester, Sheffield and London a powerful Broad Left ensured the election of left wing full timers. In 1968, this movement put Hugh Scanlon in as President. Apart from lacking the kind of factory based rank and file organisation that supported Scanion, Boyd's other disadvantage was his close association with the unpopular wage cutting policies of the Wilson government. In 1967 he had been Chairman of Scanlon was a former member of the Communist Party and was still strongly associated with CP politics, as was the AEU Broad Left as a whole.

At about this time, Jack Jones, another CP fellow traveller, won the leadership of the TGWU. The two largest unions in Britain were led by long standing left-wingers; the media dubbed Scanlon and Jones "The Terrible Twins" . Militant trade unionists looked forward to a new Golden Age of principled leadership and an upsurge in rank and file involvement. It was not to be.

What actualiy happened was that the Broad Left in both the TGWU and the AEU became Jones and Scanlon fan clubs. More and more Broad Lefts became machines for electing full-time officials. When in 1970 Scanlon was reelected for a second time, his position became secure and he didn't have to worry so much about rank and file supA miner's dhany For a long time we have Flowering of safety tam of safety standards in the pits.

Last Thursday there were two gas explosions at Bevercotes colliery, in Notts, where I used to work. Fortunately nobody was seriously injured, but that port. But still, the CP influenced Broad Left gave him uncritical support. The International Socialists who were the only organised grouping, apart from the CP, within the AEU Broad Left, commented that "to criticise or even question Scanlon was taken as an act of sacrilege like farting in church".

By the mid "70s, both Jones and Scanlon were enthusiastic supporters of the Labour government's Social Contract. In fact it could never have come into being without the support of established 'lefts' like the terrible twins. During this time, a whole series of workers went into struggle against the Labour government's incomes policy, using arguments about 'parity', 'difterentials', 'special status" - ducking the real issue of pay because the union leaders were now hand in glove with the Labour government, supporting the Social Contract.

The best known case was the Leyland tool room workers- members of the AEU. They had seen their wages slashed during the years of the Social Contract. They wanted to fight back, but received no support. At plant, district and national level, the ABU Broad left opposed the tool makers as 'craftist'.] The Leyland Combine Committee, controlled by Communist Party members, held a special conference *Against the Social Contract" while the toolmakers were on strike and not only didn't invite a tool makers' representative to speak, but actually attacked the strikers from the platform.

This sort of behaviour was what ensured that John Boyd, roundly defeated as President in 1968, was elected as General Secretary, when he stood against Scanlon's uninspiring side kick George Right in 1975. That election marked the end of the Broad Left as a force to be reckoned with inside the AEU: it was no longer an expression of rank and file militancy, but a bureaucratic machine for the elction of stooges of the Wilson/Callaghan government.

When, four years later, in 1979, Scanlon retired and a straight left-right fight took place between Terry Duffy and Bob Wright for the Presidency Duffy won quite easily.

All sorts of excuses can be made for Duffy's victory: the capitalist press gave him fulsome support; sinister organisations like the CIA-founded IRIS (who had backed Boyd) pumped money into his campaign; Catholic Action had pulled out all the stops for him. But the truth is that the rank and file of the ABU had had enough of the Social Contract and wage cuts and the AEU Broad Left had by now become the people who were most closely associated with that With Boyd as General Secretary and Duffy as President, the AEU swiftly lurched rightwards. Amalgamation talks with Frank Chapple's BETPU began.

was more luck than judgment.

Not just in the mines, but on the transport system and elsewhere, safety is going to the wall, being sacrificed to profit. We have to make a firm stand.

The safety issue must be a factor in the new wave of militancy in transport, along with the fact that the workers have had their living standards battered down.

We've seen mortgage rates go up, and every time the Chancellor puts one per cent or two per cent on interest rates, it doesn't just mean mortgage payments become "uneconomic", and there are It means pits shut, businesses closures and threats to jobs.

There is an economic reason behind the wave of militancy; and there is a surge of feeling that we can win.

Workers are drawing the line and making a stand. I think as the mood of confidence builds up it will spread to other groups of workers - just like the miners' strike in 1984 gave confidence to others to have a go.

People are talking a lot about a summer of discontent. In fact we've been living in discontent for a long time, and what's happening now is that we're going to express that discontent and turn it into action.

There is the law to contend with. But sooner of later someone will have to say To *gE SALVATION AR John Boyd Two research assistants at the union's head office were sacked for writing articles in their own time, which Boyd described as "calculated to discredit the elected leadership of the union". An industrial tribunal found against Boyd (even though he was a paid advisor to ACAS) but still, the two workers did not get their jobs back.

Boyd made it union policy that no strike could be officially supported unless a full-time official had been in. volved in discussions before the action started. The justification for this was money: the union couldn't afford strike pay said Boyd. That didn't stop him awarding himself a wage increase of 28% in 1980.

Probably the most contemptible betrayal by the Boyd/Duffy leadership came in 1979 when the then-boss of British Leyland Michael Edwardes sacked the convenor of the Longbridge plant, Derek Robinson. Robinson was a prominent CP member, who had cooperated whole heartedly with the Labour government's efforts to bail out the firm. Edwardes decided to sack Robinson as part of a calculated drive to smash the shop stewards movement throughout Leyland. The AEU leaders refused to support the strike Robinsoh, a kEp member. Instead, KORESOLL. they held their own "investigation' into Instead Robinson. It formally cleared him but, in fact, gave Edwardes all the ammunition he needed to ensure the destruction of Robinson. No informed hell with the law!' If rail workers and bus drivers all walk out together, there is very little the law can do about it. It would paralyse the capital immediately. If workers take things into their own hands and down tools unofficially, then the union can't be blamed, and there is nothing the law can do about it.

People are starting to realise that there is an alternative to Thatcher. She's not God. She is beatable.

The Tories are beatable in the polls, and they're beatable on the industrial front, too.

'm not surprised that Dr Owen has said that he's prepared to serve in a Kinnock government.

He has not kept his own ship afloat. He wants to get back. But I think it's too late for him. We should let him sink.

I can understand Neil Kinnock's reasons for dumping left-wing policies in the Policy Reviews. He could become Prime Minister after the next General Election. He does not want to deal with bolshy unions and bolshy workers, any more than Thatcher does.

Much of the Policy Review is about ditching the backbone of a socialist programme - and he intends to keep some of the anti-trade-union legislation so that in the event of workers having a go, he's got some of the laws that the Tories have built up over the years.

Workers have got to spell it out: we*re not having it. In trying to woo SDP and commentator now doubts that Boyd and Duffy worked hand in glove with Edwardes over the 'Robinson affair' If the Derek Robinson sacking represented a low spot in the recent history of the AEU then it's worth remembering the 1979 National Engineering dispute: within a few weeks of Terry Duffy's election the AEU leadership was forced to call a series of national strikes involving well over one million engineering workers in support of a claim for shorter hours and increased minimum time rate.

After 1 and 2-day national strikes over 13 weeks, the Engineering Employers Federation caved in on both hours and wages. Neither Duffy nor Boyd, of course, had ever wanted the dispute but once locked into it (by a Broad Left resolution carried on a majority of 1 at the national committee they pursued the dispute with a surprising degree of determination.

It looks as though something similar could be on the cards this year, now that Bill Jordan has given up playing footsy. with the BETPU.

The left would do well to learn some lessons from the rise of the Boyd/Duffy right wing in the AEU - and to remember that even under the most vicious right wing leadership, rank and file trade unionists can still wage successful struggles.

A successful national engineering dispute would not be such an inappropriate memorial to the CIA funded Sally-Army tuba player.

Tory voters, Kinnock will alienate a considerable number of Labour voters. Labour will not win that way. He should think again about the Policy 've watched the Chinese events through the eyes of the British media. And I'm sceptical about what I watch on British television.

For the first time in years, for example, their coverage of the May Day march in Moscow did not concentrate on arms, rockets and tanks, but on the workers. There has been no change in the parade itself, but they concentrated on a different aspect of it.

I can well understand student unrest in China. But I am suspicious of the movement in the same way I'm suspicious of other movements boosted by the British media - Solidarnosc, the activity in Georgia. I wonder how many people there are in there from the CIA trying to stir up a counterrevolution.

It may well be that Socialist Organiser is right about this. I can well understand the feelings of Chinese students wanting to make progress. But I don't believe anything i hear from the British media, and I'd like to know more before I express a firm opinion.

Paul Whetton is a member of Manton NUM, South Yorkshire. The last "Whetton's Week' described him, by mistake, as secretary of Manton NUM. Sorry! 3y Clive Bradley Argentina's general election next Sunday, 14 May, looks set to return the Peronists to power for the first time since they were overthrown by the military coup of 1976.

Rumours of a further coup in the event of a Peronist victory are widespread, and the bourgeoisie is frantically changing its money into American dollars.

Why the panic? The political programme of Carlos Saul Menem, candidate of the Peronist 'Justicialist" ParEduardo is not very different from that of Angeloz the ruling Radicals. The difference between the two parties is in their social base.

The Peronists are a peculiarity of Argentinian history, a fusion of rightwing (some would say semi-fascist) nationalist politics and the organised labour movement. Juan Peron, who first became president in 1946, managed to co-opt the powerful trade unions to the nationalist state. During his period as Minister of Labour in the early 1940s, he had dished out concessions to the working class, gaining support to the extent that when he was sacked by the military in 1945 there was a general strike to demand his reinstatement.

Workers' living standards rose — and the trade unions became closely tied to the state. Peronism became the dominant ideology of the Argentinian workers, wiping out earlier socialist and anarchist traditions, and remains so today. It is a movement which combines reliance on state patronage with militant trade union action under heavy control from the bureaucracy.

After a long period in exile, Peron returned to power in the early 1970s, and was succeeded after his death by his second wife Isabela. But then, even radical guerilla organisations like the Montoneros were claiming the Peronist mantle.

Some independent working-class politics was emerging by then, although sometimes Peronistinfluenced. The workers were very militant. In 1976, to end deepening political crisis, the army staged a coup.

The regime that followed was one of the most bloody in the history of a continent drenched in blood. Thousands of people "disappeared', never to be found.

The Falklands/Malvinas war of 1982, launched to avert a strike wave, proved a military disaster. The military regime fell. Elections were held in 1983, and the Peronists, still led by Isabela Peron, were defeated by Raul Alfonsin's Radicals.

There have been several unsuccessful coup attempts against Alfonsin, and Argentinian politics remain dominated by the prospect of military intervention. The last junta's 'dirty war against op position is a very fresh memory.

And the ruling class is jittery, afraid of the consequences of a Menem victory, not so much for what Menem intends as for the effects on workers' expectations. There have been big strikes over the last few years, and a growth of rank and file organisation independent to a degree of the Peronist bureaucracy.

To the left of the Justicialist Party stands the United Left, a coalition of FRAL (the Communist Party) and MAS, the Movement to Socialism founded by the late Nahuel Moreno, one of the most prominent figures in post-war would-be Trotskyism.

The United Left calls for wage increases linked to the cost of living; opening the books of the banks: nationalisation of the banks; and suspension of payments on the foreign debt. It also calls for Argentina to seize the Falklands.

It is not the first time the MAS has managed to form an electoral bloc with the CP. MAS literature these days carries almost no criticism of the CP, and simply boosts itself as a participant of United Left. Generally, MAS's politics tend to be quite right wing and nationalist-oriented.

Over the past weeks, Latin America has seen an enormous wave of industrial militancy, from Peru Colombia, Mexico and Venezuela. In Brazil, 35 millions workers struck in April, and strikes have continued.

Argentinian workers need our solidarity to ward off any coup attempt. A Peronist victory would hardly be a step forward for the working class, but any attempt to overthrow Menem by the army must be fought.

----- pull-quotes -----

Safety g WHET TON'S WEEK

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 401

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →