Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

How to fight the anti-union laws

Socialist Organiser no. 401, 11 May 1989 · scan p. 3 · about 852 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Last Friday, a judge ruled the London Underground workers' strike out of order.

Members of the rail union NUR had voted 7-1 for a strike. But the judge said the ballot paper was badly worded.

Port bosses are taking the dockers' union to court to have their strike ruled unlawful too. Their argument is that whatever the ballot papers say the strike is actually political, against the Government's abolition of the Dock Labour Scheme.

Almost every strike is unlawful these days. Workers can and do defy the law - health workers' and postal workers' strikes were unlawful, but never came to court — but defy it we usually must to do anything effective.] There are several laws, which between them outlaw 'secondary' picketing and 'secondary' strike action (ie action by workers not directly in dispute with a particular company; outlaw mass pickets; outlaw 'political' strikes; make the closed shop extremely difficult to enforce; make spontaneous or quickly-decided action impossible by insisting upon the slow process of balloting; interfere in various ways with the autonomy of trade unions. They have exposed unions to the threat of having all their resources and assets seized.

For the most part, the trade unions allowed these laws to be put into effect without serious opposition. The Industrial Relations Act of the early 1970s was made unworkable by trade union action. These current laws seem far more formidable.

When the 1982 Act was introduced, there was small-scale trade union agitation, but absolutely no action. Individual unions had their assets seized without significant or effective solidarity action from other unions or the TUC.

The defeat of the NGA ANCH BAKIDS-CYC WiDerk KÜRIKIRN Photo: John Smith, Profile. to hit with the law. There have been lots of 'unlawful' short unofficial strikes without legal action. But serious, long unofficial disputes are a different matter.

The trade union leaders will be pushed (by the courts) to put a stop to the strike. Remember the P&O dispute: just the National Union of Seamen declaring the strike unofficial was not enough. The union leaders have to convince the judge they were actively trying to stop the strike. And an unofficial strike means strikers will not get strike pay where otherwise they might.

Getting round the law by unotficial actions is all right for short protest actions, but no answer in long disputes.

So very often there is a stark choice: the unions either accept their action will be ruled unlawful, pull out the stops to win, and mobilise solidarity; or they surrender without a fight.

If the unions fight, we can win. A single small union on its own can't beat the courts; but the whole TUC, or several big unions, certainly can. Consider the alarm created by the prospect of two or three big groups of workers striking simultaneously over pay this summer. The unions still have great power, if they will mobilise it.

Victory can never be guaranteed. But at worst defeat after a fight is better than abject surrender.

Now there are better conditions for fighting than there have been in a long time. There is a revival in strike activity - the biggest since the defeat of the miners.

The best time to defy the law is when the trade union movement looks strong. Moreover, the union laws are increasingly unpopular: even people who supported their introduction now feel the Tories have 'gone too far' '. And in the wake of their Vale of Glamorgan fiasco, the lories must be worried about popularity.

So the time to defy the law is now. If the Tories can be forced to back down once, the laws will be increasingly useless to them. Such an achievement will not be easy. But the trade union movement has no choice. agreements was launched not by the Tories but by the TUC, in early 1972; but the Tories then used the formula to try to tie the unions in to wage controls.

The Tories were trying to damp down, obstruct, diffuse and divert a great wave of industrial militancy which had already broken their previous efforts at wage controls and made their Industrial Relations Act unworkable. To agitate for a full sliding scale in place of their half sliding scale, instead of opposing the whole affair, would have played into their hands.

Times are different today. In fact their threshhold agreements of 1972-3 rebounded nastily on the bosses, producing big wage rises in 1974 as inflation rose to levels that no-one had expected.

Since then bosses have been much more wary about anything like a sliding scale; and its value for workers has been much clearer. Over the years since the runaway inflation of 19745 and 1979-80, bosses in many countries have fought hard to get rid of sliding scale agreements dating from the '50s or the '60s.

Working class confidence is reviving today; but we do not have anything like the great industrial offensives of the early '70s. Demands which can begin to knit together unity and map out a solid defensive position are at a premium. The sliding scale is one of those.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 401

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →