2 WINSTON SILCOTT How Winston Sil was framed
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-05-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
The students at the London School of Economics who elected Winston Silcott as their honorary President were not sick, evil or seeking attention.
They were concerned to highlight what Lord Gifford called the worst miscarriage of justice in a British jury trial this decade. Yet leading figures not only in the government but also in the Labour Party rounded on the students, and the National Union of Students tried its best to distance itself from the LSE student union.
It is doubtful whether any of these people have read the Burnham Report, the result of an extensive investigation into the Broadwater Farm trials by Judge Margaret Burnham and Professor Lennot Hinds from the United States. If they had I doubt whether they would have been so quick to condemn.
The Report is a damning indictment of the trial and raises serious doubt about the validity of Winston Silcott's conviction for the murder of PC Blakelock. It justifies the calls for a retrial, and it justifies electing Winston Silcott, if only to draw attention to his plight.
The Report highlights inconsistencies and weaknesses in the evidence against not only Silcott but the other defendants: Mark Braithwaite, Engin Raghip and the juveniles X, Y and Z.
All the defendants accused the police of denying them access to legal advice and using threats to try to force confessions out of them.
The court was highly critical of the way the police treated the juveniles and X, Y and Z were all discharged by the court on the murder charge. The others, however, were found guilty.
The prosecution could find no witness to say they saw Raghip kill PC Blakelock. He had alibi witnesses to say he was at home, but they were rejected by the Jury.
The police interrogated Raghip on 10 occasions for a total of 15 hours, without granting his legal right to have a solicitor.
Magistrates ordered that he should have a solicitor present during interviews after his bail hearing. There were four subsequent interviews at which no solicitor was present, despite one solicitor leaving his phone number with the custodial officer.
Raghip was described by one solicitor who eventually got to see him as "confused and needing assistance"
The Burnham Report said that statements made under these conditions should not have been allowed before a jury.!
Braithwaite was similarly denied access to a solicitor. He also had alibi witnesses to say he was at a friend's house. The prosecution could bring no evidence to corroborate his alleged admission that he had assaulted an officer with a two foot bar. No witnesses, yet found guilty - life imprisonment.
Silcott's case raises even more doubt since the police were unable even to get a confession, despite numerous interviews. Their only evidence is an ambiguous statement he is alleged to have made in his final interview with police.
He was shown photos of other people and asked "Did you murder PC Blakelock?" '. He is said to have broken down and replied "You ain't got no evidence. Those kids will never go to court. No one will talk to you. You can't keep me away from them"
When he was charged with murder he is said to have repeated No one will give evidence against me"
Even if this statement was made, (Sillcott denied making it), it alone could never be evidence of murder. But it was adequate for the jury.
There were no witnesses despite the most extensive investigation by police, and the only people who claimed to have seen Silcott on the scene were the three juveniles whose statements were ruled 'not admissable' because of the way the police extracted them.
The Burnham Report concluded: "At best, the statements made by Silcott were ambiguous. Far less than the unqualified admissions which the police were able to secure from the juveniles, the statements are in the nature of a challenge to the police to prove their case against him.
"The criminal justice system permits a defendant to say to the government: 'You've charged me. Now prove it'. Indeed, that challenge is an explicit and fundamental tenent of a system main target of the police investigation. There was strong pressure to convict.
The Press were very hostile towards Silcott and assumed he was All Winston Silcott asks for is justice. The courts, ho wever, have continually refused • allow an Appeal.
The government wot ild like us to
----- pull-quotes -----
FR TRI