Basic Rights
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-05-04Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 15
For a fighting Br RES TORE AT BA SIC GCH RIG HTS GCHO much more over GCHQ notorious staffing disputes of 1982 in Birmingham and Oxford DHSS are still remembered by many activists). To many ordinary members in the offices, there seems little difference in a year of "left' control and a year of 'right' control. The result, too often, can be apathy and cynicism.
What, then, is the nature of the problem? And what needs to be done to build a genuine rank and file movement in CPSA, capable of overcoming the problems and shortcomings of the present Broad Left?
The biggest single group within the Broad Left consists of supporters of the Militant newspaper. Militant places great emphasis on capturing the apparatus of unions, and a good deal of effort and money goes into this: ie, into winning elections. -Supporters of Socialist Organiser also believe that elections are important...but not the all-important aspect of a left-wing movement.
Militant have their mirror image in the Broad Left too, in the form of the SWP. The comrades of the Socialist Workers Party are not too concerned about winning elections. They wish to organise at a rank and tile level, quite often being ready to preach pessimism about what can be achieved during a period of "downturn' in the class struggle. Their aim can, however, be more narrowly pinpointed as the expansion of their own sect. Their activities are geared towards this, rather than a genuine effort to create a broad-based movement.
Between them, as they pull in their own separate directions, the Militant and the SWP stifle the prospects of a healthy broad rank and file movement. Nor is this some tragic accident, but the inevitable result of the politics of pursued by these two organisations.
The problem is that both the Militant and the SWP start from their own political projects rather than internal developments within the union. They are both building white elephants.
Rather than working in the real movement as it exists, both attempt to build a movement in their own image.
As a result, neither really take on the power of the bureaucracy. The SWP explicitly, because they refuse to challenge for positions, the Militant implicitly because they actually work to take over the existing bureaucratic machine with just a few minor alterations, and use the machine as a platform for vapid propaganda. In this, the Militant are very reminiscent of the Communist Party in the '60s and "70s.
The effectiveness of the Broad Left is thus reduced by the way in which it is regarded by some of its