Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

AIDS research on the wrong track?

Socialist Organiser no. 400, 4 May 1989 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 1,453 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

book full of untruths, A offending against orthodoxy, whose publication may lead to deaths? No, not that one! This one, entitled *AIDS: The HIV Myth', by journalist Jad Adams, argues, against virtually all scientific and medical opinion, that the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) does not cause AIDS.

Since much effort in the fight against AIDS is focused on preventing the spread of HIV and in finding ways of hampering its progress inside the body, this claim is not trivial.

Adams' book supports the assertions of Peter Duesberg, a biochemist at the University of California, Berkeley, that there is no direct evidence that HIV causes AIDS and that evidence that it doesn't is ignored by an "AIDS establishment" of scientists and doctors whose reputations and livelihoods presumably depend on the links between HIV and AIDS.

Duesberg has claimed that HIV cannot be detected in everybody with AIDS and neither can antibodies to HIV. He thinks the immune systems of AIDS sufferers are suppressed by something else and HIV is just one of the various opportunistic organisms that infect people with depressed immunity.

Duesberg says that HIV has the wrong structure to cause the damage found in AIDS. He has even said that he would be willing to infect himself with HIV, so confident is he that it doesn't cause AIDS (he hasn't done so yet!).

Duesberg's views were formed some time ago, being the subject of a television documentary about two years ago. But if he was correct, we would find ourselves right back at the stage where AIDS was first recognised.

The consensus among AIDS experts ("the AIDS establishment") is that Duesberg's theories and, still more, Adams' book, are dangerous nonsense. Journalist Duncan Campbell of New Statesman and Society has scrutinised the book and recently debated with Adams the claims made in it. Writing in New Scientist, Campbell identifies several unfounded claims in the book.

Adams claims that the *AIDS establishment" has conspired to avoid investigating the real cause of AIDS. As evidence, he states that since 1985, less than 7% of AIDS cases in New York and San Francisco have been tested for HIV."

This is based on a circular from the Center for Disease Control in Atlanta which says that less than 7% (in New York and San Francisco have been reported with HIV antibody test results, conpared with greater than 60% in other areas."

But it is the reporting that is faully, not that the tests are not done. Three leading AIDS treatment centres in San Francisco said a couple of weeks ago that they had tested all their 5,000 plus patients and knew of none without HIV antibodies.

Adams then claims that most US AIDS cases are not checked for HIV and that therefore "we cannot be sure what they are carrying. Virtually anything could be causing their disease." Once again, Once again, the claim is untrue.

Adams uses research data from five years ago to show that HIV can be found in only 50% of AIDS patients. But far higher rates of detection (up to 100%) are now reported, indicating that earlier failures to detect HIV represented backwardness in techniques rather than absence of viruses.

Adams himself ignores evidence contradicting his theory. Thus, there is much evidence that development of immune deficiency follows HIV infection, though Adams would predict the opposite. For the record, Adams thinks AIDS is a "behavioural disease", probably caused by a virus.

He told the audience at the debate with Campbell that he did not plan to check the accuracy of what he had written. What I find more disturbing than Adams' standards is the behaviour of his publishers, Macmillan, who have ignored all requests to correct inaccuracies themselves.

Macmillan originally claimed that they had had the manuscript checked by a specialist nominated by the respected science journal Nature (owned by Macmillan). They told Campbell the specialist had approved publication. Nature said this was untrue and that they had not even seen proofs of the book.

Retracting this claim, Macmillan then said that neither Nature nor Nursing Times (another Macmillan publication) had seen the book before publication.

This was also untrue. NT had seen the book and got a report on it from a cancer specialist. This report had contained criticisms of the book.

In Macmillan's publicity for the book, they went even further than Adams, claiming for example that "many AIDS patients have no trace of the virus HIV...or even of antibodies to it." Once again, these assertions were not checked and would appear on current evidence to be untrue.

Macmillan have attempted to present publication of the book as a public service. Their editorial director denied that the book was an exploitative one, telling New Scientist: *I don't believe that the public should be kept totally in the dark about debates going on in the scientific community" '. As a Macmillan leaflet claims, "it is believed by an increasing number of scientists that HIV is the wrong type of virus te cause a fatal disease."

But the argument is spurious. There is no debate. The scientists believing that HIV does not cause AIDS are a tiny static minority. Adams, when challenged, could name only six, none recent recruits to the view, only one of whom, Duesberg, actually supports the thesis of Adams' book.

AIDS experts and others have expressed concern at the possible effects of the book. Charles Farthing, a leading AIDS researcher and doctor at St Stephen's Hospital, London, said: "There is no valid science in these claims. If people are foolish enough to believe this, then it will lead to more deaths. It causes distress to patients, because they are led to distrust doctors and...may refuse medication and treatment."

Chris Smith MP, a founder of the all-party Parliamentary AIDS Group, said he was "deeply concerned about the accuracy of the wild allegations and errors that appear in this book" • Tony Whithead, founder of Britain's leading AIDS charity, the Terrence Higgins Trust, described the book as "totally irresponsible" . It "makes up the news that people want to hear" in order to give them false hope. The book was "an undisguised attack on people with AIDS."

Macmillan have gone on the offensive against the book's critics, demanding, for instance, right of reply to Duncan Campbell's forthcoming review for New Scientist. Incredibly, Macmillan have met calls for the book or for their publicity material to be checked for accuracy and corrected with the hypothesis that, in the wake of the Salman Rushdie affair, such calls were a threat to "solidarity in the cause of freedom of expression".

my, finds herself pregnant. Her Lover has been shot by the Whites.

She is reluctant to give up life on horseback, but finds herself billeted in the home of a poor Jewish artisan and his family to await the birth of her child.

At first there is mutual resentment - the Commissar at having to leave her unit and the family at having her foisted on them. But gradually, Clavdia comes to appreciate the warmth and closeness of the Jewish family who end up by adopting her. After the birth, Clavdia leaves her child with the family and goes off to rejoin her unit.

It was the Jewish elements of the film that caused its troubles. It was finished just after the six-day war of 1967, when Israel inflicted a terrible defeat on a block of Arab states and occupied the West Bank. The USSR broke diplomatic relations with The authorities at the Gorky Studios insisted that Askoldov remove the premonition scene where yello-starred Jews are led off to the concentration camps and that the family in the film should not be Jewish. Askoldov refused, whereupon he was locked out of the editing room, the film confiscated and Askoldov expelled from the 'Communist' Party.

It was the end of his career as a film maker.

The film probably draws Askoldov's own experience of being sheltered by a Jewish family (later shot by the Germans), during the period of the Stalinist purges. His father was liquidated by the secret police in the year of his birth and his mother imprisoned when he was five years old.

Because of the post-war surge of anti-semitism in the USSR and Eastern Europe, Askoldov's researches into Jewish tradition were hampered: the USSR state archives had destroyed most of its Jewish material!

The film was set in the past, when the Whites were the anti-semites, but its exploration of Jewish experience was simply too much for the authorities to bear. "The Commissar' opens at the Lumiere, St Martin's Lane, London WC2 on May screenings around the country selected cinemas.

Scan page 11

nal Union of Railwayme

----- pull-quotes -----

LESTALARNES COLUIMN

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 400

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →