Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

How American socialists faced war and repression

Socialist Organiser no. 400, 4 May 1989 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 1,686 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Trotskist leaders Rose Karsner and James P Cannon in the reviews four books James P Cannon Fifty years ago this year F the second world imperialList war began. This came as no surprise to revolutionary Marxists. Since the early 1930s the exiled Russian revolutionary leader, Leon Trotsky, and his political supporters worldwide had warned of fresh inter-imperialist conflicts breaking out and engulfing the whole world in an orgy of bloodletting and destruction.

Indeed, Lenin and Trotsky had viewed the world war of 1914-18 as ushering in a new epoch signalling the decay of capitalism - an epoc characterised as one of wars and revolutions.

One of the most important single documents in the arsenal of revolutionary Marxism, analysing the Leninist attitude to wars in the era of imperialism, was written at this time by Trotsky, War and the Fourth International, published as a pamphlet in June 1934.

This and other such writings are programmatic documents - ones articulating a strategic line for revolutionary groups in the lead up to, and outbreak of, war.

There is little readily available in English on how such revolutionary groups carried out revolutionary politics in practice during the Second World War.

However we are fortunate in what we do have - five books that record the history of the American Socialist Workers Party through the war period. Four of them, covering the years 1940-47, are written by one of the principal leaders of American Trotskyism, James P Cannon; the other, Fighting Racism in World War II, covering the period from September 1939 to September 1945, is a collection of articles, pamphlets, letters and resolutions on wartime Black and anti-racist struggles from the press of the SWP. "The SWP War I' This is a collection of writings and speeches - around half of them for SWP members rather than the general public - from the period April 1940 to December 194 begins with an appraisal of the SWP after it suffered the major split of over 40% of the membership, led by James Burnham, Max Shachtman, and Martin Abern.

In 1939-40 there had been a sixmonth-long faction fight over attitudes to the USSR, but also over fundamental principles of Leninism. At the end of that fight, Cannon confidently points the way forward for the SWP's preparation. for the war - the class struggle and a deeper penetration of the workers' mass movement.

Notable, and essential reading, are five contributions on the military policy adopted by the SWP (known as the Proletarian or American Military Policy). The SWP considered that the war was basically a battle between rival imperialist looters over shares of the booty. Yet the SWP also wanted to get across to workers who wanted to fight Hitler. So instead of just saying "the war is imperialist - oppose it", the SWP said: "Yes, we want to fight Hitler. But we can't trust the capitalist government to do it. We need a fight for workers' control and a workers' government.

The book includes statements on the war and on the US's entry to it after the Japanese bombing of the colonial naval base at Pearl Harbour. Some socialists felt that the "proletarian military policy' led to tactics overshadowing a prompt and clear anti-war, anti-US government position in the SWP's publications Cannon argued that more tactically-amied articles had to be considered together with the Minneapolis Trial statements (see Socialism on Trial) and the earlier publication of the Manifesto of the Fourth International on the Imperialist War and the Proletarian Revolution. His defence of the party's "revolutionary defeatism" and what it was, makes interesting reading.

Also here are proposals for a Labour Party campaign: a speech after the formal, and cynical, dissolution of the Communist International by Stalin on the coming revolution and prospects for workers' internationalism; and articles on how to choose a new revolutionary leadership (which was necessary because 18 prominent leaders of the SWP were jailed in 1943 for supporting workers' strikes in war times). The book ends with a speech on the eve of Cannon's, and the other 17 comrades' , imprisonment. 'Socialism on Trial"

In June 1941, acting on a request from the bureaucratic Teamster Union leaders, Democrat President Roosevelt authorised the FBI to raid SWP offices in Minneapolis.

In July, 28 SWP members and leaders of the Minneapolis branch of the Teamster Union were charged under an old 1861 Civil War statute and the newly adopted Smith Act (1940) - which made the mere advocacy of certain ideas a federal crime.

The Minneapolis Teamsters, long a thorn in the side of the union bureaucracy since the great strike battles of the '30s, had refused to abandon class struggle politics and to refrain from attacking Roosevelt's imperialist war policies.

In a trial lasting six weeks, 18 of the 28 were convicted and sentenced to 12 to 18 months in prison. The trial, applauded by the Communist Party, was the first brought under the openly anti-labour movement Smith Act.

This book is the official court record of Cannon's testimony as National Secretary of the SWP. It is a great little book, popularising the ideas of socialism and Marxist principle from a courtroom dock. Serialised in The Militant newspaper (successor to the Socialist Appeal and sold in pamphlet form, its message reached out to the masses of the US population amid the increasing tide of patriotism and war clamour.

An appendix includes a criticism by a leader of the Spanish Trotskyists, exiled in Mexico, written in early 1942 with a reply by Cannon. "Letters from Prison' The conviction of the 18 was announced on the very day America's ruling class formally declared war - 8 December 1941.

An appeal against the convictions lasted a further two years before the 18 were finally imprisoned. Cannon was approaching his 54th birthday when he and his 17 comrades entered gaol on New Year's Eve 1943.

Throughout the 180-plus letters included here - most of them written to his partner, Rose Karsner — Cannon's irrepressible drive to build and shape the SWP shines out. Despite prison censorship and rules on letter writing and the receiving of mail, we learn of how closely Cannon and his comrades follow the war; struggles of their 1940s foreign comrades; labour struggles; and the development and expansion of the SWP.

Between glimpses into his personal life, and his self-established prison educational routine, Cannon touches upon: party education, field-organising, leadership, the revolutionary newspaper, trade unionism, Stalinism and Internationalism, among others, in a necessarily concise and precise way. We also hear of some of the beginn ings of what was to become another faction fight with two fellow gaoled prisoners - Albert Goldman, the SWP's lawyer, and Felix Morrow, the SWP's newspaper and magazine editor - two years later.

His last letter reiterates a task of all revolutionaries: "Our great misunadulterated Marxism. POpularise "The struggle for Socialism in the American Century' Three themes dominate this collection covering the period February 1945 (from Cannon's release from prison) to June 1947: the USSR, the fight with Goldman and Morrow and relations with Shachtman's Workers Party; and the prospects for revolution in the USA. There is also an outstanding article on Stalinists in the trade unions, 'American Stalinism and Anti-Stalinism' The background is the ending of the war and the new relationship American imperialism finds itself in with the rest of world capitalism and the expansionism of the USSR. The period also included a massive industrial strike wave — the largest in US history - which lasted until the beginning of 1947.

Critics with hindsight have pointed to these years as ones where Cannon and the SWP, througn adherence to a rigid and formalistic framework of Trotsky's thinking begin to lose a grip on reality. However, the "American Theses' of 1946, which are the tocus or inis criticism, have the purpose of restating the need and role of a revolutionary party in the immediate period - reiterating the principles of Leninism to the many new working class members recruited to the SWP since 1944.

Cannon did not waver from the view that revolution was not a perspective for war-torn and devastated Europe and Asia alone, but also in victorious America — the heartland of capitalism - and in the so-called (by the bourgeois media) "American Century'. And it was the fundamental duty of revolutionaries in the USA to fight for this.

We can criticise his judgement now, and regard his analysis of the political and economic factors of the time as wildly over-optimistic, but we should not forget that the world 40 or more years ago was characterised by uncertainty.

The American ruling class was uncertain of the road to restabilise world capitalism - to clamp down on workers' struggles — and to contain the USSR. Remember, this was the period when the USA poured billions of dollars into Europe and Japan to prop up capitalism (the Marshall Plan); the Cold War began; Mao's peasant armies defeated the bourgeois nationalist armies of Chiang Kai Shek; and, by 1950, American and other Western armies were fighting in Korea. Conclusion War and repression are a litmus test for any revolutionary party. We have in these volumes a heritage of revolutionary thought and practice to aid us in struggle today.

The SWP stood up to our class enemy through the war, despite the heavy blows of chauvinistic hysteria and capitalist repression, retaining the banner of proletarian internationalism.

All of Cannon's writings are accessible, written in a straightforward and often emotive manner. All of the above mentioned books come with notes and introductions giving the background to the period covered (and, particularly interesting for regular readers of Socialist Organiser, the bare bones of Goldman's and Morrow's views on the USSR).

Notes The four books above, by James P Cannon, are published in paperback Pathfinder Press. Fighting Racism in World War I!' is published by MONAD. 'War and the Fourth International' and the •Manifesto of the Fourth International on the Imperialist War and the Proletarian Revolution' can be found in 'Writings of Leon Trotsky' 1933-34, and 1939-40 respectively, published by Pathfinder Press.

sdw,a200lobuc nice, rebre

Scan page 10

10 REVIEV

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 400

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →