Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Afghanistan: we have to choose

Socialist Organiser no. 400, 4 May 1989 · scan p. 4 · about 886 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

tion Plans' of the Training Agents and the placement with a training manager was 26%.

A Department of Employment spokeswoman claims that the scheme was relatively new and experiencing teething problems.

Perhaps the DoE should ask the potential trainees' the reason for the schemes lack of success. They would find that it has more to do with the fact that trainees recieve only €10 top-up on ther normal benefit, for what the Unemployment Unit calls questionable training.

But then the government doesn't want to know about such things.

Has anyone got a spray can?

M side of the tracks, a eanwhile on the other survey published by Dan and Bradsheet, the business information company, reports that Britain's leading 100,000 companies made a median return on capital last year of 15.8 percent, up from 13.4 per cent. In plain English, profits are up a fair old wack.

Whilst sales are steady profits per employee have risen significantly. Translation: the bosses are making more money out of each worker.| The highest rates of return were in the construction industry, services and manufacturing. But author of the report, Geoffrey Smith, issues a stern warning to all those benevolent bosses who naturally want to share the profits with the workers who created them. He warns that the level of profit could be reduced by some 30% if 5% pay increases are not tied to productivity improvements.

ETITER Tony Dale insists that there between the Stalinist government in Afghanistan and the various Islamic fundamentalist groups that want to overthrow it.

We all know about the mullahs (although Tony argues that maybe a victory for the mullahs would be less ferocious than we suppose); but the Najibullah government is too responsible for the years of Russian occupation to be supported, even critically and as a stop-gap alternative. Progressives in Afghanistan have no side, and need prefer the victory of neither.

Certainly Socialist Organiser readers are familiar with the idea that in war we can oppose both sides. But I don't think it follows that such an approach is possible in any war. What did 'defeatism on both sides mean in the Iran-Iraq war, for example?

It meant that the basic argument of Iranian or Iraqi socialists would be that the oppressed of both countries should stop fighting each other and fight their own regimes instead; it meant viewing the defeat of their own' regime as a small matter if it was merely the casualty of growing international solidarity. It meant also, on the Iranian side, rejectior of Khomeini's claim to be 'defending the revolution' and exposure of the Iranian regime's fundamentally aggressive ambitions.

Following US intervention we argued, against for example the SWP, that the war had not really changed, and that the US had absolutely no intention of imposing a new regime on Iran by conquest (an analysis 100% vindicated, which the SWP might think about, incidentally).

But opposition to both (or all) governments involved in the war was based on concrete analysis of what the war was actually about; it wasn't a general expression of distaste for all concerned. We said that in the hypothetical event of an American attempt to conquer Iran, we'd be for the defence of Iran.

Surely, in Afghanistan the question of a temporary united front for defence against the mullahs is posed as an immediate, practical question What would "not taking sides' mean? In Iran, not taking sides would have meant something quite straightforward, in the first place as argument or propaganda, in the second as practical activity. Afghanistan seems to me rather different.

This is not to say that socialists have to take sides in civil wars by definition. I'm not at all sure we'd take sides in Lebanon, for example. We might ally tactically with different groups for particular short- term objectives, but our basic approach would be to find some way to reconcile the different religious or ethnic conflicts. We are basically indifferent to whether Christian or Muslim (or different Shi'ite) guerillas control bits of Beirut, or rather we don't want any of them to have control.

In Afghanistan the question is whether we are indifferent to the prospect of Islamic fundamentalist conquest of the cities, Or whether we want to see the mullahs defeated, or at least prevented from achieving such conquest. 'Not taking sides' in fact would mean surrender, in the name of political independence. In other words, while in Iran socialists would have a choice whether to take sides, in Afghanistan, it seems to me, there simply is no room for. choice.

If one argues that the regime is simply a surrogate for Russian oc. cupation, has no independent social base, and so on, the logical conclusion would seem to be not neutrality, but support for the mullahs who are leading a national liberation movement. Neutrality in that case is, little more than a suggestion however few vaguely progressio Afghans that they find the quickest route possible to some other country l Maybe the regime has no social base at all, but I find that implausi ble. There must be people who both don't want to be ruled by the mullahs and are deeply critical of the regime. But I'd be prepared tc et that our line would appeal to them more than Tony's.

Clive Bradley, South London

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 400

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →