Labour council
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-04-27Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 15
and we would be the link that is necessary to connect the two.
Thus making the trade union movement stronger, more firmly rooted in society, and more approachable and accountable to the life of the community and its wellbeing. A true and firm basis for a caring, socialist society.
As women also, we would have to adjust, not only to the aspects of feminism which need a fuller discussion and understanding if we are to succeed, but also a more concerned approach and understanding of masculinity, what this entails in our present situation, and why this concept needs to undergo a change, both for us and men.
This would perhaps be the most wide and far-reaching area of re-education ever undertaken in our society, but one which is far overdue, and one which could have the most beneficial impact upon the whole of the civilised world.
If we want to do all this, we need to start now, from where we are and with what we could most reasonably expect to achieve at this present moment. Amongst all the women's organisations, WAPC is in a unique position to be perhaps able to start this up. The strike gave many of us new confidence in ourselves, but sadly, for many others, it did not change anything.
So the proposal initially is that we re-organise and re-build our movement into a women's union, open to all women. This would not change any groups still in existence in the coalfield areas, whose struggle is now intensified, and would be in complete accord with the women's charter based on class It could in fact strengthen their work, enlarge their support, extend their influence. It would help them to link the issue of pit closures and its attendant problems to the larger problems of every community, pin pointing, with others in struggle, the utter devastation caused by Tory policies. • This article first appeared as a paper to the WAPC conference ir. 1987, and was discussed at the Women for Socialism conference in February this year.
Coulton
The first effects of the Tory White Paper on the health service are beginning to be felt in Manchester, as the chair of Central Manchester Health Authority has announced plans for the city's largest hospital complex to 'opt out' of the NHS.
This move would affect Manchester Royal Infirmary, the Royal Eye Hospital and St Mary's Hospital, which is a specialist maternity and children's hospital.
If these hospitals do opt out of the NHS it would be extremely bad news for both the health workers inconey, and local order thee day, with good patient care coming a poor second.
If the plan goes ahead, health workers will undoubtedly have to suffer worsened working conditions, and have to carry on trying to provide the services patients so badly need as already overstretched resources are cut back even further.
The people who are entitled to use the hospitals will be limited to a strict geographical area, so many in need of care will be denied access to specialist services.
But even for those who are still allowed to use the facilities, the sort of services available will change drastically. 'Efficiency' will mean an end to high-cost services like casualty units, and special baby care units - services which are of vital importance to the inner city area in which the hospit/ls are situated.
These changes will hit working class people hardest - poverty and bad housing makes you ill, but at least up to now there has been the NHS to rely on. Women and children will be especially affected as they are amongst the biggest group of hospital users.
It is frightening to think what might happen to already inadequate services like those for sick children, pregnant women and older women needing hip replacements. "Opting. out of the NHS can only mean playing with people's lives.
We have come to expect this sort of thing from the Tories - but the chair of Central Manchester District Health Authority is a Labour councillor, Ken Collis.
Local Labour Parties are calling for the expulsion of Clir. Collis from the party for his actions -Stretford Women's Section ard Moss Side ward have already pas ed resolutions to this effect.
Activists are organising lobbies of DHA meetings, and linking up with health workers fighting the opt out proposals.
The Labour Party nationally has said it will bring any hospitals which have opted out back into the NHS - this must be included in the Policy Reviews and the next manifesto.
But more than this, the Labour Party needs to fight now to make sure that no hospitals do opt out. Manchester will be the first of many unless a broad campaign is built among health workers, Labour Party rank and file and the wider community to save our hospitals.
Women are in the forefront of the fightback in Manchester both as health workers and hospital users. There is going to be a demonstration when Junior Health Minister Roger Freeman visits Manchester on 5 May.
We need to link together to show the Tories - and Tory-backed Labour councillors like Collis -that they can't get away with opting out of providing the health care services based on neet, not efficiency.
Scan page 16
Pornography available in your average newsagents shop *includes magazines specialising in sex and violence: women being humiliated and beaten, schoolgirls being stripped and whipped, pictures of punishment and interrogation with Nazi overtones...
"Their (the most popular titles) main fare is an obsessive fixation on women's open genitals and anuses, photographed close up, often pulled or stretched and posed to appear gaping, inviting sexual access.
So savs Catherine Itzin in an Observer article, publicising a new campaign — the Campaign Against Pornography and Censorship.
A campaign against both porn and censorship sounds the answer to many a socialist feminist's prayer. After all, we're in favour of freedom of speech, but also we're against pornography. Most of us find it personally offensive. Porn tells lies about women's sexuality -perpetuates pernicious myths about what we want - even what we are. Porn routinely - even the 'soft' stuff - depicts women as suborlinate, always receptive, passive, • iviting. We want to be taken, want to display ourselves. Whores, bitches on heat - that's what we all are really.
A campaign which publicly exposes these images for the rubbish they are, which explains why porn makes women angry, why we do not want it in our workplaces, this surely must be a good thing.
Sadly, though, the Campaign Against Pornography and Censorship (CPC) is not it. For sure the campaign is against censorship...except in the case of pornography.
medical and forensic literature."
Pretty tightly drawn, or so it seems. But then what about lesbian porn? Contrary to the illusions of those who present lesbian relationships as soft-focus celebrations of woman-centredness, lesbian sexuality can be violent, aggressive and feed off power relations. Some lesbian porn depicts this too - indeed, for the past few years much of the lesbian movement has been bogged down in a discussion of the rights and wrongs of lesbian sadomasochism. Would we ban lesbian porn that didn't fit with our idealised picture of full equality?
What is maybe more worrying than semi-theological • discussion about where we draw the line is the way the case for banning porn is being argued by the CPC.
A resolution, sponsored by the CPC, and passed amidst much controversy at the recent conference of the National Council for Civil Liberties (NCCL - now called Liberty') argues *there is sufficient evidence to say that it is highly likely that a link exists between certain kinds of pornography and harm to women, both in terms of the aggregate increase in sexual violence against women, some individual sexual attacks and the subordinate, unequal status of women."
Phew! There's a lot there. But one or two fairly unsubstantiated assertions leap out of the page.
The question of the "link' between porn and sexual attacks on women is a controversial one. Those who argue that such a link is "highly likely' rest on the evidence of one research programme, carried out in the US, during which a cross-section of men, under controlled conditions, were questioned on their attitudes towards women and sexual violence before and after being exposed to pornographic imposure desensitised Prolonged exindicates that women were treated brutally. For sure legally they were the property of men. Rape was a crime against the husband or father — not against the woman herself.
Franco's Spain banned porn — do we think women had more equality under fascism? Is it likely that sexual violence decreased?
In Iran today, porn is outlawed. And yet we all know of the terrible situation of Iranian women. In prison, women are routinely raped - virgins are always raped prior to execution, so that they do not go to heaven. Rape here is used as a tool of political repression — not simply misogynist repression, but part of repressing political oppositionists. It's nothing to do with porn — it's to do with a society which rests on the severe subordination of women.
In her article, Catherin Itzin quotes with approval the view of the US Court of Appeal, which said in 1985: *Pornography is central in creating and maintaining sex as a basis of discrimination...
But clearly not. Women have been oppressed for thousands of years. In different societies - different times and places — women's oppression has taken different forms. Porn has sometimes figured largely, sometimes hardly at all. Is porn central to women's secondary position at work?
For sure porn can be used to make a workplace uninhabitable for women. It can be used as part and parcel of a campaign of sexual harassment to drive a woman out of her job. As such it should be fought management should have guidelines, unions should be prepared to put up a fight about it.
But more central to perpetuating women's secondary status at work is the position of women in the home, lack of childcare, lack of opportunity, which drive women into low-paid, part-time work; the assumptions that women should be financially supported by men, that our job is to keep home and look after the kids; that we work for 'pin money' . Our unions are not geared to our needs - so often we cannot fight to improve our position in the workplace. This, and not porn, is the key.
It is profoundly misleading and politically disorienting to argue, or even to imply, that to ban porn would clear the ground for a significant improvement in women's position in all areas of life. It won't.
We have to organise, to fight, to argue on all fronts. And no, this isn't sidestepping the specific issue of pornography, it's attempting to find a way in which we can make real gains, lasting gains. Banning porn, however carefully we go about it, won't do that for us.
----- pull-quotes -----
council opts defending NH