Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Come back Noah

Socialist Organiser no. 399, 27 April 1989 · scan p. 10 · about 864 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Of Ark, an environmental pressure group, is correct in its predictions, we may live to regret the wholesale closure of the British shipbuilding industry.

Their estimate for the rise in sea-level if the greenhouse effect' (GHE) continues unchecked could leave us looking like Noah's imprudent neighbours. According to Ark, average sea-levels could be 5.7 metres (nearly 20 feet) higher by 2050. This would be due to a partial melting of the polar ice caps as average temperatures rose. This would flood large areas of Brisea-level. Higher seas would also accelerate the erosion of the cliffs which is already threatening residential areas on the East Sussex coast.

Ark claims that *Parliament may have to move to Birmingham because vast areas of central London will have Ark's predictions lose some of their force when it is revealed that they are merely the most extreme of a range of possibilities arrived at by geographer Michael Tooley of Durham University. If all goes well, the predicted rise in sealevel won't come for 300 years. Tooley's estimates lie outside the current consensus for the scientific community. Their estimates range from rises of 20cm (8 inches) to 1.4m (4 to 5 feet).

But these figures are not to be sniffed at, particularly in conjunction with other predictons for the GHe One of these is that summer rainfall in Britain will be reduced. Coupled with the greater rates of evaporation in a falls of 40% in the contents of reservoirs. Apart from making water scarce (and more expensive, under private monopoly control!); there would be higher concentrations of pollutants. This is because a similar amount of toxic chemicals would be dissolved ina smaller volume of water.

On the topic of the GHE, the government is now speaking with a forked tongue. On the one hand, Mrs Thatcher has publicly embraced the environmencredit for the work of British scientists in unravelling many of the details of the GHE and other environmental benefits.

One mildly amusing consequence of this 'green' enthusiasm was the way the United Nations Environmental Programme got £1½ million more than intended following a disagreement between Mrs Thatcher and Environment Minister Nicholas Ridley at a press conference. She announced a doubling of Britain's contribution to UNEP. Since this turned out to be ¼ million more than she thought, UNEP was the beneficiary of her unwillingness to back Mrs Thatcher was also hosting a daylong seminar at Chequers this week to discuss environmental issues, particularly the GHE. This coincided with the Department of the Environment's three-day meeting to discuss priorities in environmental research.

On the other hand, the Department of Energy has rejected demands from scientists for action now to reduce carbon dioxide emissions. In evidence to the Commons Environment Committee, the Natural Environment Research Council called for more research coupled with action now to reduce the chances of harm from the GHE. Given the uncertainty in the predictions, but the seriousness of the situation should they prove correct, this is the only prudent and responsible course.

In contrast was the statement of the Department of Energy's junior minister, Baroness Hooper. She referred to 'wild' speculation (ie. the broad consensus of climate scientists) and said that it would be ten to fifteen years before we knew for sure what was going to happen. There was therefore no need to take any measures till then!

The US Environment Protection Agency has assessed the implications of doing precisely what the DoEn proposes, ie. nothing till about 2010. The result could be a 40% greater warming of the world by 2050.

The EPA suggests various measures to cut CO' emissions, such as:

• increasing the fuel efficiency of vehicles (to 80 miles per gallon for small cars); • increasing the heating efficiency of homes and offices (the most efficient use less than a third of the average);

• switching more to solar, hydroelectric, geo-thermal and nuclear power.

The folly of the wait-and-see approach is highlighted by two other contributions to the debate. The CEGB has told the Commons Energy Committee that it will be emitting a quarter more CO* from its power stations by 2005 unless the government intervenes to modify the operation of its beloved market forces. And scientists at the Meteorological Office at Bracknell, praised by Mrs Thatcher as a leading centre for GHE research, have pointed out that there is a considerable lag of up to 100 years between the emission of CO and its effect in warming the world. Thus, the present mild warming could be the effect of CO emissions in the last century. Since emissions this century are far higher (and still increasing), the wilder' predictions could turn out to be quite near the truth by the middle of next century. This is because the oceans tend to absorb about half of all CO released. But as world temperatures rise, the oceans will absorb less and may even start releasing CO*, perhaps leading to a runaway warming.

I'm thinking of buying before the prices go up!

Green Socialist Students Conference Saturday 6 Masy, from 11.30 at Leeds University Union Registration: Ron Strong, 28 Richmond Mount, Leeds L56 1DG (0532 781900)

----- pull-quotes -----

LES HEARN S COLUMN

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 399

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →