Tragedy of a woman artist
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-04-27Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
reviews 'Camille Claudel"
amille Claudel' is a major C film, probably the first to pressures that women artists undergo in their struggle to produce and sell their work in a world dominated by men.
Camille Claudel was a nineteenth century sculptress who came from a middle class French background. Her brother Paul, a diplomat, became a well known French poet. Other contemporaries included Zola, Debussy, Balzac and, most importantly, the sculptor Auguste Rodin, who became her teacher, then her lover.
Camille's family were unusual. Her mother didn't like her sculpting but her father and brother were initially supportive, especially her father, who moved the family from semi rural life in Villeneuve so that Camille could work in Paris.
By the time Camille meets Rodin in the film, he is already one of the giants of his age. No longer struggling, he is established, famous, sought after, already beginning to coast on his fame.
Camille is shocked that he seems to prefer the adulation of the world to serious work of his own. Camille, on the other hand, is drive, passionate about her work, embracing the clay she sculpts like a lover. When she becomes Rodin's apprentice, she strives to do her best and, in turn, inspires him. He is dazzled by her ability and moved by her passion for her work. Through her he can recapture something of the exhilaration for sculpture that he has begun to lose in the bustle of the world. The film presents Rodin as vain, eager to cut a figure in the great from his work, since he spends his time, as Camille warns him, with people who care nothing for his work, but hand around him because of his fame, the name he has made for himself. The relationship Camille and Rodin develop becomes a counter attraction to the temptations of vanity and prestige.
Shared work leads to shared passion and Rodin proclaims Camille the most desirable woman in the world. With Camille's very real beauty and talent, it is easy to see why she fascinated him. It is perhaps harder to accept her love for him, since he never courts her with his talent. We never see her in awe of him as a sculptor, but only in love with him as a man.
Yet the film conveys brilliantly the emotional battleground of their relationship, their passion, their desire and their competitiveness. The performances of Gerard Depardieu and Isabelle Adjani are so good that you never doubt that real feeling exists between Camille and Rodin. Camille is marked for doom. She is the typical Romantic artist, isolated, withdrawn, difficult, caring for nothing but her art, and great love affair. As her relationship with Rodin founders, she withdraws more and more into a world of her own. Her studio becomes more and more crowded with unsold work. As an artist she no longer seeks an audience; the work has become an end in itself.
Nemesis strikes at Camille from without and within. The film shows Rodin incapable of accepting her both as a woman and as an artist who might equal or even surpass his own achievement. And his rejection brings all her insecurities to the surface, unbalancing her.
Believing him jealous of her ability, Camille creates a paranoid myth of an all-powerful man out to destroy her. Rodin becomes the untroubles. Though Rodin is shown as both vain and cowardly, he is definitely not the villain of the piece. The film presents him fairly honestly, with some justification for his actions.
And it doesn't present Camille as simply the victim of male cruelty.
Cruelty there certainly was, but Camille herself was flawed - too proud, too insular, too competitive, too driven, to exist easily side by side with another towering talent.
Camille's family are implicated in her later breakdown. Her mother represents conventional society, a world that denied women any self expression, any desires beyond home and children. Camille's brother Paul, though her earliest confidant, eventually turns against her. As he converts to Catholicism, his soul seems to shrivel within him; he can no longer pity Camille or try to understand her. His cold eyes condemn the waste of her gifts.
The pressures on Camille were many. For a woman to be an artist in the 1880s was rare enough. For her then to turn her back on her family to live unmarried with Rodin was even more shocking. She lived as a veritable outcast, having lost even the goodwill of her father and brother. The strains on her sapped her early drive and confidence, and when she was most vulnerable she had no one left to turn to.
It is a truly tragic story, shows the destruction of someone who could have been a major talent. The film captures that tragedy well. We see the characters for what they are - weak, flawed, passionate, cowardly, complex, brave and talented.
The film is over two and a half hours long, but is so engrossing that the length is unimportant. It is well worth setting aside time to see "Camille Claudel'.