There's worse than Stalinists
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-04-27Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
opposed the Russian invasion of Afghanistan and demanded the withdrawal of USSR troops so that the peoples of Afghanistan could be free to determine their own future. But since the Soviet withdrawal we have argued that the elements of 20th century progress - women's rights, education, secularism -which exist under the PDP regime should be defended against the Islamic rebels. Some readers have disagreed. These contributions are abridged from a debate on the same issue in the US socialist magazine Against the Current'. David Finkel argues for siding with PDP regime.
There is nothing inherently progressive about "modernising? dictatorships - there was certainly nothing progressive about the Shah, and I'm frankly dubious about some of the claims made for the Afghan regime's programs — but in the excitement of the Iranian upheaval many of us forgot that there are worse as well as better options.
The triumph of Khomeiniism in Iran was not only a real political revolution but also an authentic catastrophe, not only for progress" in some historical sense but for a nation of real human beings.
The victory of the Afghan Mujahedeen would be at one and the same time the triumph of a real national resistance movement and a major catastrophe for Afghan workers, women and intellectuals. The ascendance of Islamic fundamentalism to leadership of the Palestinian movement (not that I expect such a thing to happen) would be an even worse setback for the Palestinian cause than the 1967 war.
We should no more wish for the victory of such a force in Afghanistan, or anywhere in the Middle East, than we would like to see Jerry Falwell take over the United States and proclaim a Christian Republic.
I'd like to briefly suggest an approach for the left on Afghanistan from my own political perspective - which I realise is not shared, unfortunately, by any major forces in the Afghan war — that of revolutionary Third Camp socialism.
From this perspective, it is unthinkable as a matter of basic principle to support or apologise for a Soviet military occupation of any country, just as no circumstances permit the slightest degree of support for US imperialist intervention (including US backing for the Afghan Mujahedeen).
For one thing, the Soviet motivation for invading Afghanistan is in no way progressive. While I think the standard Cold War interpretation that the Soviet Union moved into Afghanistan to pursue ambitions for a warm-water port is nonsense, I do think the bureaucratic ruling class in the Soviet Union seeks to consolidate its social system, which is anti-socialist and in no way in the interests of the working class or the oppressed.
For anther thing, the practical consequences of the invasion are that for the next generation or two, land reform, literacy and women's rights will be associated with napalm, plastic mines and Hind gunships.
Indeed, not only on a world scale but also inside Afghanistan this invasion has stengthened not socialism but the most reactionary kind of politics. Time will tell if the withdrawal of the Soviet troops took place before the Afghan regime's dependence on them had become an incurable addiction. international left ujaheden in Does this imply that the supporting the Mujahedeen defense of Afghan self-determination? Not automatically.
While it is permissible in principle for socialists to support a socially and politically ultra-reactionary national force against an imperialist invader (for example, defending Haile Selassie's slave-owning Ethiopian regime against Italian agression in the 1930s), there is no Falarmat that we do so if there is an alternative perspective through which national independence could be realised. Whether such an alternative exists requires a concrete and specific analysis of the given situation.
In the case of Afghanistan, I believe there is a better or at least "less bad" alternative to supporting Islamic fanatics whose victory would mean the slaughter of a large section of the population, the return of women to the Dark Ages and quite possibly the breakup of the country along lines of tribal and super-power dominance.
Prior to the Soviet invasion in 1979, when the conflict between the PDPA regime and the Islamists had the character primarily of a civil war that is, an internal struggle even through there was of course outside great-power support on both sides, it seemed to me that socialists ought to critically support the PDPA regime, not because of agreement with its bureacuratic politics but because in that time and place its victory was the best possibility for advancing the rights of workers, women and ultimately of the rural population.
With the Soviet invasion, I think it was wrong for the left to support any side, except to demand the end of the invasion and of US CIA arming of the Mujahedeen and the Zia dictatorship in Pakistan. My view today is that the withdrawal of Soviet troops will once again mean that the conflict is primarily a civil war in which we ought to be for the victory of the PDPA - without apologising for its complicity in the crimes against humanity committed mistakes and committed by the Soviet invaders.
I cannot agree that the PDPA deserved from the international left the sort of support - and along with it, comradely and constructive criticism and advice - that for are undoubtedly motivated by revolutionary goals and desires tc advance the well-being of the people, I do not believe that as s party the PDPA's politics and record in power cannot justify our political solidarity.
At the same time, I hope the PDPA survives without the Soviet tanks and that the Afghan peasant's identification of "socialism"' with helicopter gunships and mass extermination can be overcome in a. matter of years, rather than decades.
However, any optimism I might have is tempered by the PDPA regime's apparent lack of steps tc create serious self-defense popular militias among its own presumed social base - notably the urbar working class and the pro-regime popular organisations — for a mas: defense against the Islamists* onslaught. This may be a product of bureaucratic paralysis, or perhaps a fear of which way the workers might point the guns.
----- pull-quotes -----
example, the Sandinistas have enjoyed. While many of its cadres