Communists but feudalists
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-04-27Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
List.
are afraid of the Gerry Bates the critique of the ageing bureaucracy that has ruled China since the revolution of 1949.
Demonstrators have increasingly come into conflict with the army. At Xian on Sunday 23 April, students rioted - although student leaders immediately distanced themselves from hooligan elements' But the most important element in the developing crisis is the increasing role of workers. Young workers joined the 100,000 students in Tiananmen Square last weekend. Any alliance between students and workers would spell disa ter for Deng Xiaping's ruling clique.
China has 70 million industrial workers - the la gest number in the world. The 'open marker policy of China's rulers, like an such policies, has meant economic hardship for the working class. The Thatcherite Chinese 'Communists' have been sitting on a powder keg.
In neighbouring South Korea, a student movement demanding democracy did indeed pave the way for a working class movement for independent unions. That could happen in China, too. in 191, The new republican regime, in turn, quickly dissolved into a patchwork of 'warlord' rule. Different regions were ruled by different 'warlords' • And then, after 1937, the Japanese seized most of China, including the main cities.
Chen Duxiu, founder of the Chinese Communist Party and its leader in 1925-7, had been convinced by the events of 1925-7 that Trotwas right to insist on the political independence of the working class and to reject Stalin's and Mao's idea of a 'bloc of four classes'. . Trotskyist groups organised among the city workers. But repression by the Japanese and by Chinese bosses kept them weak.
Meanwhile, in the absence of any effective central government, the Maoists were able to oust the old landlords and bureaucrats and make themselves the ruling 'warlords' for substantial regions. Separated from their earlier roots in the working class, guided ideologically by Stalin, basing themselves on peasants rather than workers, and becoming administrators for large regions, the communists around Mao gradually became something other than communists.
They remained, however, determined revolutionaries against Japanese imperialism and against China's old ruling class. In the war against Japan they formed a united from with the Kuomintang but kept their armed forces separate. They gained strength. When Japanese power collapsed in 1945, the Maoists were soon able to defeat the corrupt and unpopular Kuomintang forces of Chiang Kai Shek.
The Maoists re-entered the cities — but as a new ruling class, not as fighters for working class self-liberation. The workers were instructed to stay at work and obey their bosses. Strikes were banned.
The Maoists took over the large proportion of industry and commerce which Chiang Kai Shek's regime had nationalised or which had been owned by Chiang personally or his cronies. The rest of the capitalist class was treated very gently - its property nationalised only in the mid-'50s, and with compensation.
Those of the Chinese Trotskyists who did not flee in time were jailed.
In the countryside, the Maoist revolution did mean some progress. The peasants seized the land. The living standards of the poor peasants rose substantially. The traditional extreme subordination of women was lightened.
In the cities, the Maoists tried to build a base for themselves in the working class. They developed industry fast, and workers in the big state enterprises had job security and higher incomes than the peasants. The only trade unions allowed, though, were statecontrolled outfits, so much a sham that they could be abolished altogether during the Cultural Revolution of 1966-67 without much effect!
Until the late '50s China moved pretty much in line with the USSR. In the early '60s, however, Mao parted ways with Moscow. China became isolated economically and diplomatically. Until 1972 China's official line internationally was very left-sounding. Thousands of revolutionaries left the Moscow-line Communist Parties to form Maoist groups.
The leftism was always hollow, however. And in China itself the policies most admired by Maoists in far-off lands were disasters for the workers and peasants.
In the so-called Great Leap Forward of the late '50s, peasants were forced into huge collective farms and exhorted to develop industry through backyard steel furnaces' This craziness cost the lives of thousands of peasants.
In 1966 Mao launched the so-called Great Cultural Revolution -mobilising 'Red Guards' of youth to help him in a faction fight within the state bureaucracy. Both Western culture and what remained of old Chinese culture were denounced in an orgy of phrasemongering. The country's education system and its industry were set back many years.
Then in 1972 Mao made a deal with US President Nixon, on the backs of the Vietnamese revolutionaries. Soon Chinese foreign policy was consistently proAmerica. After Mao's death a group around Deng Xiaoping took charge and turned China resolutely in the opposite direction from the Cultural Revolution.
Since the mid-'70s the land has been effectively returned to individual peasant ownership. China has been opened up for foreign trade and foreign investment. State controls on the economy have been rolled back in favour of market mechanisms.
These measures have led to rapid economic also to mushroomi growth on, increased inequality and vast unemployment in the cities.
----- pull-quotes -----
quoted n (the party They're just