Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Students organise Left Unity

Socialist Organiser no. 399, 27 April 1989 · scan pp. 5–6 · about 1,886 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

Millward Two hundred and forty students gathered in Sheffield last Saturday for the Left Unity conference called by Socialist Student.

It was the biggest event of its kind for over a decade, with participants from all over the country and from a number of different left groups (including Socialist Student, Socialist Outlook, Socialist Action, Workers Power, the SWP and the Militant).

Socialist Student organised the conference after a highly successful fringe meeting at the last National Union of Students conference, with over 300 people attending.

The call for left unity has obviously struck a chord with many students who feel demoralised by left infighting, and the inability of NUS to organise and lead effective campaigns.

The NUS leadership (the Democratic Left faction of Labour Students) talks left while surreptitiously swinging NUS's campaigns behind Kinnock. This means that all the life quickly drains out of campaigns and that ordinary students despair of ever being able to beat the Tories. Everything not organised by the leadership is condemned by them.

For many activists, the last straw was the Democratic Left's vote for 'Cosmo' Hawkes, an independent right-winger, at last NUS conference. This man, who claimed to have ended homophobia in Portsmouth and who is currently suing Socialist Student supporter Dave Barter for libel, but not for calling him a 'closet Tory clown' , is now, thanks to the Democratic Left, National Secretary of NUS.

Running true to form, one of Cosmo's supporters even tried to stop the Left Unity conference going ahead, with a solicitor's letter of course. Happily the attempt failed.

In fact the conference was a great success. Whilst one section of the conference (Campaign Student) appeared to be interested in creating an election machine, the vast majority of participants wanted to use Left Unity to launch a serious fight back against the Tories.

The conference opened with a plenary discussion on loans, the poll tax and education cuts.

In contrast to NUS debates which are made up of speaker after speakerd outlining how bad the Tories are, Left Unity concentrated on how to beat them.

The afternoon was taken up with workshops and a final plenary which voted on proposals arising from the day's discussion. Subjects covered included internationalism, lesbian and gay liberation, women, anti-racism, anti-fascism, education and arts campaigns, FEs and Areas, green issues, students and the labour movement, loans and the poll tax.

The final debates were remarkable. At NUS conferences the left is constantly maligned, accused of intimidation, of being against autonomy for oppressed groups and of disrupting debate. In fact no-one was intimidated, everyone spoke who wanted to, all the speakers kept to the point, there was none of the precious demagogy which is part and parcel of NUS, and the first policy passed recegnised women's right to autonomy and demanded that at least 50% of the steering committee should be women.

that it who cannot bear democratic debate, because people might get the chance to listen and make up their own minds and vote with the Left.

People submitted resolutions throughout the debate and made amendments from the floor and the world did not end. Both workshops and debates showed how little the bureaucracy genuinely serves political discussion.

Obviously there are a lot of conflicts still to come. Last Saturday the Left was looking for its common ground and there is a surprising amount of it. The policies which were passed will all be circulated soon in the form of a solid basis for getting campaigns off the ground on all the issues which were discussed.

The only real spanner in the works was the attempt by Militant supporters to insist that they had been carved out. In the morning they tried to say they hadn't been allowed to register, and it took a unanimous vote of the conference to finally persuade them to get on with it.

They then proceeded to take very little part in the discussions (most of them going to the pub during the workshops) but insisting on making interminable statements alleging harsh treatment.

When Jill Mountford, Socialist Student convenor, asked if they would commit themselves to building Left Unity, they were outraged, saying that there hadn't been enough discussion and making pitiful cries of 'carve up'!

In fact the conference voted to offer them places on the steering committee but they effectively indicated they would not take those places up.

Given that their main contribution to the event was to moan about it, Jill's question was quite reasonable. As usual, it appears that the Militant are not prepared to build any organisation which they do not Though they wouldn't state that they agreed with the programme for Left Unity, they made no attempt to argue against it. They made no comment about positive discrimination, the right to autonomy, support for the PLO or Time To Go - policies which the conference backed, but which they disagree with.

Instead, they told us how new layers of students will rise up in future and create left unity. Those of us unfortunate enough to be around just now will have to wait I suppose. To be honest, most of us are getting very bored of waiting for Militant.

The elestions ensured that the political groups involved were represented, but with a majority of independents on the stee ring committee.

The committee of around 35 people has over half women, and six black members. Its main job will be to coordinate the various campaigning activities agreed by the conference, and to organise a second conference later in the year.

A number of Left Unity meetings are planned for a variety of NUS events, and our job now is to build Left Unity into a campaigning force within the student movement. We are committed to using the rest of this term, and the summer, to keeping the loans campaign going, and to trying to put back the enthusiasm that the NUS leadership has killed.

The poll tax registration forms will be appearing very soon so we have to organise frustration of the registration process as part of getting the poll tax campaign off the ground in England and Wales.

In addition, Left Unity is committed to helping the dockers in their struggle to keep the National Dock Labour Scheme, and to building not one, but two 'Beat the Blues" demonstrations in October.

This is not paper policy like NUS's. These activities and many others will be organised even though we don't have the resources of NUS. The delegates at Left Unity do not want Left Unity for its own sake, but in order to build a current in NUS which will fight the Tories, that will involve the majority of students in that fight, and that will stop the drift to the right.

The NUS leadership should take notice of what happened this weekend, or it may very well find itself out of a job. NUS Executive member Emma Colyer addresses the meeting

Scan page 6

Gabor Fodor, a member of the Hungarian opposition youth group FIDESZ, spoke to Janet Burstall and Tony Brown The programme of FIDESZ T has been described as "liberal democratic'. Is this a fair assessment?

Yes, I think so. At the end of the *70s and beginning of the '80s there was a Hungarian democratic opposition. From this opposition grew the Alliance of Free Democrats, a liberal and social democratic oppositional group. There is another line in the Hungarian opposition, a populist line, the Hungarian Democratic Forum.

These are the two main trends in Hungarian political life. Between them is FIDESZ.

FIDESZ is a very liberal and very young organisation. FIDESZ is not as strict as the Democratic Forum bed the Alliance of rike mariass because they DaL LIeD. FIDESZ is freer because it is a youth movement.

FIDESZ's aims are like a normal liberal democratic youth have not existed for 40 years.

Are there any direct relationships between the opposition groups and the reform wings of the ruling party?

Not very strong. For instance, Imre Poszgay, the head of the CP's reform wing, had very good connections with the Hungarian Democratic Forum, but the HDF is more radical than Poszgay. There is some connection, but it's not strong.

Some of the opposition's demands are political, such as freedom of press, speech and assembly, but what of economic demands? Does the opposition have general agreement on economic reform?

Yes. As everybody knows, it's very important. Economic problems are the business of government everywhere. Now the opposition groups have said we have to fight in the Parliament and we have to fight to make political questions on everything. For example, the "The import ant development of the opposition.

So does this mean that one of the main aims over the next year is to build a team capable of forming a government?

We believe we will be fighting a free election in the next year.

And so one of the first jobs of the next government will be to create a new Constitution, and not leave it to this government?

Yes. After the free elections the new Parliament will make a new Constitution.

Do you think the CP will try to stop that happening?

The CP want this Parliament to make the new Constitution because they want to limit the changes. It's a very dangerous situation. The opposition has to fight against this.

I don't believe the CP want a free election because they know they will lose. The opposition will win.

Before the 15 March demonstrations, the CP made a big campaign that we should all celebrate and demonstrate together — the CP and the opposition. The opposition said it was impossible because nothing had changed and we don't forget what has happened in the past. We saide we would demonstrate and the party and their organisations could make another demonstration.

25,000 or 30,000 people went to the Party demonstration and more than 100,000 people attended the opposition's. After that the governAnyway, after one month of the union I described, all that had happened was that the rules had been made. Workers aren't interested. They don't spend their days working out rules. It's a different situation to Poland. The workers don't feel that they have to set up independent unions.

But FIDESZ and the other opposition groups do have to explain why workers have to set up their own special organisations, and maybe soon they will.

How important does FIDESZ think that work is?

For example, a lot of young workers are in FIDESZ. We do have a miners' group in the coun try. But most people don't feel that it's important to create organisations. They think the Communists are shit, but they don't go the next step. So maybe that's something where we can help them.

One of the problems facing Solidarnose is the introduction of market reforms. Some of these are popular also in Hungary. The logic of these reforms is that places like the Lenin shipyard will be closed. So while the Solidarnose leadership may favour such policies it will seriously affect Solidarnose members - which highlights the problems of these reforms.

There is not a trade union in Hungary. The contradiction is for the Solidarnosc leaders.

But what consideration does the students confront soldie

----- pull-quotes -----

thing this thina is that

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 399

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →