What it means to Scheme
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-04-27Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
number there assembled must be left to idle the day out in want.
"To look in the faces of that hungry crowd is to see a sight that must be ever remembered. Some slaves with wanton brutality as one throws scraps to hungry wolves, to delight in the exhibition of a savage struggle for existence with the beasts tearing each other to pieces."
LUNO 60 EvANS and degrading scramble for work in pre-scheme days as an example of the harmonious workings of the free market?
The scheme, claims the document, has resulted in the docks industry being highly "strike-prone" but the document does not explain how the scheme caused strikes, any more than it explains its assertion about . "practical impossibility" of sacking a docker registered with the Dock Labour Board.
Moreover, continues the document, starting to get down to the nitty-gritty, "once the Scheme ceases to compensate for a weakness of the market, then its costs must outweigh its benefits" This is now the case because "permanent employment relationships are now firmly established".
In fact in recent years, many port employers have been intent upon replacing registered dockers with casual labour. In South Wales for example, the local port employers are currently attempting to pay off 40 'surplus' registered dockers in Cardiff, whilst seeking permission to take on 50 casual non-registered dockers at the Port of Barry, just six miles away.
Once the Scheme is scrapped, claims the document, then the benefits will start to flood in. But when the document's authors talks of "benefits". , it is clearly benefits for employers that they have in mind.
The document claims that 4,180 jobs would be created in the registered ports within five years of Scheme being abolished. But the document fails to reconcile this secretary of TGWU 6/2 branch at n Manchester docks itself, there are only nine of us left, but there's 168 workers along the canal up to Ellesmere Port.
It's always been union policy that any attack on the Scheme we would meet with an immediate strike. Ron Todd has tried to convince the Docks Committee delegates that their remit was the wrong course of action, and in no time at all the union would be skint.
So he tried to persuade them over two days to change policy. The national delegates wouldn't. He called a meeting of the Executive Council who supported him, and the national delegates still stuck to their remit.
It was put to the delegates that we go along that line, meet the employers on the Tuesday. That was backed, eventually, 85 to 10.
Ron Todd said that if the union sits down with the port employers, even it they do say no, then he is in a posit to call it an industrial dispute, and call a ballot.
The thing the employers are after is the "jobs for life'. But if we've got a job for life, why are we down from 47,000 registered dockers in the early "70s to All we're trying to do now is get negotiations going — because technically we've no terms and conditions of employment after July. Even under the Scheme, employers can fold up business, sack everyone and start up again with fewer workers.
But it would be disastrous to negotiate port by port - the likes of us will have no chance.
What we're frightened of now is a return to casual labour. Our employer could just turn round to us in July and say "if you don't like the conditions, get going."
One reason why they've hit us now is because May, June and July are the quietest months in this trade. So they've picked their time.
We're hoping we can get support from unregistered ports. After all, if we're on the same level as the unregistered ports, their jobs too will be in jeopardy.
We have regular contact with Liverpool. At the national meeting they and other places like Southampton wanted it out. The bone of contention was that we should pick the time, and we should pick the place.
It would be crazy for the employers to say they're not going to negotiate on anything. The real crunches are, one, the employer being given men he doesn't want, and, two, the 13% levy they have to pay to finance the Dock Labour Scheme. Yet one port made £47 million profit with the Scheme.
As far as the Labour Party is concerned, the question on every docker's mind is, if they get back into power, will they return the Scheme to what it was before?
Scan page 3
low is the time to fight
----- pull-quotes -----
ON THE WATER- LABOUR SCHEME To L!"
means the scrap Johnny Jones,
Manchester docks, spoke to SO