These laws are rigged!
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-04-27Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 1 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 1
called for the scheme's abolition at ple to go for abolition in February a banquet attended by Norman. of this year.
The Transport and General Workers' Union (TGWU) has held back their ballot on strike action over the docks. They have delayed sending out ballot forms until they have retained legal advice.
Once again, Tory anti-union laws have been used to intimidate the union. Under the law, if the union's dispute is with the government, rather than the port employers, it is "political' and so unlawful.
But in fact, the Tories and port employers are hand in glove.
Look at the evidence:
• Just hours before the abolition was announced, Sir Keith Stuart, head of ABP, the single largest port employer, said abolition was to be -welcomed as it would boost their profits by £5-10 million a year. He then warned the dockers: "If there were a strike and it affected our ports, so be it, that would be a very small price to pay against the longterm benefits which would accrue to our business.
"Industrial action in any form would not deflect me or my board from our strong support for the abolition of the scheme."
• In January this year port employers from Britain and France met together to co-ordinate plans for destroying the Dock Labour Scheme and its French equivalent.
• Abolition of the Dock Labour Scheme was not in the Queen's speech or the Tory manifesto, but it has been consistently campaigned for by the port employers.
For instance, just weeks before the abolition announcement, Nick Finney from the National Association of Port Employers - the bosses' national, organisation Fowler. It's clear where the initiative comes from.
• Over the last few months, port employers in Glasgow, Liverpool, Grimsby, Hull and Aberdeen have been gradually escalating their attacks on the Dock Labour Scheme in order to prepare the ground for an all-out confrontation.
Those attacks came after the cabinet made the decision in princi• The port employers donate millions of pounds every year to Tory party funds. P&O boss Jeffrey Sterling — the man whose moneygrabbing greed led to the Zeebrugge disaster - stands to make millions out of the abolition of the Dock Labour Scheme as port employers go on a general offensive against wages and conditions.
Surprise, surprise, gave €100,000 to Tory party funds last year and Sterling is an advisor to the Department of Transport.
After all that, the port bosses say that the dockers have no legitimate industrial dispute with them! If we'd seen pressure from dockers pushing a left-wing Labour government to extend the Dock Labour Scheme to non-scheme ports, do you think the port bosses would be saying they had no quarrel with the must
Scan page 2
What casual labour means bosses' grim fairy tales The port employers insist that there will be no return to casual labour after the abolition of the NDLB. There is little reason to believe them.
Already the port employers have plans to prepare the ground for casualisation.
If the scheme goes then the protection that it gives to all dockers, registered and unregistered, will disappear. A general offensive against wages and conditions for all dockers can be expected.
The employers want to break down port work into core and peripheral jobs. They aim to Before the Dock Labour Board, docl were hired by the c or half-day. This is how Mayhew described it in 19th century.
"Then begins the scuffling and scrambling forth of countless hands high in the air to catch the eye of him whose voice may give them work. As the foreman calls from a book of names, some men jump upon the backs of others so as to lift themselve: high above the rest and attract the notice of him who hires them.
"All are shouting, some cry aloud his surname, some his Christian name, others call out their own name, to remind him that they are there. Now the appeal is made in Irish blarney - now in broken English.
Indeed, it is a sight to sadden the most callous, to see thousands of men struggling for only one day's hire; the scuffle being made the fiercer by the knowledge that hundreds out of the create a divided workforce. A "core" group of workers will be fully trained, skilled and permanent; and 'perhipheral' workers will be employed on temporary contracts to cope with changes in trade and the seasonal nature of much dock work.
In the fish ports the trawler owners will try to unload their own ships and just employ dockers on a casual basis if and when they need them for big loads.
The employers plan to scrap the industry's National Joint Council, opening up dockers to local attacks on pay and conditions where the employers think they can get away with it. smiling to the foreman to coax him into remembrance of them; others, with protruding eyes, eager to snatch at the hoped-for pass.
And the dockers' leader Ben Tillet, later:
•Struggling men fought desperately and tigerishly, elbowing each other, punching each other, using their last remnants of strengt to get work for an hour or half an hour for a few pence...Coats, flesh, even ears were torn off; men were crushed to death in the struggle. The strong literally threw themselves over the heads of their fellows and battled with the milling crowds to get near the rails the cage, which held them like rats - human rats who saw food in the ticket.
"A grinning caller-on walked up and down protected by these stout iron bars facing the raging and shouting mass and as he walked, the mass swayed with him. He faced the iron bars and moving from one end to the other, he would pick and choose the Stan Crooke Spring 1988 the Port Employers commissioned a report on the Dock Labour Scheme. The document rests on some very simple assumptions, such as that port employers are the sweetest, nicest people you are ever likely to meet (which does not say much for the rest of humanity, and that free market capitalism is the best of all possible worlds.
It also draws some very simple conclusions, such as that Britain would be a land flowing with milk and honey if the National Dock Labour Board were to be abolished, and that the scourges of unemployment and inflation would also depart from Britain's shores forever as a result of the scheme's abolition.
Before the Dock Labour Scheme. says the document, "anvone could attempt to sign on for a day's or a half-day's labour at the dock gate - though obviously hiring practices were less chaotic than this suggests"
What's the evidence that they were "less chaotic"? Do the document's authors perhaps find it too difficult to portray the frenzied claim with its statement a few pages on that, "there will be a further voluntary (sic) shake-out (of labour) on the repeal of the scheme...The labour force will be reduced by 1,295 by the end of year one and a further 868 by the end of year two."
Such wage cuts and job losses would make the Dock Labour Scheme ports more "competitive" - with the non-Scheme ports. The latter would then have to pursue a similar exercise in "cutting costs" (ie. wage-rates and jobs) to remain "competitive". As the document puts it: "Competition between ports would intensify as restrictions were lifted...non-Scheme ports would also have to offer similar reductions in the cost of treight."
The document also claims that the Dock Labour Scheme is the key to regenerating the entire British economy.
Firstly, abolition of the Scheme would reduce unemployment in the areas around the ports themselves. This assertion is "proven" by pointing to the fact that job-creation levels are higher around nonScheme ports than around Scheme ports. It's the same fallacy as if you point out that there are more umbrellas on the street when it's raining than when it's dry, and conclude that abolishing unbrellas would abolish rain.
Unemployment is higher around registered ports because those ports are in areas like the North where industry has been in decline for years.
The document also argues that abolition of the Scheme would reduce the cost of importing foreign goods, and that "the forces of competition" would ensure that these savings "are passed on in the final price to the consumer"
But you don't need to be a professional economist to know that inflation depends upon a lot more than just the freight costs of importing foreign goods. And even if people did buy more imported goods because of their lower prices, this would merely make even worse Britain's trade deficit, especially given that low inflation would push up exchange rates and thereby make British exports abroad more expensive.
The document suffers from one other major deficiency. It is extremely dull and boring. The only consoling thought in reading it is that the National Association of Port Employers probably wasted a lot of money on it.
----- pull-quotes -----
Help the dockers beat the Tory/port bosses' conspiracy