Time for a drive against AEU right wing
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-04-20Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
In a hur -irti g backdown on 12 April, Bill Jordan and the negotiating committee of the Confederation of Shipb-ilding and Enginzuring unions withdrem their proposals for a major sell-out of national cagineering conditions.
A 300-strong lobby of engineering workers outside the Confed's talks with the bosses on 12 April concluded a series of meetings throughout the country of engincering stewards rejecting the proposals.
Jordan avoided the lobby, but apparently was persuaded by Alex Ferry, the Confed General Secretary, that ignoring it would only add fuel to the protests of engineering workers. So Ferry, Jordan and Todd Sullivan (president of the Confed and a TGWU official) met a delegation from the lobby.
At this meeting Jordan came under strong attack from convenors and delegates from local Confeds throughout the country, demanding to know with what mandate he had ditched the eight-point claim and the 35 hour no-strings policy agreed at the Confed's Annual Conference.
Delegate after delegate pointed to the high profits in the engineering industry, and said that now was the time for attack, rather than retreat.
Jordan argued that the sell-out proposals were agreed by all the union İcaderships within the Confed. Anyway, successful further attacks by employers on engineering workers were inevitable. To surrender before the attacks start might get engineering workers something in return.
He chose not to answer the question of his lack of accountability to conference policies, arguing instead that he would abide by any ballots held on the issue.
The withdrawal of the sell-out proposals hours later shows that the Confed leadership are not confident that there is such a mood of despair as could give legitimacy to their business unionism. The members' response seems to have taken the Confed leadership by genuine surprise. Not one union on the negotiating committee had spoken out against Jordan's proposals in advance of the lobby.
Two factors undoubtedly influenced Jordan and his cohorts, and contributed to what can only be regarded as a major blunder by them.
After years of inaction at national level, local Confeds have increasingly become talking shops which officials like Jordan think they can safely ignore.
The absence of a serious organised left within the engineering unions also encouraged Jordan. What exists of an organised left, such as the Engineering Gazette, has been preoccupied with, and generally defeated in, union elections, and has shown very little initiative in any other area of union activity.
Conditions now exist for major changes in both these areas. For the second time in two years proposals for changes in engineering conditions have had to be withdrawn by union national officials in the face amongst lay officials file membership.
The effect has been to focus engineering workers' interest in the machinations of their national officials and stimulate active opposition to their policies.
Much needs to be done to give coherence to that growing opposition. Years of inactivity at national level have opened wide discrepancies in conditions, pay and the extent of casualisation, and consequently in the confidence of workers within various sectors of the industry. There is growing militancy, but it is concentrated in particular areas and companies.
The demand for 35 hours without strings undoubtedly strikes a chord with these workers whilst national minimum time rates (NMRs) for the industry as a whole are generally less important.
Less well organised areas, on lower wages, higher levels of overtime and the worst conditions are probably more concerned about NMRs, restrictions on overtime and other such conditions.
The indications are that the union bureaucrats will attempt to exploit these divisions to reduce the risk of a dispute.
Theoretically, the initial 8-point claim submitted to the EEF in September 1988 is back on the agenda after the withdrawal of Jordan's proposals, with, in addition to 35 hours without strings, demands for increases in pay, shift premiums and overtime premiums, and limitations on overtime. If campaigned for they could unite engineering workers against a vulnerable employers federation.
But instead of pushing for the full claim, national officials are talking in terms of two options.
Firstly, they are talking of separating off the claim on hours from the pay claim - a strategy that will make it doubly difficult for militant sections to take weaker sections of the unions with them in a ballot, not only isolating those fighting for a reduction in hours, but also deflecting attention away from what can only be expected to be a shoddy compromise on pay.
One thing that has been quietly slipped in in the wake of Jordan's defeat is a proposal for a two-year deal on pay. At present the bosses have offered just under 6% for both November 1988 and November 1989. Talks of a two-year deal must be strongly opposed.
If the officials are unable to carry their plan of separating the items of the claim they are likely to go for a rapid conclusion of talks and an immediate ballot.
With the officials clearly not wanting a dispute that would significantly undermine their dominance in the unions they cannot be expected to campaign seriously for industrial action - and considerable campaigning would undoubtedly be necessary to win a ballot.
With eight months already having been wasted in talks between the EEC and the CSEU time is running short. An urgent national conference of engineering stewards is still vital to take on the task of building rank and file campaigning unity which is essential to make a fight on this year's full claim.