Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A story of solidarity and vi

Socialist Organiser no. 398, 20 April 1989 · scan p. 10 · Vicki Morris · about 865 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Neil Cobbett "Matewan' n the 1920's virtual civil war erupted in the West Virginia and Kentucky minefields of the US as the bosses strove to smash down the miners.

In Matewan, a company town in West Virginia, run by the Stone Mountain Coal Company, a strike/lock-out developed to the point where strikers were evicted from their homes and attempts made to "repossess" their belongings.

In the end the Coal Company imported an army of gunnies to run the strikers off the land or kill them.

The strikers organised an ambush in which most of the bosses' gun men were wiped out. In retaliation the bosses' hirelings murdered members of the local community and the minefield was blown up.

In 'Matewan' , director John Sayles depicts the events of this strike as seen through the eyes of ('Return of the Secaucus 7' 'Lianna', , Brother from Another Planet') are all of an alternative, if not radical, persuasion, but this film is much more clear cut and, -think, shows real guts and a healthy attitude to union struggles.

Whatever its shortcomings it is the first commercial film in years which shows workers in struggle sympathetically. Conversely it shows how the bosses will use every dirty trick in the book to break strikes (scabs, company guards, James Earl Jones in John Savles' Matewan spies, slander against union organisers and armed force etc.

The plot revolves around the arrival of Joe Kenehan, a union organiser and an ex-member of the radical IWW who spent time in stir for opposing World War 1.

The local strikers are hell bent on stopping the company's scab labour by force. Joe, realised that the scabs (poor blacks and Italian immigrants who are in the dark about the strike and lured by the promise of work) should be won to the union if the strike is to be successful.

He tells the strikers that they need solidarity to win ("One big union" was the battlecry of the IWW) and that a union that refuses to organise the most oppressed black and immigrant workers isn't a union but a club.

The strikers think otherwise and organise for a shoot-out. But the scabs realising what they are doing, throw down their tools in front of the bosses and join the strike: this is a powerful moment and shows the power of ideas of soldarity in uniting workers.

This is a recurrent theme of the film, whether the workers should opt for violence (under provocation) or build up solidarity and focus on mass industrial action, while not shrinking from violent resistance where necessary.

Unfortunately, whatever Sayles's intentions, I don't think the film comes across clearly on this point. The end of the film had a pistols at dawn romanticism which will leave many confused and feeling that minority violence against the bosses rather than mass action, is the key (although the epilogue makes it clear that this is only the opening round in a war in which the miners came off worst).

However, this is an ambiguity, not a clear "message'. In fact the union organiser is the first casualty in the shoot-out, and the scene leaves us with a feeling of regret that the others don't listen to him.

In any case, this is a powerful film, whatever the problems involved in trying to portray a strike in terms of a "workers' western'. See it.

series "The Thatcher analyses the special complexion the Prime Minister has given to 10 years of Tory government.

The first programme was a general review of the Thatcher decade which concentrated on the characteristics making the PM a hard nut amongst Tory leaders. It included accounts of her tyranny over Cabinets and her campaign to oust the "Wets'. This picture was tempered by testimonies of personal kindnesses to close colleagues, to what purpose I couldn't fathom.

Hugo Young, who wrote the series, is a Guardian parliamentary correspondent who, judging by the narrowness of his arguments, appears not to have stepped outside the House of Commons lobby for the past 20 years.

His recent biography of the Right Honourable Margaret portrays an admirably vigorous enemy the Establishment and his programme, therefore, was stuffed with the Tory Party faithful bearing witness to Thatcher's revolutionary zeal, and professing unqualified optimism for the future of Britain and Party under her tutelage.

Indeed, it is a large part of Young's project to explain how Thatcher's support endures, and how she has "an instinctive feel for what the ordinary Tory voter out in the Shires is thinking."

But he implied that there is another brand of Tory - represented by the Wets, but Tory nonetheless whom other political parties need to woo if they are to stand any chance of governing before the century is over.

Only a handful of non-Tories - like Marxism Today's Stuart Hall — were interviewed, and they seemed to have been chosen precisely because their political perspectives would add weight to Young's defeatist argument. For that reason, the programme's explanation of Thatcher's endurance was scandalously: incomplete.

Most of the opposition to Thatcher has not accepted the framework in

----- pull-quotes -----

Danny, a sometime Baptist preacher. Sayles's other films

factor TV

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 398

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →