Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Worse than mistakes

Socialist Organiser no. 398, 20 April 1989 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 1,535 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Militant denounce black workers The 'counter-revolution' , they said, had been defeated (Militant, 13 May) - which will come as a shock to most Afghans. Militant denounced "the confused 'analyses' of the capitalist media, which portray the Russian withdrawal as a defeat.* The idea that the USSR and similar systems are progressive is common to many socialists. Yet these regimes are totalitarian police states in which the working class has fewer democratic rights than it does in Western Europe.

Militant agree, in general, with making a revolution against these regimes. But if workers' revolution is not on the cards - like in Afghanistan — a totalitarian police state is, in their eyes, at least a big step towards socialism. It tells you something central about Militant's whole idea of socialism.

It tells you even more when you read that Militant sees Stalinism as the only way forward not just for exceptionally underdeveloped the world.

Marxist Party...would not be sufficient to prevent the deformation of the revolution on Stalinist lines," wrote Militant leader Ted Grant in his major article on the "Colonial Revolution" "Revolutionary victory in backward countries, such as Algeria, under present conditions, while constituting a tremendous victory for the world revolution and the world proletariat....cannot but be on the lines of a totalitarian Stalinist state."

Algeria is far from being one of the world's most backward contries. If Algeria has no better possibilities, then so has most of the world. The only Third World countries for which any • better possibilities are even hinted at are India, Sri Lanka and South Africa. And in its time the Militant tendency has also welcomed as a huge step forward the creation of deformed workers' states" in Europe — in Czechoslovakia and in Portugal.

For Militant, progress means nationalisations - carried out by whom, and under what conditions for the workers, is secondary. Workers' liberty is a desirable but optional, and in most circumstances of the workers themselves, but the task of the progressive state Shot because we think revoly. ocialist Organiser is a revonot because we think revolution is a nice, romantic idea, but because revolution is necessary to defeat once and for all the capitalist They won't give up power without a fight, if necessary a violent one. Moreover, real socialism — democratic workers' control of society — will have to be created from below. No government in Parliament can introduce socialism from above.

On both these aspects of a revolutionary programme, Militant are a long way from Marxism. Each week in their Where We Stand column they argue that peaceful change -without serious ruling class resistance — is possible through an Enabling Act in Parliament. After scenes during the miners' strike or at Wapping, who could believe that?

Militant's call for a government to 'nationalise the monopolies' by passing an 'Enabling Act' in Parliament is a strategy for socialism *from above', which wouldn't work, and wouldn't achieve socialism.

Revolutionaries don't ignore Parliament. And we do want a Labour government! But we don't pretend that such a government could achieve socialism - although we woud fight for a left Labour government to support workers in struggle, who could achieve socialism.

The Militant tendency is not Marxist, and it is not revolutionary. It is a bureaucratic sect • that destroys what it runs, and participates only to take control. The front organisations it has set up have all been exactly that — fronts, woefully inadequate to the tasks of the class struggls..

Socialists need a different sort of Marxist tendency - one that builds the broad movement as well as itself, and sees no conflict between its own interests and those of the working class as a whole. That is what Socialist Organiser aims to be.

our article on Militant (SO 397) refers to their war of attrition with Liverpool's Black Caucus as if the City Council's mistake was primarily one of tactics.

That the Militant councillors made every tactical mistake in the book is true, but those mistakes merely compounded a far bigger miscalculation and the part which was mentioned indicated an unprincipled attitude to black people in Britain.

Anyone reading 'Militant' especially their youth paper, would get a picture of an organisation committed to black rights. On paper, every week, Militant pledges to fight racism.

Yet they regard all black self-organisation as "divisive' and argue vehemently against it - which does not stop them hypocritically participating in the NUS Black Caucus when they want votes for one of their candidates.

More ridiculous still, they organised all their black youth in 1977-78 into the British section of the Jamaican PNP -an enterprise which was a separatist black group and implied that all British blacks are foreigners and moreover that all West Indians are Jamaicans!

Militant's record with regard to black organisation is one of sectarian cynicism Militant boasts a lot about the fact that one of its supporters is now the first black woman on the National Union of Students Executive.

Look at Militant's record, and it becomes clear that this pretence of concern for the special struggles of specially oppressad sections of the working class is pure tokenism.

In 1974 there was a big strike by Asian workers at Imperial Typawritars in Leicester, demanding equal opportunities for training and promotion. The white workers and their notoriously racist union officials opand indicates a basic hostility to a large section of the working class. Nowhere is this more blatantly shown than in the Sam Bond affair.

Militant's programme of build more houses' patently did not benefit Liverpool's black community. The Liverpool black caucus discovered racist practices in the allocation of new and better quality council housing - but the council did nothing about it, leaving the black community ghettoised in the worst estates.

At the same time, the council dropped a project to build sheltered housing for elderly people in an area with a high black population, which would consequently have benefitted elderly black people more than whites.

The Housing programme, arguably Militant's Liverpool flagship, did nothing to alleviate the problems of the city's indigenous black population. The council cannot argue that it was ignorant of these problems it deliberately chose to ignore them.

The one promise that the council did keep to the black organisations was of the council 'unit' to tackle racism within the city. Yet even here, Militant were not prepared to counternance any dissent from its own dogmatic views.

Whilst it is possible to have some sympathy with a left council which appeared to be reacting against an appointment from the burgeoning race relations "industry' the facts are that:

1. Bond was the least qualified candidate by anyone's standards.

2. Both ethnic monitoring posed the strike and scabbed on for Militant blamed the strikers splitting the workforce, and delivered many lectures on the need to win over the white workers. In fact the Asian workers had tried that and failed, partly because of the bureaucratic strangling of their union branch.

In a preview of Militant's scurrilous attacks on the Liverpool Black Caucus, Militant justified their line on the strike by diverting the argument into denunciations of a radical black lawyer who was helping the strikers. 'positive action* even in their most minimal form are a necessary part of a serious attempt to tackle racism in council services.

3. Militant had stitched up the appointment long before the interviews even started.

Politically Militant were 100% wrong, and a simple reaction against leaderppointed black "community wanting local government riches for themselves does not let them off the hook.

The Militant may not have been prepared to give the race relations industry a foothold in 'their' council but the evidence shows that they were not tackling racism in a way acceptable to their dogma either.

Neither the housing programme nor the job creation schemes were doing anything for Liverpool's black people. In reality ethnic monitoring schemes, 'positive action' in employment and promotion and all the other systems which should have been administered and initiated by the new unit should have gone hand in hand with the jobs and houses programme.

Militant's politics failed on both counts. What followed was inevitable given Militant's starting point.

A right wing administration refusing to take seriously the very real problems faced by its black constituents, refusing to face up to racism in its own proceedures, making sensitive appointments from its own ranks, then attempting to cover up the ensuing furore with outrageous front organisations, denunciations of the trade unions and legitimate community groups ('alien methods") denouncing the black caucus as 'pimps and gangsters' calling the police to evict demonstrators, and towards the end disgusting corruption, is no more than we expect.

Yet this is precisely how Militant behaved in Liverpool. They have a view of the politics of race and for the matter sex and sexuality culled from the most backward sections of the working class. This is coupled with a smug sense of their own rightness which blinds them to reality.

They are thus not merely insensitive, capable of tactical mistakes, but positively anti-Marxist. No amount of anti-deportation campaigns or portraits of angry blacks in their paper will change that.

Liz Millward North London

Scan page 10

The m

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 398

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →