Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Is Militant Marxist? Part 2

Socialist Organiser no. 398, 20 April 1989 · scan p. 8 · about 1,850 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Clive Bradley looks the record the Militant tendency in the unio on the Eastern Bloc, and on the 'parliamentary road to socialism' Last week we argued that the Militant tendency is a typical sect, self-absorbed, arrogant, disdainful, despite having its home in the Labour Party.

Its sectarian approach just beilding itself, increasing the number of Militant supporters, even at the expense of wider struggles, as in Liverpool - is very sharply expressed in the trade unions. Here also Militant has a "front organisation', the Broad Left Organising Committee (BLOC).

BLOC was set up in 1981. Its first couple of conferences were large and relatively lively. The platforms were heavily dominated by Militant speakers, but many other socialists turned up. It looked promising.

But soon BLOC became nothing more than a signboard for Militant rallies. It ran no campaigning activity. In late 1983 thousands of activists mobilised to support the NGA print union picket lines against Eddie Shah in Warrington.

It was a crucial test battle for the Tory anti-union laws. BLOC took no initiative at all.

In 1984 a BLOC conference coincided with the start of the miners"

strike. The conference passed a bland resolution of general support for the miners, and then for the whole year of the strike BLOC did nothing beyond issuing one leaflet and calling one lobby of the TUC.

When a Mineworkers' Defence Committee was formed to unite and organise activists, it was Socialist Organiser and Briefing who took the initiative, not BLOC. BLOC played no role at all.

Where is BLOC now? Nobody knows. It has shown no signs of life for some time. From the thousands of activists who were attracted to BLOC when it was launched Militant has created something even more lifeless than the Communist Party's old Liaison Committee for the Defence of Trade Unions. Bere usualy dominal Lefts efore the 1980s, the old were usually dominated by the Communist Party, which was a very burcaucratic organisation (and is now two very bureaucratic organisations - one trendy and right-wing, the other pro-Moscow). The Broad Lefts were never active, democratic rank and file movements: they were machines for winning elections. Today's extremely right-wing leadership of the electricians' union, the EETPU, dates back to a big scandal in the early 1960s when it was proved that the previous CP leadership had rigged elections to keep control.

By the early 1980s the old Broad Lefts had largely died away and been replaced by new ones, dominated by Militant. Some these are still more than Militant fronts, and other socialists, like Socialist Organiser, are often involved in them. But it is an uphill struggle to stop Militant stifling even the best of them; and they are just as much electoral machines as the old Broad Lefts.

Militant looks to capturing the apparatus of the trade unions, and devotes lots of energy to winning elections in them. In itself, this is reasonable and necessary; but Militant look no further.

The trade unions are the basic, "bedrock' organisations of the working class. Partly because their job is to bargain within capitalism, the unions have developed a powerful bureaucracy - a distinct layer of full-time officials who see their role as negotiators as the be-all and end-all. Because big strikes often threaten the position OI the bureaucrats, they frequently sell them out.

Socialists need to deucatise the trade unions, and fight to replace bureaucrats with a new fighting leadership. Elections are important — it makes a difference whether a union is led by Eric Hammond or Arthur Scargill.

But the key to transforming the unions is the rank and file itself. A socialist policy tries to develop the confidence and organisation of the rank and file. So while fighting to replace old, right-wing leaders, we have to build a rank and file movement that can, to a degree, act independently of the officials. The lack of such a rank and file movement across the unions was one of the reasons the miners' strike of 1984-5 lost: when the TUC refused to do anything to help the miners, those activists who did want to do something had no means to build solidarity.

The Broad Lefts could have helped build a rank and file movement. They didn't because Militant had no interest in fighting for that. Just like the CP before them, they did not represent a fighting leadership in the unions. The Broad Lefts they dominated were either largely lifeless front organisations, seen as recruiting grounds to the Militant or, where they did have life, were electoral machines.

The jewel in BLOC's crown is the Broad Left in the Civil and Public Servants Association (CPSA). This Broad Left is large and used to be quite active and lively; but now it does very little outside of union elections. A Militant motion to BL conference in 1987 argued: " ...the priority must be the re-election of the Broad Left NEC."

That year Militant supporter John Macreadie had his election as General Secretary ruled out by the CPSA President. Macreadic took the CPSA to court - at a cost of E20,000 — violating the principle of trade union independence from the courts. He consulted the Broad Left had the nerve to ask the BL to pay for it! He lost both court case and re-run.

Militant frequently oppose the extension of union democracy. For example, they are against the annual election of full-time officers like Macreadie, who is now Deputy General Secretary for a five-year period. Militant say five years is short enough...

They see the Broad Left as their property. When a policy was passer by the Broad Left that the Militant leadership disagreed with, committing the BL to fight for action over the sacking of trade unionists at GCHQ. Militant supporters who are Broad Left officers just ignored it. They even refused to put out a Broad Left leaflet explaining the policy. A fine example of commit ment to rank and tile control and workers' democracy!

Broad Left conferences are like Militant rallies, with guest (Militant) speakers who even intervene in debates on contentious The BL have controlled the did so in 1982-tiveand their reCora, matched against the class struggle, was not impressive.

The big battle during their period of office was by DHSS workers in Oxford and Birmingham, against job cuts. Militant argued for a return to work from the beginning. They said that workers should keep their powder dry for a bigger struggle later, over pay. They organised no mass pickets or demonstrations.

After four months, the NEC balloted for a return to work.

Nothing was won - and no bigger struggle over pay followed.

In 1987-8, Militant were no better. The NEC under their control failed to organise any strike action against YTS, although sporadic strike action was already taking place. They stuck to producing a few glossy leaflets.

They failed to hold a Labour Party affiliation ballot, although it was conference policy to do so, because the Treasury threatened to stop the deduction of union contrioutions at source. There was no campaign against the Treasury, or even an attempt to find ways round it.

The NEC failed to call out civil servants on the one-day strike over the NHS on 14 March 1988. John Macreadie (who is the CPSA delegate to the TUC) called on the TUC to have a one-day strike instead. The TUC should have had a strike; but Militant's policy was just a posture.

The Broad Left National Committee did not meet for four months after the NEC victory, and never consulted the BL about its actions.

As a result the BL was effectively paralysed as a serious rank and file organisation in the vital period of the 1987 pay claim. This paralysis allowed the right-wing to step in and do their best to sabotage the ballot for all our strike action. The BL lost that ballot and the seeds were sown for the return of the right to power in the union in 1988.

That defeat at the '88 conference was rationalised by Militant as mere lull before the storm'. We'll be back next year they vainly boasted. Tragically the BL's inactivity over the last few months makes that prospect unlikely.

Militant ran the DHSS Section Executive from the early 1980s until 1988, when they lost it to the rightwing. They ratted on BL and Section policy to fight the Fowler Social Security Reviews (1986-7) by refusing to ballot on strike action -for fear of the courts.

They refused to spread limited (but successful) action against Limited Period Appointments (casuals on fixed contracts) brought into the DHSS to implement the Fowler Reviews.

•Now the DHSS looks set to lose 15,000 jobs. The new right-wing leadership, which won't fight, was voted in on a backlash against Militant.

LOC has had little presence in any of the big battles of the 1988 NHS dispute, Militant barcaucratically strangled the shop stewards' structure that health workers were creating. Militant wanted the whole thing co-opted by BLOC. Failing that, they weren't interested in building the rank and file organisations needed to go forward.

In the biggest of all recent battles, the miners' strike, Militant could have played an important role -via Liverpool - and failed. They had little involvement in miners' support groups (usually setting up separate ones with only themselves in them).

They played stupid games with the vital slogan of the general strike. If the labour movement had mocilised its full force alongside the miners, they could have won - and much more could have been achieved. Militant called for a one-day general strike only, hardly enough to win, Except for a couple of days. In the middle of LPYS summer camp in 1984, South Wales NUM had its funds sequestrated. The LPYS NC called a special meeting, at which they called for an all-out general strike. Everyone was very hyped up.

But a Militant Special Edition that week just called for a one-day strike again. The discrepancy was never explained. But the hyping-up had served its purpose- to browbeat the left in the LPYS.

Militant never understood one of the most important lessons of the miners' strike - the role of women. Women Against Pit Closures - the organisation of women in pit communities — showed how politically powerful an independent movement of working class women could be, fighting as part of the labour movement.

Militant tried to reinterpret would-be Trotskyists. But Militant have a version of this theory that is particularly appreciative of the alleged economic advances in these countries.

The clearest example of what this meant in practice for Militant was the USSR's invasion of Afghanistan at the end of 1979 and beginning of 1980.

Now, in 1989, the USSR has left Afghanistan, and socialists should side, for the time being, with the USSR's former Afghan allies against the Islamic fundamentalists. But for nine years, the USSR carried out a brutal colonial-type war to subdue the peoples of Afghanistan - using napalm, demolition of villages and so on.

----- pull-quotes -----

"The Militant tendency is not is not sect which

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 398

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →