[poll tax", that contains not a single proposal…]
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-04-20Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
poll tax", that contains not a single proposal for "struggle" of any sort. Instead, it closes with a list of "demands" upon the TUC and Labour demonstration', organise a national Party leaders national should break the law", "MPs and councillors should declare they will defy the law", , etc etc), with no suggestions for rank and file action beyond moving a resolution at union branches.
The pamphlet singles out one other target for particular attack: "Community Politics" As someone who has spent the last few months criticising the romantic illusions in community-based campaigning that exist in my local (anarchist-dominated) anti-poll tax group, I was very familiar with all the arguments the SWP raise about the limitations of this orientation. I've used them myself.
But the SWP go further and effectively write off the value of any community-based mobilisation at all. Big meetings on housing estates are all very well, we are told, but they "only BER D9! 60p plus 13p postage from so, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA
Scan page 7
ockers union mands. The union grew massively a result, and had 154,000 embers by 1892The docks strike was the biggest stied in Load unsure year year fore the match girls at the Bryant unions, which functioned as friendly societies and were therefore unwilling to get involved in strikes.
The craft unions would only become radicalised in the late 1890's under the pressure of technological change and Stan Crooke looks the history behind anti-Moscow demonstrations in Georgia, and the rights and wrongs of Georgian nationalism Georgia was incorporated Gito the Russian Re pire Flat the start of the 19th century, became independent for four years after 1917, and was conquered by the Bolshevik Red Army in 1921.
Complex national and ethnic conflicts had featured prominently in the history of early twentieth century Georgia. Many merchants and money-lenders were Armenian; British, French and Jews figures prominently In the emerging Georgian capitalism; the Russian government was the biggest landowner in Georgia; and the local administration was in the hands of Russian officials.
When the Bolsheviks seized power in Moscow in November 1917, the Menshevik-dominated Transcaucasian Regional Soviet (covering Georgia, Armenia and Azerbaidzhan) condemned the revolution and called for a continuation of Russia's war against Germany and Turkey. In May 1918 Georgia was declared an independent sovereign state, and in elections in February 1919, the Mensheviks won 409,766 of the 505,477 votes cast.
The Menshevik government encouraged a wave of Georgian nationalism. The use of Russian was banned in the Georgian Parliament, in the law courts, and in the army and Georgian was declared the sole permitted medium of official business.
Before the year was out, Georgia was involved in a brief war against Armenia, for control of land vacated by the retreating Turkish army. The long-standing hostility between Georgians and Armenians flared up, and a series of outrages were committed against the large Armenian community in Tbilisi. part in a rebellion or a revolution... The Georgian masses had become accustomed to the idea of an independent Georgia."
Lenin and Trotsky were horrified when they learned of the truth of the situation. Lenin wrote to Stalin's crony Ordzhonikidze in Tbilisi, telling him that "the internal and international position of Georgia requires of the Georgian communists not the application of the Russian stereotype, but..an original tactic, based upon greater concessions to the petty bourgeois elements."
Though many of the Georgian Bolsheviks themselves attempted to pursue such an approach, Stalin would have none of it, and instead forced through the creation of a Transcaucasian Socialist Federal Soviet Republic (covering Georgia, Armenia and Azerbaidzhan) at the close of 1922. Georgian communists opposed to the creation of the Federation were slandered as "national deviationists" by Stalin and his associates.
Lenin initially supported the creation of the federation but quickly changed his mind upon receiving reports of the repressive policies being pursued there by Ordzhonikidze, with the approval of Stalin. He informed the "national deviationists": "I am with you in this matter with all my heart. I am outraged by the arrogance of Ordzhonikidze and the connivance of Stalin and Dzerzhinsky head of the Soviet secret police.
But Stalin emerged victorious in the dispute, and soon in the Party as a whole. Lenin suffered a third and ultimately fatal stroke. Trotsky was slow to take up cudgels against Stalin, although in later years he recognised that Stalin's victory in the Georgian affair was "the first victory of the reactionaries in the party" and signalled the beginning of the Stalinist counter-revolution.
In the purges of 1936/7 the entire leadership of the Georgian CP, with the exception of the 70-year old Makharadze, was tortured to death or shot. The sweep of the purges embraced the Georgian population in its entirety, with imprisonment, exile or death for anyone whose loyalty to the regime was subject to the slightest doubt.
At the close of the war, Georgians who had sought asylum exert a powerful the Georgian CP.
A decentralised governmental structure might provide even more scope for black marketeering. This may be one reason for the strength of Georgian separatism; but it is certainly not the only one.
Georgian nationalism has been a political force ever since the Georgian national revival of the late nineteenth century. As a result of the role played by non-Georgians in Georgian development, class antagonisms have interlaced with national antagonisms.
Georgian nationalists have been even more hostile towards Azerbaidzhanis than towards Russians. At least Russians tended to be white and Christian, whereas the Azerbaidzhanis were dark skinned, Muslim and economically backward. Armenians, the third major natinality in the Transcaucasus, were likewise despised by Georgian nationalists.
The level of repression under Stalin and his immediate predecessors prevented such national antagonisms coming out into the open. But they clearly continued to exist.
Once Gorbachev slightly loosened the straitjacket of Soviet society, the long dormant Georgian nationalist forces (some pushing for more autonomy, some pushing for outright independence) inevitably re-surfaced and re-entered the earlier traditional relationships of national hostility between the major and minor nationalities inhabiting Georgia in particular and the Transcaucasus in general.
Whilst Georgia can point to a long history of oppression by Tsarist Russia and then the Stalinist Soviet Union, the brief experience of the independent Georgia of 1917-21 underlines the fact that Georgian nationalism in power can be just as oppressive of national minorities.
The validity of the Georgian demand for self-determination should not blind socialists to the fact than an independent Georgia might be no less intolerant of its national minorities than its predecessor of seven decades ago.