Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why bosses are in two minds about automation

Socialist Organiser no. 398, 20 April 1989 · scan pp. 5–6 · about 1,124 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

TECHINOLOGY Bruce Robinson starts an occasional column on new technology with a look at why bosses have mixed feelings about computerised manufacturing mages of workerless factories, Fiat s 'built by robots' and automation spreading relentlessly through manufacturing industry are equally part of socialists' nightmares and Tomorrow's World-type technclogical fantasies.

Computers first made their appearance in manufacturing in the late 1950s. They were used for monitoring processes and in metal manufacture to control machine tools.

Instead of having a skilled operator guide the machine, a program punched onto paper tape would control the tool. With the advent of chips the 'numerical control machine' had its own internal computer instead of the paper tape. 75 per cent of machine tools produced in Europe are now of this type (known as CNC machines).

They can automate tool changing, work handling. sensing and monitoring. In theory, at least, they, can run unattended.

The most recent development is computer-integrated manufacture in which the computers involved in production are linked into other computerised processes such as design, stock control and providing information to management. The process is more flexible as it is possible to redesign products and reprogram the machine tools very quickly. Fewer stocks of components are required as production can be planned better.

There are fewer workers, usually with a much more general role in controlling and supcrvising production than old-style production workers.

Anything approaching full-scale CIM is still a rarity, even in Japan, not just because of technical problems, but also because of the high cost of the machinery. Attempts to use CIM techniques in Europe and the US have not been very successful.

General Motors has been a pioneer in the Us, investing $60 billion in automating all its factories, but it is falling behind Ford in productivity and profits. GM's own factories got only half the productivity increase registered at a plant which GM runs jointly with Toyota in California. The California plant did not use automation but did use Japanese management methods.

As the Financial Times put it: *What GM seems to have failed to appreciate is that new technology has to be matched to changes in management and in the way the manufacturing process is organised." The title of a recent Economist report is even more blunt: "The new manufacturing: minimal IT [information technology] for maximum profit."

The more far-seeing elements of management seem to be coming increasingly to the conclusion that it's more important to keep workers involved and docile in high technology factories. The machinery itself doesn't solve their problems.

In this model - taken from Japan and increasingly the rule in British 'greenfield' sites - the smaller number of workers have a much more direct role in supervision and control of production and are expected to make suggestions to improve production levels and quality. They have a wider range of skills and are expected to move flexibly between different functions (eg. being responsible for maintenance).

Cooption and participation become more important when the responsibilities of the worker often include being able to stop production if anything goes wrong! The potential power of these groups of workers is huge.

Another reason for the continued importance of the skilled worker is the difficulty involved in computerising those parts of the job that require knowledge that comes from direct involvement in production. As a German manager put it: "As long as one is working with metal it is impossible to plan everything and we must acknowledge the limitations of theory. CNC machines relieve the workers only of the physical burden. Skilled workers remain a necessity due to the inevitable imponderables." The skills may change, for example to include programming, but cannot be removed altogether.

The Economist report states: *Automation as practised by most Western firms has been the final doomed episode of Taylorism." the "scientific management" techniques based on the assembly line, with the work divided up inte minute steps and the workers no required to use any initiative. Thi is echoed on the left by talk o *post-Fordism' (which if it mean anything must mean this and o 'human-centred' automation. as : means of using workers' skills te meet the requirements of new form: of production.

This doesn't mean that a ros! future for factory workers i waiting just around the corner: ver few firms have achieved the degre of automation necessary for CIN and many areas of production ar not amenable to it. More commoi is a use of limited islands o automation' in those parts of th process most suited to it.

The reluctance of British bosse to abandon their old methods i perhaps not as short-sighted as it presented. It probably stems from fear of giving a large degree of cor trol over production to a workforc much better organised and com bative (even now) than th Japanese. Where CIM has been im plemented, the workers are ex pected to do a whole range of job and - very explicitly - told tha they are responsible for ensurin the company's profitability.

Scan page 6

Jackie McDonough reviews "Socialists and the struggle If anyone still needs convincing of the Socialist Workers Party's degeneration into a banal propagandist sect, they need look no further than this miserable offering.

The opening words of the pamphlet are, "The Poll Tax must rank as one of the most vicious Tory attacks on the working class yet". That being so you would expect some sort of strategy to fight the poll tax, wouldn't you? Sadly, you would search in vain There are plenty of attacks on the Tories and still more denunciation the Labour and trade union leaders, to involve a minority... sometimes an extremely impressive minority, but a minority nonetheless" . And I thought "win the militant minority" was the semi-official slogan of the SWP!

Anyway, "once the meeting is over, individuals are prey to the distortions and demoralising effect of the media. For once you are back in your home there is no collective debate or feeling of strength to counter them"

There is no discussion here of how street committees, regular advice points, telephone trees and even the good old fashioned window-bill can be used to counter such isolation. Even the most starry-eyed anarchist will make the point that anti-poll tax unions exist precisely to counter the isolation individuals feel in their homes.

The SWP even sink so low as to distort history in the section on the Glasgow rent strike of 1915. Victory then was not won because of the community organisation, but because of strikes by shipyard and munition workers, we are told.

It is true that strikes in the shipyards and one armaments factory in support of tenants finally secured the victory in 1915. But the SWP appear not to

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 398

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →