Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Right of Reply

Socialist Organiser no. 398, 20 April 1989 · scan p. 3 · about 576 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Now dare the dockers What the Dock Labour Scheme did do was abolish the system of dockers being hired by the half-day, and gave dockers more job security.

pa them more; to make the poor work harder, you pay them less. Judges deserve jobs for life; uncouth dockers don't. bosses and their system, the right to work' is too expensive to be granted. If they can't afford to employ people, they won't. But it's

Denham

Labour MP Tony Worthington's Right of Reply:

Bill has returned from the dead.

This Friday MPs will have another chance to give a statutory right of reply to those who claimate LIC VICELLS press tima "inaccuracy" If Worthington succeeds, papers will have tc publish corrections with the same prominence as the original offending - articles.

At present, when a paper like the Sun loses a cast at the Pres: Council, it tucks the correctior away in the corner of an inside page and might even denounce the Press Council decision in its editoria? column.

Worthington's Bill sounds like an excellent idea, doesn't it? It has the backing of the Campaign for Press and Broadcasting Freedom and many prominent left-wing MPs are among its most enthusiastir supporters. More suprisingly, quite a few Tories are in favour of it and Mrs Thatcher is said to be "ambivalent" on the matter; the word is that the Bill could well gu through.

So why are some of us less thar wholeheartedly enthusiastic abou the proposal for legally-enforceable redress for the victims of press lies For a start, the wording of the Bill is dangerously sloppy — it give no guidelines on what would actually constitute a "factua inaccuracy". Look through the res of this paper: you'll find plenty oi articles accusing the Tories, variou employers and even some unior leaders of all sorts of nasty things.

They might well object to a lot of what we say about them, and clain that their motives are entirel honourable and their actions reail in the best interests of us all - dir we but know it. Who is to judge?

Well, if Tony Worthington get. his way, a group government appointed commissioners answerable only to the Hom Secretary - will judge. Do yor really want to give this governmen that sort of power over the press Just remember 'Spycatcher" 'Death on the Rock', the nev Official Secrets Act - even the ludicrous Lonrho affair' and! ask yourself if you'd willingly giw Mrs Thatcher and Mr Hurd additional powers to determine what goes into the newspapers.

Of course, the general standard of the British press are a disgrace Opinion polls have shown that mosi people - quite rightly - thin:1 something has to be done to curi! the excesses of the gutter press.

But Tony Worthington's would not particularly help the many "little people' who hav: suffered at the hands of the Sur the Star and the News of the Worla! What it would certainly do is ga: genuine investigative journalisms: give the government additions! powers to interfere in the media and make life impossible for left wing papers.

Socialists, more than mos: people, have good reason to hat the national press and to relish th pr seemo that more and mot ordinary people share our feeling. on this subject.

But giving the state more power.

even over the Murdochs ask. Maxwells of this world - wouk: simply make matters worse.

----- pull-quotes -----

PRESS GANG

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 398

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →