[reviews 'Working Girl" Working Girl" is a fairy…]
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-04-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
reviews 'Working Girl"
Working Girl" is a fairy W tale updated for the new world of female corporate achievers. In it Cinderella wants to get into the boardroom, not go to a ball, and she wants to do it on her own, too, not by marrying any stray prince who might come along.
At the beginning, Tess (Melanie Griffith) is a filofax toting secretary with a ferocious ambition to get on in New York's hustling, bustling brokerage world. But she's from the wrong side of the tracks (or rather the water; she's from Staten Island) and so she keeps getting turned down for training programmes at work.
Every day Tess joins the group of workers who crowd on to the Staten Island ferry for the trip to Manhattan. They're like guest workers, tolerated by day because they're needed to do the lowly jobs, but banished at night. Tess already a little apart from the girls she grew up with. She's struggled to get her degree by studying at night, and she's taking voice lessons too. But she looks all wrong - lots of makeup and jangly jewellery, teased hair.
When she's assigned to a new female boss, Tess thinks her big moment has come. Katherine, played by Sigourney Weaver, has a good line in psycho-babble; she tells Tess that she herself must be the one to 'make it happen'. Tess tries. She reads everything, follows the market, and comes up with bright ideas.
When Katherine is put out of action by a skiing accident, Tess sees her chance. Like Michael J. Fox in "The Secret of My Success' she takes over Katherine's empty office, and starts putting deals LES HEARN S together. It's a bluff, but she hopes it will pay off.
In the meantime, she meets Prince Charming, another dealmaker, played with a kind of bewildered aplomb by Harrison Ford, but it's still the deal that interests Tess. It's rather nice to see a woman in movies put love second for a change. (In "Baby Boom" Diane Keaton threw away her million dollar deal to stay with her sweetheart in rural bliss).
The plot takes a few twists and turns with the introduction of the fairy godfather, Orrin Trask, who plays the latest in a long line of supposedly 'nice' capitalists. Hollywood has long been in love with these mythical figures, men who must have risen to the top by ruthless ambition and exploitation, but who have hearts of gold underneath. Somehow they never quite work.
Sigourney Weaver's Katherine turns out to be the ugly sister, despite all her surface charm, and in fairy tale style, she gets the Such efforts have not been successful, using more energy than they have produced, as well as costing hundreds of millions of pounds. Therefore, when chemists Stanley Pons and Martin Fleischmann, of the Universities of Utah and Southampton, claimed to comeuppance she deserves.
The film is a study in serendipity. Far from being a manual on how to make it, it's almost a cautionary tale; Tess succeeds by extraordinary luck. Amazing improbabilities just keep stacking up on her side. But for every Tess, there are also a hundred girls like Cyn, Tess's friend, who stays in Staten Island, marries her childhood sweetheart, and never gets further than the typing pool.
There's no questioning at all in the movie about whether what Tess wants is worth having. Manhattan Is presented as the magic kingdom of opportunity, whose gleaming towers seem to mock at the poor Staten Islanders across the water. There's no glimpse of the sordid side of New York, nor any condemnation of corporate cut and thrust, except where it hurts Tess. The room where the deal is to be signed is like a chapel consecrated to the twin gods of money and success.
The barriers keeping where they are held fast in a small volume. They are held under an effective pressure far higher than that at the centre of the sun.
There is still a substantial energy barrier to their fusion but, due to a phenomenon called 'quantum tunnelling', some pairs of ions still are the barriers of class. She has the wrong accent, the wrong clothes, the wrong background. Yet though the capitalist system is what is keeping Tess down, it is also the elevator that she finally gets on in her ride to the top. The film seems to be saying "Capitalism can work for you!" But the small print says, "Only if you're one in a million" Tess is that one in a million.
What is delusive in films like "Working Girl" is that every single person will identify with Tess and So while Girl" making it, everyone watching the film can go away comforted, thinking she too would be the successful one, given half the chance.
Because capitalism offers the occasional individual an escape clause, it can seem less unbearable than it is. Each person can dream that success is just a round the corner. "Working Girl' • is just a female version of that other old fairy tale, the American Dream.