[City Council decided on a policy in 1983…]
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-04-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
City Council decided on a policy in 1983, that committed it to an all-out fight with the Tories. Unlike other councils, they worked hard to convince local working class people that a fight was necessary and possible. In later 1983, Liverpool saw a one-day general strike in support of the council and in defiance of the Tories.
But the campaign never reached such a pitch again.
It was wound down after the local elections in May 1984. By then the miners' strike was underway — the biggest single working class struggle since World War Two. And the miners' strike created a context that both Liverpool and the Tory government had to be aware of. The Tories were: Militant weren't.
In his book Inside Left', Derek Hatton recounts how a Tory MP money. At this stage we want Scargill. He's our priority. But we'll come for you later."
In short, Liverpool were being fobbed off to divide the labour movement. This is what Militant called a 95 per cent victory!
Then things got worse and worse. Militant began to alienate important sections of the community in Liverpool, notably the section of the black community represented in the Black Caucus. The Caucus had been recognised as representative by the council; but Militant picked a fight with it by appointing a Militant supporter, Samson Bond, as Race Relations officer.
Who was right in the dispute that followed isn't really very important. The council needed full support against the Tories; if a fight with the Black Caucus was necessary, it could have waited. But to achieve their own objective — a political appointment (one of many), Militant were prepared to provoke a bitter and deeply divisive controversy.
In typical Militant style, they then demanded full support against the Black Caucus from the rest. of the left, denouncing left-wing critics as 'witch hunters' . This was a technique they repeated throughout the coming months.
Meanwhile the council was sleepwalking towards disaster. It made general agitation about fighting the Tories but ran no real campaign like the one it organised in 1983-4. Periodically council leaders predicted all-out struggle in the next few days. Workers in Liverpool got confused, then demoralised. Support for the council faded.
In September 1985, the council committed the fantastic blunder (later admitted by Militant as 'a mistake') of sending sacking notices to all 30,000 of its staff, because money was running out. In the chaos that ensued, a Swiss bank came up with the money, and more breathing-space was found.
But the council never recovered. It had been defeated; soon, lett wing councillors were fined and barred from office.
But it turned out the deal with the Swiss bank had been concluded two months before it was made public. So for two months, the council had been playing games with its own supporters. That alone is a disgrace.
The disgraceful behaviour of Derek Hatton, who increasingly became an embarrassment to Militant, was just the public face of the inner political collapse of the Militant in Liverpool.
Like other Labour lefts, they "seized control' of the local government machine - and in the end the machine seized them.
Their much-vaunted "Marxism' didn't help much. There were two main reasons for this.
First, Militant see control of the machine almost as an end in itself (as we shall see when we look at the unions).
Second, Militant's *Marxist perspective" always says that the situation will improve. If the future is going to prevent better opportunities for socialists, why risk anything in struggles now?
Due partly to luck and partly to its position in the Labour Party, Militant was able to grow. Even so, it has always been a sect. It only acts out of self-interest; when it controls something - like the LPYS - it strangles it. What the working class needs is a different sort of Marxist tendency' altogether.
Since 1970 Militant has failed to give any suppo • to the struggles of the ol pressed Catholic minority in Northern Ireland.
Support for working class unity and socialism is not unique to Militant. What is unique is the use of abstract lectures about socialism to evade the issues and the struggles of the here and now.
Initially it opposed the deployment of British troops on the streets after August 1969, and sympathised with the Catholics. It quickly veered (by 1970 or "71) to an attitude of condemning the "sectionalism' and then the 'terrorism' of the Catholics. It was like its attitude to the struggles of blacks, womeH gays and others in Britain itself: the Catholic revolt in Northern Ireland was a complication which it wished would go away.
Ever since Militant has not supported the just revolt of the Catholics. Within the labour move. ment they are among the most vicious opponents of any attempt to get a calm discussion of the Republicans, their struggle and their objectives. Militant peddles its own cure-alls and nostrums, like the famous 'trade union defence force'.
In 1969, it speculated, fanSix Counties unit!
*If the demands (minimum wage; equal pay; crash building programme; take over big building companies; improved social services) are pressed home in action, it can be linked up to the demand for the taking over the big monopolies and the establishment of a democratic socialist society -which would have immediate repercussions in the South, Britain, and internationally. (Militant, May 1969).
Then, responding to the slaughter of 14 Catholics by the British Army in January 1972, Militant waxed eloquent about...organising the British Army for socialism.
"A campaign of individual assassinations...of the British soldiers can only provide excuse for further repressions...Also it can only reinforce the hostility of the ordinary soldier to the Catholic population...(Rank and file soliders) could be appealed to on a class basis and won away from the army brass, if a clear socialist alternative was given to them." (Militant, February 4, 1972).
Faced with what looked like civil war in mid-'72, Peter Taaffe wrote this: "But, given the failure of the trade union leadership to initiate a trade union defence force, every working class area must have the right to defend itself." (Militant no.113, July 1972).
You're on your own boys! In fact this was to give the seal of Militant's approval to the Protestant-bigot Ulster Defence Association (UDA).
It should be remembered that it was the Catholics who were likely to need defending if it came to an all-out war.
Militant's main slogan has been the 'trade union defence force' though the communal clashes against which defence must be organised were in a different world from the trade unions.
At the same time Militant has speculated about the processes going on in the UDA that would produce class consciousness.
*The development of the UDA with its veneer of class consciousness shows that Protestants are well aware of their class position.. (Militant no.118, August 18, 1972)
During the Orange general strike of 1974 Militant opposed any action by the Labour government to break the reactionary -and even racist strike, thus telling British workers that the strike was entitled Workers' defence force? Leaders of the reactionary 1974 strike. to be treated as a working class action, if not quite a proper or normal one.
In 1980-81 Militant opposed the granting of political status to the Republican hunger strikers.
For centuries the Irish people were oppressed by British imperialism. In 1920-21 Southern Ireland won independence - but half a million Catholics were trapped in a *Protestant state for Protestant people' in Northern Ireland. The British government, allied with the Northern Protestants, partitioned Ireland undemocratically.
In the 1960s the Northern Catholics finally rebelled. Signs of some desire for reform from Britain - which had mended its relations with Southern Ireland - and the model of the Civil Rights Movement in the USA encouraged them.
Northern Ireland had been run as a one-party Protestant state, with Protestant workers jobs ting preference for scarce jobs houses. Behind the Catholic revolt the Protestant workers saw the prospect of a reunited Ireland with a Catholic government in Dublin which would oppress them as they had oppressed the Catholics in the North. They reacted with panic and bigotry.
The artificial Northern Ireland state began to fall apart into civil war. British troops went on the streets to hold it together. Britain's strategy was to control the situation by beating down the rebellious Catholics, then impose reforms.
The reforms faded away after a Protestant general strike in 1974 toppled a British-sponsored powersharing' Goint Catholic-Protestant) government in Northern Ireland. The repression against the Catholics remained.
The Catholics are fighting against British repression, and a Britishdominated state, that they never wanted to be part of. Socialists must support them. At the same time we must put forward ideas for a positive solution.
Replacing a half-million oppressed minority of Catholics in Northern Ireland by a million-strong oppressed minority of Protestants in a united Ireland would not be progress; and anyway, given the strength of the Protestants, it is not possible.
A serious drive to push the Protestants into a united Ireland by brute force would result only in full-scale civil war and repartition.
That is why Socialist Organiser argues for a free federal united Ireland, with regional autonomy for the mainly-Protestant areas.
Militant answers none of the issues. Instead it preaches about abstract socialism to evade them.
----- pull-quotes -----
LIVERPOOL COUNCIL
told him: "You do realise that we had to tell Patrick to give you the
SUPPOI LABOUA
tastically, about the prospects for pioneering socialist society in...the