Is Militant Marxist?
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-04-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Derek Hatton: while Militant campaigned for workers' MPs on workers* wages, he was their public figurehead on Liverpool The Militant tende is still perhaps the biggest and best-known of the left groups in this countr But where do Militan really stand? Clive Bradley investigates. Part Two next week f you ever hear the Militant tendency talk about the rest of the 'far Left', you'll notice they describe everyone as *the sects'. But Militant are themselves a real sect, even if an unusually large one by British standards. They're a bit like a religious sect — a group walled off from the rest of the world convinced they've got the tablets of stone, and seeing their own interests as the most important thing.
Debate on the left is as important as unity, if we're to build an intelligent socialist movement. Different left groups should argue, debate and criticise each other — and unite against the right-wing.
What is a Marxist tendency? Marxism is a way of analysing society which understands politics as the sum total of struggle between different classes — mainly between big business and the working class. We think real change comes about when people fight for it. A national dock strike, if the whole labour and trade union (and student) movement back it, will have more effect in turning the tide on the Tories than glitzy Labour Party TU commercials.
So Marxists don't just analyse the try to find a no been our leas about society and the struggles that take place.
The working class will change society. And the working class in Britain has built a movement - the Labour Party and the trade unions - over 200 years. We get involved council to change this movement can change the world.
The movement won't change all in one go. The working class learns lessons from its different stuggles; but sometimes it is a slow process and the job of Marxists is to help the working class learn, not like teachers with a blackboard, but by being part of the education itself.
A Marxist tendency is that section of the movement that has studied and understood the big lessons of the class struggle. It tries to help the rest of the movement learn the same lessons by fighting alongside it, and within it.
A sect, on the other hand, just sees changing society as a matter of gradually getting bigger. It sees getting bigger as more important than the development of the whole movement.
Back in the heady days of 1968 Militant was a small very lacklustre part of the left. In the "70s it grew to a few thousand supporters because it had control of the Labour Party Young Socialists (LPYS). It took control in 1969-70, when the rest of the left had left the Labour Party -sometimes out of stupidity, sometimes to get involved in big stuggles against the Labour government in the late 'sixties, and the Tories in the early 'seventies.
The 17 years or so during which Militant ran the LPYS were a strange time in the history of Labour's youth movements.
Outside those 18 years, the entire history is of radical, combative groups gaining support among the youth and coming into stormy conflict with Labour's bureaucratic leaders. But the 17 years of revolutionary Marxist' leadership by Militant were years of peace and quiet. And then when Neil Kinnock decided to shut down the LPYS it went with scarcely a whimper.
When Militant took over the LPYS, it was a shell with a few right wingers in it. The Labour Party leadership had imposed undemocratic rules on the LPYS, because in the early 'sixties the LPYS had been too radical.
Militant never changed those DEGSY rules, and fiercely opposed those us who wanted them changed.
For example, LPYS National Committee was not elected by its annual national conference regional conferences elected one representative each, instead. This meant that the NC was not accountable to the conferences that made the policy it was supposed to act on.
It also meant that minority views never had any hope of representation. Unlike the National Union of Students for example, there was never any provision for minority viewpoints to be reflected on the the leading committee. If NUS Exec was elected in the way LPYS NC was, Militant would not have anybody on it.
So the LPYS was generally not very democratic. At national conferences the overwhelming majority of speaking time was taken up by Militant (often through long 'summing up') with very little debate. Debates were often stitchedup to make sure as few non-Militant supporters as possible got to speak.
Democracy and debate aren't just nice thoughts for the working class movement. We need debate, so we can be sure about what we're doing.
Worse, the LPYS was never much more than a stage with a Militant speaker on it. It never intervened in the world around it. Two examples:
1. In the late 1970s, there was the biggest radicalisation of youth since the Vietnam war, focussed around the Anti-Nazi League (ANL).
The ANL was set up by the Socialist Workers' Party. It had lots wrong deroined because it failed to deten black people from fascist attacks. In October 1978, the ANI deliberately avoided a clash with fascists threatening the Asian community in East London, and marched tens of thousands of people to a pop concert instead.
But thousands of youth involved in and around the ANL wanted to do something to stop the National Front, who had been getting high votes in by-elections. And the ANL certainly did help force the NF into the retreat.
A socialist youth movement should have got involved been he tely antivists in it, it id been the best activists in tried to give it a socialist direction. That way, it would have built itself.
The LPYS largely sat on the sidelines, complaining that the ANL wasn't socialist. Militant wasn't in East London, helping the Asian community to beat back the fascists — and it wasn't visible at the ANL pop concert either!
This was typical Militant. Their argument ran: "We know how to fight fascism - fight for socialism. That's the only way - anything less is a blind alley. The ANL are wasting their time."
For Militant, 'understanding' or "seeing the need for socialism', was an alternative to actual struggle in the here and now. They just criticisec the ANL (sometimes fairly, often not) rather than try to convince ANL activists by fighting alongside them.
The end result, of course, was that the ANL collapsed and very few of the youth in it got involved in the LPYS.
2. A few years later, there was another youth radicalisation, around Youth CND. It was a repeat performance.
The Militant-dominated LPYS did almost no work in the YCND. Instead it lectured YCND that 'only socialism can stop war' (which is true) and felt very pleased with itself. Another opportunity was wasted.
Again, Militant's arguments were typical of them. They had a very off-hand attitude to the thre it of nuclear war (implying it impossible because the working class was too strong) and were opposed to British withdrawal from NATO (because it would make no real difference).
They didn't understand that a struggle against nuclear weapons — or NATO - could make far more difference to people's understanding and to their real ability to achieve socialism, than Militant's patient explainations Explaination is fine - but it must be connected to struggles around us, or it doesn't really contribute to building a socialist movement. Militant counterposed a future socialist movement to the currentactivists, who could create such a day 'raw material', like YCND movement.
Year after year for 17 years, Militant had declared at each year's LYS conference that it was the best ever. "The Marxists" were going ever onwards and upwards, building a strong movement of working class youth.
When Kinnock finally moved against it, that movement proved to be dead and hollow. It crumbled into dust. Militant moved shop into the Youth Trade Union Rights Campaign and the National Union of Students - and there was nothing left.
Empty, lifeless, bureaucratic, radical in its words about 100% nationalisation but timid and narrow-minded in activity - that, on the evidence of the LPYS, is what a Militant-led youth movement looks like. Students attracted by Militant's new upbeat style in the National Union of Students should take note.
Because Militant only saw the LPYS as a theatre to perform in, it remained small and ineffective. When the Labour Party leadership decided to axe it, they met little real resistance.
The whole story of the witchhunt is instructive too. The current Kinnockite leadership of the Labour Party came about because of the 'rise and fall' of the Labour Left. Militant's sectarianism throughout that process cut their own throat later.
Thatcher won the election of 1979 because the previous Labour government had been a disaster. Labour Party activists resolved *never again' to allow a Labour government like it - right-wing, cut-making, ignoring conference policy, anti-working class. powerful campaign for democracy was organised.
Its culmination was the campaign to elect Tony Benn as Labour Party Deputy leader, in 1981. He was very narrowly defeated. Other victories had been won - that Leader and Deputy Leader were elected at all, for were elected at all. example. But thereafter, reasons we will go into, the movement declined, Militant played very, very little role in all this - except in their usual way of making general propaganda. When the right wing counter-attacked after 1981, Militant argued it was impossible for them to win, because the left was too strong.
Militant itself was a big target for the right-wing, of course - not because it had been the main force fighting for change, but because it was visible and unpopular. The witch-hunt was launched.
Just as Militant had little to do with the democracy campaign, ll also had little to do with lighting the witch-hunt. It had its own front, and paid little attention to Labour Against the witchhunt, the campaign run by Labour rank and file activists. In fact, Militant tended to be far more timid than most Labour Party activists. Instead of mobilising, it went to the capitalist courts. This was wrong in principle — we don't want the capitalist courts deciding the internal affairs of the labour movement - and foolishly short-sighted in practice.
When the knives came out for the LPYS from 1986, Militant put up very little opposition. LPS national conference was abolished and Militant's campaign to save it was too little, too late.
then, something else had B happened which had shaped British politics generally, and to which Militant had been central: Liverpool.
Local government proved to be both an opportunity and a snare for the Labour Left. The same Labour Left that had fought the right wing on democracy found itself in many cases in control of local town halls in the early 1980s.
There was a great opportunity to use Labour councils as the organising centres for war on the Tory government; instead, over time, the left councils gave up the idea of fighting the Tories and set about making cuts and in many instances acting like old-style employers. So the Labour Left was defeated - and defeat propelled it to the right.
In Liverpool Militant was the dominant political force. Liverpool
----- pull-quotes -----
SUPR LIV