Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[For some time now sections of Stalinists like…]

Socialist Organiser no. 397, 13 April 1989 · scan p. 7 · Jack Allison · about 1,505 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

For some time now sections of Stalinists like Miodowicz will be Solidarnosc is a great prize won by the Polish opposition have able to mobilise some workers the Polish workers. The expressed the view that Solidarnosc against the reforms and Solidarnosc introduction of a 35% block of has built a bureaucracy of its own, due to the effects of the economic freely elected members of the based on a leadership who would opposition into Parliament and the rather negotiate for reforms with reft seens highly unikely that the establishment of a freely elected the state and subdue radical action reforms from the round-table will senate provide for the first time than fight for real change. One of prevent a new outbreak of strikes. since the establishment of the the groups who express this mood The PPS-RD and rank and file Stalinist system an open political in the Polish opposition is the groups need not only to link these Polish Socialist Party-Democratic struggles through strike committees We must however recognise that Revolution.

PPS-RD and various rank and or a clear leadership from system democratic. The senate is file workers groups have for some Solidarnosc. The fight for a unlikely to have much power and time pointed to the contradiction socialist leadership of Solidarnosc the whole opposition are only given inside Solidarnosc between a radical in the struggles to come is central.

Real power will still rest with the and a leadership composed of big work in Solidarity with our class in ruling party. Parliament will elect a names' from the 1980s.

In the 1980s Solidarnosc was take the mass of the Polish people the ruling party, who will have great built as a workers' free trade union, forward is a system of democratic power. Control of the state, the based on the tinest traditions of workers' control of society a army and the economy is still firmly working class democracy and workers' revolution not just in the grip of the state-monopoly action. It was built by a massive reform. "social movements. John Rentoul, after disputing all Marxism Today's assessment, paradoxically arrives at very similar conclusions.

He wants a "radical left-wing "revolution"" - but the scarequotes round the word revolution' need to be there! This 'revolution' is to be achieved by Labour reducing its links with the trade unions and allying with the Democrats in a 'popular front' based on the collectivist and liberal consensus which (Kentoul believes) already commands a majority in Britain.

Rentoul finds that "The class divide remains, even if some don't think it has widened...Class divisions have become deeper and sharper...Class...is the most important factor in British politics " Yet in his conclusions he ignores this "most important factor"

Class struggle remains the road to change. Working class confidence in struggle has been severely battered in recent years, and so, in manly areas, has workers organisation. But British society has not been reduced to the stifling conformism and 'normalcy' of the early 1950s, of the 1850s-1880s, or of America in the 1920s.

Even if it had, the fact would still remain that capitalism can never abolish the working class and can never stifle working class struggle more than temporarily. But one of Rentoul's most startling opinion poll figures is for the percentage of people who say that they have been politically active beyond just to influencean Ast of Parliament?.

In 1959 only 6 per cent had been active on that level; in 1986, 44 per cent. Most of that 44 per cent had done nothing more militant than sign a petition; but the figure does point to an increased readiness to think critically and to speak out about politics. We haven't been "replaced by sensible persons" yet.

Thatcherism still has many storms ahead of it; and, while socialist politics in coming years will have a big proportion of long, hard slog in it, there will also be more boisterous, turbulent moments.

We need an alternative both to market economics and to nationalist, bureaucratic '1945 socialism' - a programme based on internationalism, workers control, workers' I democracy and Imost without exception A the round-table discussLions in Poland between Solidarnosc and the state have been reported without the slightest mention of the massive strike wave of last summer which forced the Polish state to renegotiate.

That round of strikes forced the Polish ruling class to realise that they could not afford to ignore Solidarnosc and that their attempt to crush opposition has tailed, post 1981.J Once the Polish state offered the round-table talks, the Solidarnosc leaders jumped at the chance and actively quashed the strike wave of August 1988 to meet the conditions laid down for the talks.

The Solidarnosc leaders' attempts to cool down the strike wave aroused the anger of many strikers. The strikes had not been started by the Solidarnose leaders, who only put themselves at the head of the strikes after they had started and spread.

During my visit to Poland in January this year, I witnessed a great uVaI areat deal of resentment at the quashing of the August strikes. It also became clear that most of the radicals in Solidarnosc had little interest in the round-table talks.

After months of delay and weeks of talks, the results of the discussions were announced in a bizzare television broadcast on Wednesday 4 April. What will the round-table aggreement mean for Polish workers and Solidarnose?

The political reforms of the system are certainly to be welcomed. The legalisation of challege to the system. these changes will not make the a 35% stake in the Parliament.

President, inevitably the leader of Protest in Czechoslovakia The elections will open up great opportunities for the opposition to organise. The degree of freedom allowed in the elections, especially to socialists like the PPS-RD will be a test of the limits of Polish glasnost.

But there is a catch. Lech Walesa called for an end to industrial action during the talks. And now the discussions are over, the catch is clearer in the economic 'deal' contained in the agreement.

Information on this economic "deal' is still limited. However, several central elements seem clear. The 'deal' seems to have pulled the Solidarnosc leadership behind the Polish state's 'economic reform programme' Lech Walesa has launched himself into a campaign to get foreign economic aid, stating that he is prepared to beg for it, if necessary. And the round-table agreement has pegged workers' wage rises at 80% of the inflation rate.

The state wanted a far lower figure, but the decision of the Solidarnosc leadership to agree to a wage cut of 20% a year in an economy of 100% plus annual inflation and great poverty will be met with massive opposition.

How strong and effective the opposition is will depend on the extent to which the leadership of Solidarnosc headed by Walesa will try to hold back the workers demanding and fighting for wage rises over the 80%.

It certainly seems that the state have managed to tie the Solidarnosc leadership into their programme of *economic reforms' - whether it can tie the Polish workers to this programme and whether it can hold the Solidarnosc leaders when the workers fight back is another matter. t rank and file worker and youth base workers revolt and soon grew to a mass movement of some 10 million people. The workers were always central to Solidarnosc.

The last few years, however, have seen leaders like Lech Walesa move away from this view towards a view of Solidarnosc as a broad social movement - not a union or even a worker based movement. The PPS-RD and rank and file groups have on the other hand asserted that it is vital to rebuild the union and Solidarnosc based on workers and their demands.

It is highly unlikely that these groups will support the results of the round-table talks, and the gulf between the Solidarnosc leadership and these activists is hound to widen. MAAM Walesa still commands enormous respect, but he did not come out of strikes shihout hair amount of workers' resentment against him. If the Solidarnosc leadership intend to try to hold workers to the 80% ceiling to wage rises and to the economic reform programme of the state, Walesa's authority could soon diminish.

This new situation will face the militants with the massive and vital task of preventing this loss of faith in the leadership and especially in Walesa turning to disillusionment, and instead organising the workers behind a socialist leadership to rebuild Solidarnosc. the economic reform shora mae will fail to solve the massive crisis in the Polish state monopoly system. In the light of this one danger arises from an unlikely quarter.

Mr Miodowicz, the leader of the state 'trade union' , is calling the deal a sell-out of the workers. Fine words from a Stalinist butcher of workers and free trade unions!

The danger is that hard as they did in 1988 but also to fight We must support that fight and Poland. The only change that can

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 397

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →