Taking sides in Afghanistan
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-04-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
frightening resurgence of A far-right sympathies in West Germany has been revealed by a poll in Der Spiegel magazine.
The poll asked West Germans to rate their sympathy for Adolf Hitler on a scale from + 5 to -5. Only 36% rated Hitler entirely negatively, at -5. 14% gave him a positive mark, and 12% a zero.
A staggering 43% thought the National Socialist period had good and bad sides, though only 3% considerer it be be clearly positive.
Continuing anti-semitic attitudes were also revealed by the poll.
Social security benefits rise one million claimants the real value of their benefits will drop.
Some of the worst off claimants have suffered as a result of the changeover last year from supplementary benefit to income support. Over half a million have had their benefits frozen for two years running, because their entitlement under the old system was higher than under the new - all this whilst prices have risen by 12%.
Another 600,000 claimants will get : rise lower than the rate of inflation.
The ending of special allowances fo heating, diet and domestic help have hit those most in need - the old, the sick and the handicapped.
So this is what the Tories mean by targetting' id-Glamorgan Health ment cuts by making a bargain with a car dealer.
recruitment methods, or change traditional work organisation to attract new workers.
A survey of 2,000 employers shows that only half are considering job share or part-time work schemes. Only 14% are making special provision for returning mothers' . One in ten offer extended leave or career-break schemes - and a mere 9% are prepared to consider them.
Childcare is still a major problem, with only 2% of employers offering workplace nurseries, and 19% contributing to childcare costs. M operating in Budapest in • Donalds is already Hungary and is currently setting up 20 outlets in Moscow, the first of them to be open by the end of the year. The future managers of McDonald's outlets in Moscow are already being trained in Canada.
McDonald's has been trying to expand into the Soviet Union since the mid-1970s, but initially without success. A recent article in Pravda explained: "We continued to stigmatise McDonald's as the producer of lowquality food and as a plunderer of peoples** But then things began to change: "In the meantime, for some strange reason or other, these peoples allowe themselves to be "plundered", and turned out to be not in the least choosey about a piece of the 'lowquality food"
In fact, it now turns out that McDonald's is the home of cuisinary Tony Dale (Letters, SO 393) argues that we should support neither side in the current civil war in Afghanistan. The mullah-led 'rebels' are reactionary; the government shares responsibility with the Kremlin for what has been done over the past 9 years.
It might be true to say that whichever side we take won't make much difference: we have no audience for our ideas in Afghanistan. But I don't think socialists should be indifferent to the outcome of the civil war.
The Najibullah government, of course, does share responsibility with Moscow for the years of occupation - it has blood on its hands, or maybe up to its neck. And I don't think there's any question of supporting the government.
But wouldn't socialists have to choose whose side to fight on? Without giving any support to Najibullah, and indeed whilst ruthlessly criticising Najibullah, not least for collaborating with the USSR, I think we'd choose to fight against the Mujahedin. We'd choose to be alongside people who wanted to see rights for women, land reforms, some secularisation and so on.
It isn't unusual for socialists to participate in one side of a civil war without supporting the government currently expressing that side: consider the Spanish Civil War of 1936-9. Socialists were simultaneously against the Popular Front government but with the Republican struggle.
I'm not saying Afghanistan now principles are similar.
Perhaps Tony felt that by taking sides now we are retrospectively condemning our own record on Afghanistan - which was wholehearted opposition to the Russian 'side'. Certainly some left groups have jeered at us along those lines.
But it only shows the limits of our support for the Stalinist side. We don't and can't support them to the extent of riding roughshod over the national rights of Afghanistan, Vla a Russian occupation which if it were to have been successful would have required more brutality and oppression.
If it's the case that the only way the 'progressive forces' in Afghanistan can win is through the USSk wiping out a large section of the population and imposing its own techniques of T rule, thie "progressive forces' will will have to lose.
I'm not sure it is the on things look bleak now for tieth century, it's the fault. Our political prio state that openly.
But even during Russial ton, we weren't indif ferent to social questions in Afg thanistan, and would have been defence of what limited pi rogressive measures had been introdi aced. Our emphasis was on the righ its of nations, but that never exha lusted the Now I think our empha sis has to be different. Now it is a m atter of a civil war — now the Russ ians have gone — we do have to ch oose between social forces who at l east identify with modern history, a und social and political forces who n night well be worse than Khomeini.
There isn't really a neat formula to express this approach • Maybe "Defend the cities" wa isn't too brilliant a slogan. But I think Tony's approach is sectaria an - and followed through consisten itly could lead to all kinds of sectari an errors in relating to Third World: Stalinism of the Afghan type.
Hard Ellis, muthwark
----- pull-quotes -----
M Authority is planning te compensate for govern-
socialist possibilities in A thanistal are microscopic. But the general