Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Comparing the USSR to ancient despotism

Socialist Organiser no. 397, 13 April 1989 · scan p. 4 · about 427 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

Anti-Nazi protest in Frankfurt revives GRAFFIITI F11Z.800 TIM espite the lack of skilled D labour, and the shortage of school-leavers entering the workforce, most employers: doing nothing to change their ETTERS found very interesting the article of Clive Bradley (SO 388) in which he compared the Soviet Union to the Ottoman Empire. For my part, I have a similar analogy in mind for a long time. We once discussed this question in Turkey.

The Soviet bureaucracy was born as a pseudo-class from a political counter-revolution led by Stalin. I would also say that it was a by-product of Bolshevism.

It is a fact that the Russian Revolution was a premature and unexpected revolution. It occurred by chance. Lenin never foresaw that a socialist revolution would take place in Russia. Only Plekhanov and Trotsky had foreseen it a long time before. Trotsky elaborated his theory of Permanent Revolution.

The other problem is that the Leninist concept of party was one ot an end for itself just like a conspiratorial organisation. It was a finalist or teleological concept.

Stalin found a ready-made machine in his hands. The party bodies were already ideologically assimilated and they were submitted to the supreme authority. And he used it in a very talented way to usurp the political power. The means were transformed into an end in itself.

The bureaucracy was born as a pseudo-class. It did not have the legal ownership of the means of production. But that is not important. The promulgation of laws does not determine the entire process.

What is important is how the system or organism works and how its self-regulation reproduces it: that is what defines whether the bureaucracy is a new class.

The bureaucracy is an independent and uncontrolled body. It controls the means of production and dominates the society and economy. It usurps the surplus and it uses this surplus according to its own needs. I think these are the most important points to classify a social group and decide whether it is a ruling class or not.

Effectively the bureaucracy acts as a ruling class. But I'm not certain that the Soviet Union and the others represent a new type of class society from the phylogeneticosociological points of view. More correctly speaking, I can't find a term for them.

In sum, there is a class exploitation in the Soviet Union and the similar societies. This exploitation is somewhat similar to that in the Ottoman Empire and the Asiatic type of production described by Marx.

Adem Topol Dijon, France.

----- pull-quotes -----

NAZIS® RAUS

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 397

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →