Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Playing into the hands of the nationalists

Socialist Organiser no. 396, 6 April 1989 · scan p. 9 · about 453 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

W declared Canon Ken- e represent Scotland, Lyon Wright, a member of the Scottish Council of Churches, in his speech which opened the Scottish Constitutional Convention (SCC) in Edinburgh last Thursday, 30 March.

Beer-gutted trade union bureaucrats and pompous politicians, and clerics, took turns at proclaiming themselves the proud heirs of a tradition stretching back through the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland of 1842 and the Scottish Parliament of 1689 to the Declaration of Arbroath of 1320.

The names of William Ewart Gladstone, Mahatma Gandhi and Hugh McDiarmid were all invoked as the spiritual founding fathers of this select gathering, jointly chaired Labour right-winger Harry Ewing MP and David Steel, exleader of the party whose name no-one can remember.

Roddy John McLeod, a member of Commun Na Gaidhlig, sought to address the gathering in Gaelic and demanded that Gaelic be the language of the SCC, but to no avail. No-one could understand him.

Green Party member Phil O'Brien was impolite enough to point out that Labour had won less than 50% of the vote in Scotland and said demands such as proportional representation, a freedom of information act, and removal of all nuclear bases from Scotland, should be taken up by the SCC. Labour MP John McAllion promptly slapped down such dangerous proposals "harangue" as he preferred to call them — as they would only result in divisions which would benefit the Tories.

It fell to the representative of the Communist Party (Eurocommunist variety) to sum up the philosophy of the SCC, when he asked all political parties to forget political differences until a Scottish Assembly had been established.

Issues such as the poll tax or the government's Scottish Homes scheme, both of which were coming into effect less than 48 hours after this circus, were, needless to say, not even touched upon. Instead, the SCC closed by agreeing to have another meeting. In the summer. In Inverness.

Tories, of course, gave the event the thumbs down. This is because they support Thatcher's policies. The Scottish National Party also gave the event the thumbs down. This is because they know that the SCC is an empty talking-shop which is not going to get anywhere.

The SCC merely plays into the hands of the SNP. It reinforces the tendency to replace class-againstclass politics by Scotland versus England politics. The SCC will fail to deliver anything. Then the SNP can step forward, as the "true" representatives of Scotland.

The labour movement should demand that our representatives pull out of this talking shop and base themselves instead on poll tax non-payers, tenants fighting Scottish Homes, trade unionists defending their rights, and all the other forces putting up a real fight against the Tories.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 396

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →