6 THE WORKING CLASS TODAY We can turn the tide
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-04-06Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Defeats over rece years have led to depression in the labour movement continued defeat inevitable. Sarah Cotterill dissents.
During a decade of Tory rule the working class has had many defeats. Two of our best organised sections — the miners and the printers — have lost major battles.
Sweeping anti-union legislation has been introduced, largely unopposed. 'Flexible' working - part-time, temporary, sub-contracted labour - has been increased to cover a third of the workforce. Privatisation in hospitals and local government has divided workers.
At the same time, the working class has changed. The proportion of manual workers has decreased from 75% of the workforce in 1911 to 40% today. The service industries — mainly state services — have grown enormously. White collar workers (typists, cashiers, health workers, office workers, teachers, etc.) are now over half of the workforce. We've also seen the development of mass unemployment.
The labour movement has to respond both to the attacks on our class and to the changes within it. How?
A defeatist response has been argued by the Communist Party magazine Marxism Today and its guru, Eric Hobsbawm. They conclude that the working class has been vanishing since the late 1940s. As more people take up white collar jobs, they achieve an affluence which is reflected in a decline in class consciousness and a deterioration of the Labour Party vote.
The solution? An alliance between Labour and the Alliance parties to defeat Thatcher. We need, they say, to look to new forces outside the working class - women, black people, lesbians and gay men, peace activists, eto.
When Hobsbawm says the working class is vanishing, what he means is that the manual working class is decreasing. This is true. But for socialists, being working class doesn't mean doing dirty jobs.
The working class is made up of all those who have to sell their labour power to live, regardless of what work they do or how much they are paid. If that is the definition of working class, the working class is thriving, not vanishing. But it is changing.
The number of white collar jobs has expanded - in health, local government, shops, catering, office work, etc. In the past many of these were high-status, better-paid jobs, linked to management. Today they are often worse-paid than skilled manual workers.
Most white collar workers have no control over their work or the resources they work with, and do no manage other workers. Their work has become increasingly proletarianised. Nurses, teachers, civil servants, typists, etc. have the same position in society as printers, car workers, bullders, etc. Many now work in large workplaces -hospitals, DHSS offices, town halls, office blocks — and are, or potentially could be, as strongly unionised as factory workers.
Women will be half the waged workforce by the early 1990s. In the 1950s we were only a quarter. The main increase has been in part-time work and in service industries. 62% of part-time workers are women.
Since 1979 the pay differentials between women and men has increased, so women now earn proportionately less than we used to.
There are clearly problems in organising part-time workers but these are not insurmountable. Overall, the entry of women into the waged workforce is to be welcomed, as it brings women into the labour movement.
Capital has invested heavily in new geographical areas like East Anglia, going for 'greenfield' sites where union organisation is weak. The aim is smaller factories, flexible working arrangements and a placid workforce. Compared to the service sector the 'new industries' employ a small number of workers but they are still an important development.
Yes, the working class is changing, and these are real, permanent changes. But they are changes within the class the working class is being reconstituted, not withering a This type of change has been continuous under capitalism, from the early days when most people were agricultural labourers, domestic servants, workers in trade or craft workers, to the times of factories and mines. When Marx wrote Capital, far more workers in Britain were domestic servants than factory or mine workers. As production changes, so does the working class.
If anything, the working class is growing, as increasing sections are proletarianised. The working class is divided: full/part-time; employed/unemployed; men/women; black/white. But it has always been so. These divisions can only be broken down by building basic solidarity through joint labour movement activity.
Marxism Today looks at the changing working class and the weakening of class struggle and concludes that the working class has got more affluent and less combative:
"It is the ancient myth of the Garden of Eden in which a pauperised proletariat lived in socially and geographically isolated communities: their only consolations were beer, Blackpool, football and fish and chips.
They packed the union branch meetings and the Labour Party wards and voted on the basis of the Labour Party and the union right or wrong'. But then came the fall: they were corrupted by Volvos, videos, television sets and two weeks in Majorca.
"Hobsbawm's noble savages are the haggard, brylcreemed footballers, old before their time, peering worriedly from their old team photographs. Like their too-cleverby-half affluent successors today, the electorate has turned Jack the Lad." (John Mcllroy: Hobsbawm and SDP-Communism)
The main evidence for the decline of class consciousness is taken from the drop in trade union membership, 2.9 million since 1979. But the falling numbers are mainly due to the collapse of manufacturing industry in the early '80s and a failure of the trade unions to recruit in the new industries. It is not so much a problem of workers leaving the unions in droves (as they did in the 1920s and 1930s), as of wellMINERS Your Union Needs YOU STRIKE HOW Juppole * Al Healthworkers: a new battalion organised workers losing their jobs.
What is needed is a fight for recruitment to the trade unions in the new industries. Militancy has to be fought for, just as it had to be fought for in the car industry.
Hobsbawm also points to an increase in sectionalism since the early 1950s. But look at the strikes against the Industrial Relations Act at the start of the 1970s! Back in the alleged Golden Age of the 1920s, none of the miners' strikes until 1926 had the backing of the rail unions refusing to handle scab coal. In these days of decay - 1972, 1974, even 1984-5 — the solidarity has been stronger.
There has always been a lot of sectionalism, but surely today, as trade unionism embraces previously unorganised workers - women, white collar - we have greater opportunities for building solidarity.
The period of defeat is dated from the early 1950s. What nonsense! Since then we have seen the development for the first time of shop stewards' structures in many areas, and workers defeating a government in 1974.
The part of Hobsbawm's argument which has been seized on by many Labour leaders is his assessment that the decline in Labour are ahear IThRT ATS f Labour militancy. Photo: Paul Hermann Party support is due to increased affluence. This assumes that Labour voting correlates with poverty, which is not the case. For example, more workers voted Labour in the affluent days of 1966 than at any time in the depression of the 1920s and 1930s.
The working class vote for Labour has not progressively declined, but has gone in ebbs and flows. A decline occurred in the early 1950s, in the late 1960s and after 1979. These have all been times when the political attack on the working class has been intense, but has not met with an adequate response from the labour movement.
Hobsbawm's conclusion is that we need an electoral pact with the Alliance parties to create a popular movement against the Tories. Old-style class politics are out.
This idea is not new. In the 1930s the Communist Parties advocated building Popular Fronts with antifascist bourgeois parties to defeat fascism. In Spain this meant working class organisations were physically smashed and factories seized by workers were returned to their previous owners. This kind of politics has nothing to do with
Scan page 7
Has ahe
----- pull-quotes -----
and some people arguing that