Two cheers for charity?
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-04-06Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Workers' Liberty '89 A weekend of discussion Socialism and Revolution Saturday.
Sunday July 8ch and 9th Caxton House, St John's Way Archway, North London Sessions include:
• A new direction for • Glasnost: is it a revolution?
• Is there a ruling class in Russia? • Iran: ten years after the revolution • Solidarity forever? Trade unions into the 1990s. • Leninism after Lenin • A history of British labour • Imperialism.
nationalism and socialism. • Introducing Marxism COMRADE MAGRET THATCHER organised by Organiser and E6 low-waged, E4 Summer School, n SE15 4NA was interested to read Jim Denham's comments in his Press Gang column on the charity fund raiser 'Comic Relief'. He says he has never been one for the Socialist Worker type sanctimonious approach of pointing out that such fund raising does not address the real problems.
I spent my early days in revolutionary politics with Socialist Worker and learned precisely that attitude towards charity. We would sit stern faced in the pub as anyone came round rattling a tin for the deaf, the blind, orphans, a body scanner or whatever, and refuse to contribute.
To anyone with us who didn't understand our attitude we would explain that the state should provide for these people; that they shouldn't have to rely on charity.
But millions of people give millions of pounds each year to charity. In many ways it is big business - but it does show that there is a human desire to help other people you may never see or meel.
Capitalism has in many ways usurped this desire to its own ends, getting basic needs met on the cheap and having a sort of pressure valve that helps to shift the blame when the state doesn't provide. The best example here would be the recent limit placed on the DHSS Social Fund by the government and the suggestion that people should seek charity where the needs.
Of course we don't think that charity should be relied on to meet needs, there should be state provision that is good and reliable. But meanwhile charity exists, is relied on by people and is widely contributed to.
Certainly the SW attitude is wrong. And it seems to me that Lenny Henry's attacks on government cuts, mentioned by Jim, would have had more impact on people watching Comic Relief precisely because he was trying to raise money for charity.
So what should our attitude be?
Rob Dawber Sheffield
----- pull-quotes -----
Tickets f8 waged, unwaged. Contact: PO Box 823, Londe