Self defence for Afghan workers
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-04-06Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
6 Nov 2026, after a reader report: a letter, answering Tony Dale's in SO 393, signed Duncan Chapel, Nottingham. Transcribed from the scan of page 4; the machine reading had not begun at the start of the letter. 'heterogenous' is as printed.
Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.
Scan page 4
I was surprised to see Tony Dale’s letter in SO393 criticising the development of SO’s position on Afghanistan marked by the slogan ‘Defend the Cities’.
Let’s take a look at the situation. After ten years Soviet troops have left. There is civil war between Najibullah’s Stalinist regime and the Mojahedin. Both sides are offering some form of ‘peace’. Najibullah has offered the rebels local autonomy if they agree to end the war. The Mojahedin are besieging Kabul and the provincial capitals — in an attempt to institute an Islamic fundamentalist regime.
A Marxist approach doesn’t consist of taking sides between the Mullahs and the Stalinists. Marxists have to give here and now solutions to take the weak working class forward. In Afghanistan that means a strategy for ending the civil war and building for a permanent revolution. The workers and peasants should not be fighting one another, but should turn against their Islamic and Stalinist oppressors.
Tony opposes military defence of the gains made for the women and the workers in the cities, but calls for ‘political defence’ instead. Crazy! What is ‘political defence’? Perhaps Tony advocates a special edition of Socialist Organiser — headlined ‘Please Don’t Kill Us’ — for Afghan workers to sell to the Mujahedin?
In fact the line between the political and the military is a fake one. Ultimately, the most pressing task for socialists in central Asia is building a workers’ party that challenges the Mullahs for the political leadership of the peasantry. That can’t be done if the massacres of the working class go on.
Tony says the Mujahedin have mass support. Half right. The Mujahedin is not a coherent political bloc. It is a massive, fragmented and heterogenous Islamic movement against the PDP’s regime. The various factions have been unable to settle their differences, or even build a joint offensive to occupy the cities.
We must call for Afghan workers to defend their cities and their rights. Passive ‘political defence’ will leave them dead. We need a tactical assessment of the situation to take the workers forward.
At best we would argue for independent workers’ militias to build a united front with the PDP against the Mullahs, and then to turn the civil war into a revolution. At the least, we would argue for a ceasefire or conditional surrender leading to autonomy for the various tribes fighting Najibullah’s regime and for a constituent assembly.
When the Soviet troops withdrew, it looked as though the cities would fall within days. In fact the cities — filled with refugees, workers and soldiers — have held out through the Mojahedin’s weakness more than because of their own strength. The class is incredibly weak, but Tony’s conclusion — give up — is wrong.
Tony’s Stalinophobic reaction to the PDP is understandable, if incorrect. Soviet troops were wrong to go in, and should have left, but ‘Defend the Cities’ is not a formula for ‘Troops in’. It means workers’ self organisation. It means calls for international solidarity — ‘not a bullet for the Mullahs, Arm the Afghan workers!’.
It means building a political current in the Afghan workers in solidarity with an international tendency fighting for workers’ liberty East and West.
Some of Tony’s demands — ceasefire, settlement, democratic assembly — I can agree with. But Tony fails to say what social force can carry that programme through. In 1935 Trotsky declared the idea of abstentionism as the most revolutionary of politics to be a dead one. Let’s keep it that way!
Duncan Chapel Nottingham