Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Businesses face a bumpy rid

Socialist Organiser nos. 394–395: How to Beat the Poll Tax, 30 March 1989 · scan pp. 19–20 · about 761 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 19 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 19

Booialist Organizer pamphlet IZ Some of these problems could be reduced by making rates more flexible. Why shouldn't councils be able to charge more rates per pound of property value on bigger, more costly buildings than on small, cheap buildings? Why shouldn't councils be able to set rates on businesses much higher than rates on homes, rather than the relation between them being set by Whitehall?

Local income taxes exist in many other countries. Advantage: your tax rate is decided by your ability to pay. Disadvantage: it would be no fairer than the present national income tax system, with all its loopholes for the rich.

Labour Party policy is for some combination of rates and local income taxes.

Again, a more flexible system could be better. Why shouldn't councils be able to claim a sort of "poll tax" from the employers of workers who live in their area (and from the central government for unemployed people) in the same way that the National Insurance fund collects employers' contributions? After all, employers wouldn't have a workforce without the educa tion, housing, and social services provided by the council: why shouldn't those employers help pay?

Central government grant to The Tories' poll tax law is also a side-swipe against small businesses in many areas.

Businesses will continue to pay rates, but differently from now. At present local councils decide the level of rates and collect rates. Under the new system central government will set a uniform rate, collect the money and redistribute it to councils in proportion to their population.

The Tories say this Uniform Business Rate will be fairer and more predictable than rates are now. After a transitional period, the increase in business rate each year will be fixed by the general rate of inflation.

But the transitional period will be very bumpy indeed.

Rates are calculated by multiplying the "rateable value" of a property (an estimate of the rent on it) by "poundage" (a figure currently set by the council). The Tories' plan means one "poundage" for the whole country.

But rents, and therefore rateable values, tend to be higher in many city centre areas — and so poundages are lower. The Tories' plan, if implemented in 1987-8, would have had the paradoxical result of increasing business rates in "loony left' Islington by 18%, and decreasing business rates in Tory Hertfordshire by between 8% and 15%.

The most drastic effects will be in rich inner city areas like Kensington (rates up 104%), Westminster (up 46%), the City of London (up 47%) and Wandsworth (up 60%).

Rates generally hit small shops more than big businesses, because they're a bigger proportion of turnover. So small shopkeepers will be the people worst hit by these rate rises, too.

At the same time as the Uniform Business Rate is brought in, there will be a comprehensive revaluation of all business properties. This was last done in 1973. The revaluation does not necessarily mean an overall rise in rates - but it will certainly mean sharp rate rises for some individual businesses.

All this makes the Uniform Business Rate unpopular even with bosses' organisations. The Tories have had to cushion the effects by bringing it in gradually over five years. In Scotland this year businesses will pay not Uniform Business Rate but the same rates as last year with an addition for inflation.

Central government control of business rates is bad from a socialist point of view because it means any gap on a council's budget has to be covered either by poll tax or by cuts. Businesses take none of the strain.

Scan page 20

10190 OFFICIAL PICKET 20lg0 OFFICIAL PICKET The next day the union's National Executive turned down calls from two branches (Islington and Knowsley) to hold official ballots for non-cooperation by their members in finance departments.

It was part of a joint retreat, alongside Labour councils in England and Wales. When the preparations were being made for the poll tax in Scotland, Labour councils dithered about how to appear to oppose the tax, yet plan to collect the money.

Councils in England are all just pressing ahead with the tax.

Can council workers stop this retreat? There are important things we can do now, and in future.

The chance of total non-cooperation which would stop poll tax departments being established has already gone, but there are ways of preventing, or at least sabotaging, the operation of the tax.

The many council workers who will be asked to give information have very good reasons not to: housing workers, housing benefit workers, swimming baths

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 394–395: How to Beat the Poll Tax

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →