Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Instead of poll tax

Socialist Organiser nos. 394–395: How to Beat the Poll Tax, 30 March 1989 · scan pp. 18–19 · about 308 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 18 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 18

-he old rates system is not ideal, but it's better than In fact, no system can be ideal. No system of local taxes, however well-designed, can undo the inequality and injustice of capitalism. Only collective ownership and democratic control of the wealth of society can do that.

But some sorts of taxes are better, or less bad, than others.

Rates have one great advantage. They are simple and easy to administer. That's an advantage not just for administrators, but also for socialists. Rich people will always find ways to evade any complicated tax. They can't evade rates.

Moreover, businesses have to pay rates out of their profits as well as workers having to pay out of our wages.

Rates mean the rich paying more than the poor. But - and this is the big disadvantage - they tend to mean the rich paying a smaller proportion of their income than the poor.

Say a worker on £5,000 a year lives in a flat costing £100,000 (there aren't many cheaper than that in London). A capitalist on £500,000 a year might have two houses worth £1 million each.

The capitalist's houses are worth 20 times as much as the worker's flat, so the capitalist pays 20 times as much in rates as the worker. But the capitalist's income is 100 times the worker's.

So the slice that rates take from the capitalist's income is only one-fifth the slice they take from the worker's income.

And if the worker becomes unemployed, or retires, it's even worse. They still have to live somewhere. But now the rates may take half their pension or benefit.

Rates are better than poll tax - but they still bigger slice of from the than from the rich 16 A socialist organiser pamphlet

Scan page 19

"Employ ers wouldn't wouldn councils is good in that it siphons

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 394–395: How to Beat the Poll Tax

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →