Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

NO FINES Lies the Tories tell

Socialist Organiser nos. 394–395: How to Beat the Poll Tax, 30 March 1989 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 590 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

A Socialist Organiser pamphlet Z Die no.1: The poll tax will make councils accountable.

• Central government will decide, not local voters.

Under the poll tax, 20% of councils' money will come from poll tax. Poll tax means more control over councils by Whitehall, not by local voters.

Local voters will be asked to choose between high council spending and high poll tax, and low council spending and low poll tax. Very democratic, the Tories say. But it won't be like that.

The money councils get from Whitehall will be decided by what the government reckons are the needs of the area. And if the government reckons wrong? Too bad.

On current calculations, the poll tax in Labour Islington will be more than twice the rate in Tory Aylesbury Vale. So Islington is twice as spendthrift as Aylesbury Vale? Maybe not. If the Tories' assessment of Islington's needs were 14% higher, and their assessment of Aylesbury Vale's needs just 14% lower, then Islington's poll tax would be lower than Aylesbury Vale's. In other words, your local poll tax measures what the government thinks of your area much more than it measures how spendthrift or stingy your council is.

• The system is biased against inner-city Labour areas.

Inner-city councils with a lot of poverty and a rapidly shifting population, like Islington, will find it much more difficult to collect poll tax than stable, prosperous Tory areas. They'll have to spend more on collecting the tax, and to write off more of it as irrecoverable. Yet they'll get no compensation for that from central government.

• The system is biased towards cuts.

Since poll tax will be only one-fifth of council's income, to increase spending by 10% a council will have to increase poll tax by 50%. If it cuts spending by 10% it can cut poll tax by 50%. In any case, the government will still have the power to order councils to cut poll tax whatever local voters want.

• Poll tax is a tax on voting.

If your name is on the electoral register, it's on the poll tax register too.

Die no.3: Councils are spending too much, and poll tax will stop them.

In reality, councils everywhere have been forced into damaging cuts by the Tories chopping back central government grants. If the Tories gave back all the cuts they've made since 1979 in money for local councils, then the entire population could be given a year free of rates.

Meanwhile, the Tories are spending enough on Trident nuclear weapons to build 300,000 new council houses. And they have given £3 billion a year in tax cuts to the rich.

ie no.4: The poll tax is better than rates.

Under the rates system there is at least a rough relationship between income and what you pay: poor people live in smaller flats or houses, with lower rates, and rich people live in bigger houses, with higher rates. Under the poll tax, there is no relationship between income and the poll tax to be paid.

Rates are easier to collect than the poll tax. They are a tax on property, and property doesn't move. The poll tax is a tax on people, and they move - a lot. 800,000 people move home in Scotland every year. 34% of 18-24 year olds in Scotland have at least three addresses during those years. Difficulties in collecting the poll tax will mean a higher poll tax which will mean a still bigger burden on the less well-off.

Scan page 9

ommunity-based struggles

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 394–395: How to Beat the Poll Tax

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →